Subtitles section Play video
(APPLAUSE)
Well, thank you so much for that.
Thank you so much for inviting me back to the Opera House.
I remember the first time I spoke here,
I thought, "This is definitely going to be the last time,"
but it's now, I think, even my fourth time here,
so it's an incredibly generous gesture on the part
not only of the Opera House
but also of the whole city of Sydney.
I can't thank you enough.
What I want to talk about today is my new book
and the themes that underlie it,
and I guess it's worth saying that throughout my career,
I've been in search of guidance.
I don't believe that the business of living
is very obvious.
It's not very obvious to me.
On a daily basis, I'm reminded of how little I know
and how things are extremely complicated
and don't necessarily have easy answers.
And this has led me to look in a number of different areas
for what I could broadly call wisdom.
I've looked at the world of philosophy.
I've looked at the world of literature,
of art, of sociology,
and then a few years ago, I began to be interested
in the field of religion.
Now, this surprised me as much as anyone else
because I didn't happen to believe anything,
and still don't believe anything,
and in our society, we assume, naturally,
that those who don't believe
won't really care very much for religion
and won't be able to see anything in it,
but I suppose my whole argument is
that that's perhaps not entirely true.
One of the major divisions of the world nowadays
is between those who believe and those who don't,
between atheists, or agnostics, and believers,
and for about the last, I would say, 10 years or so,
it's been relatively clear, in the minds of many,
what being an atheist means.
Being an atheist means someone
who not only believes that God doesn't exist,
but it also means someone
who thinks that anyone who believes that God does exist
is a simpleton.
(LAUGHTER)
Or an idiot, to put it more politely.
So, in other words,
a rather virulent kind of atheism stalks the land
that essentially believes
that there is something quite wrong with believers.
They are not simply making another choice.
They made very much the wrong choice
and need their errors pointed out to them
in intellectual ways.
They've made an intellectual error,
and therefore, they need an intellectual corrective.
I've got a few quibbles with this,
and my approach is slightly different.
I don't believe
that the question of God's existence or non-existence
is the most interesting one in this topic.
In fact, I think it's incredibly boring and sterile,
because one never really makes any headway.
You know, on the one hand, you've got the believers,
who think the atheists are going to hell,
and on the other hand, you've got the atheists,
who think that the believers are rather stupid,
and that kind of divide is, for me, painful and sad,
and I don't really want to dwell on it.
So I'm taking a different road.
For me, I am an atheist, and so I want to begin, really, now
with something which may surprise you,
and if you feel very strongly about it,
please make your ways to the exit,
and I won't hold any grudges,
but, you know, let's be honest with each other.
I don't think God exists.
Now, let's move on.
-(LAUGHTER) -If we can.
I think that's the end of the matter.
-Now, the greater question is... -(LAUGHTER)
..where...
The greater question is, where are we gonna go from here?
Now we've settled that question, where are we gonna go from here?
How are we going to live a good life? How is our society...
How are our societies to be managed
with that insight in mind?
And I suppose I'm writing for someone
who's a little bit like me, who thinks something like this.
I don't believe in the doctrines of religion,
but I do like singing Christmas carols,
and I quite like some of the passages of the Old Testament,
and I love the music of Bach,
and there's something about Zen Buddhist temples,
and there's something about the moral structure
that you find in certain religions, etc, etc.
You know the sort of person - someone who cannot believe
but is attracted to aspects of religion.
Now, for too long, the choice has been either
you sign up to all the doctrines,
involving many supernatural incidents, etc,
and then you get all those nice bits,
or you find you can't sign up to these doctrines,
and then you're left in a sort of wasteland,
where there's a lot that isn't really attended to.
I want to suggest a different strategy.
I want to suggest it not just for myself
but, as it were, for our own times,
and that's a strategy of stealing from religions,
that atheists should learn to inform themselves
about what religions are up to
and then selectively steal the best bits.
Now, this has been described to me sometimes
as a bit of a pick-and-mix approach,
and the truth is, that's exactly what it is,
and I'm very, very proud of pick-and-mix
when it comes to religion.
Some people say, you know,
I've rifled through the buffet of religions.
Well, that's great. I think that religions are a buffet.
They lie before us, and a lot of what you might put on your plate
is, to my eyes, not that appetising.
But there are some really lovely bits,
so I'm gonna go round with my plate
around some major religions and pick the nicest bits,
in my eyes.
That is my overt strategy.
I don't mean to offend,
but I think that if you'd believe, as I do,
that religions are essentially cultural products,
that they were made by humans,
then there seems to be nothing wrong with choosing among them
like one would with any work of culture.
I mean, imagine... Take music.
You know, imagine you like the Beatles,
and somebody said, "Oh, right, you like the Beatles,
"so I hope you're committed to the Beatles
"and will listen to every single track
"and never deviate and make no time for,
"you know, "Robbie Williams,
"because, really, you must stick to the Beatles,"
that would seem bizarre.
We naturally rifle through the buffet of cultures,
be it in music or in literature -
you can go from a bit of Jane Austen to a bit of Shakespeare
to a bit of James Joyce, and that's allowed.
You can create a playlist.
And that's what I want to suggest
that contemporary society can do as regards religion too.
So, what I want to do tonight is take you through the buffet
and show you the bits that I'm picking.
You may want to pick out other bits.
What I'm trying to show you is a method, and...
'Cause I think at the end of the day,
the method is more important than particular choices, but...
Let me take you through some of these choices.
So one area that I think religions are fascinating in
is the area of education.
Now, education is something that the secular world
prides itself on taking very seriously.
Huge amounts of money are devoted to education, and...
Now, the question is, what is education for?
Well, when politicians talk about it,
the prime explanation is that education will provide us
with the skills necessary to take up a place
in modern capitalism.
So education will give us technical and business skills
to make our societies richer and safer.
But there's another claim that you often hear made
on behalf of modern education,
and you sometimes catch it during the more lyrical moments
of politicians' speeches