Subtitles section Play video Print subtitles What's going on guys, Carshmeckle here and the latest episode of Game of Thrones was a nice little cool down we got from last week's epic "Hold the Door" episode. While I did enjoy it I did feel that certain scenes went on a little too long and that the ending was slightly unnecessary. The one thing I started this notice about this season and I'm sure some of you will agree with me is that these episodes are way too short for a normal Thrones season. Way too short. This episode clocked in at about 50 minutes minus the intro and outro songs and I find this to be a major problem especially considering a lot of the scenes we've gotten recently could've had more substance to them. This wouldn't be a major problem if the show's premiere and finale were over an hour and thirty minutes but so far that doesn't seem like it'll be the case. But this episode, as I said, had its moments and did surprise me in terms of progress for some story lines and some people have commented on how this is the first episode without anybody dying, minus flashbacks and plays of course. Comment section back me up on this if its true. Now with all that out of the way lets get on to it. First lets start with Bran, Meera and the return of uncle Benjen. Yes hes finally back and ready to kick ass with his flail that can catch on fire which I thought was really cool. I don't know about you guys but I'm always happy when we get to see these awesome medieval weapons that we haven't seen yet on the show and I love when they're used in cool and interesting ways. Bran's scenes this time around were short and a little spazzy with the visions but also pretty good. Spazzy because they moved by so fast and you'd literally have to re-wind multiple times or have a nice quick finger to pause at the right time to catch some sort of glimpse a key pivotal moments in the Thrones lore. Some people were complaining about the it not fitting with the tune of the scene but I did enjoy it. In the ever so often Hollywood fashion all hope is lost when Meera is running away from the cave and then Benjen comes and saves them and you automatically knew it was Benjen because who else could it be. Now this is where the controversy begins: It's been public for a while now that Coldhands, the mysterious figure beyond the wall that helps Bran's party in the books is not Benjen. How do we know? well because George Martin's editor asked him about in and he said no. Here is the picture now. Some people speculate that George was just lying to his editor to get her to stop asking him questions and others believe that Coldhands and Benjen are two completely different people but the show didn't want to try and introduce new characters beyond the wall so they said fuck it and merged the two. My belief is that Coldhands, in the books, is Benjen but George is doing one of those things where hes saying that the Benjen we knew is long gone and that this person is someone else entirely different but has the appearance of Benjen. Like...it's the Benjen we know but because hes been dead I guess hes just a changed person so George is referring to him being someone else. Like what happened with Arya. The Arya Stark we knew is gone but in her place is "No One". Yeah I think hes doing something like that but to the review: Benjen comes in and saves them just in time, of course and we find out that the Raven isn't exactly a person but a title. When he told Bran it was time for him to become "me" I guess he meant his job. Its time for Bran to become what he was all this time. It seems the mantle of the Three Eyed Raven has been passed down to Bran and with it a lot of knowledge. We also learn that in order to stop someone from turning into a wight you'd need to infuse them with obsidian, much like the ritual to make the Walkers in the first place but something has been bugging me for quite a while...why did Benjen lead a ranging party to find the Walkers? and why did the Children of the Forrest save just him and where was he throughout the entire events in season 4 when Bran was heading to the cave? I hope these questions are answered but overall I did enjoy the Bran scenes this time around and I really did like the return of Benjen and something tells me that when he starts to lead Bran back to the Wall he he may not follow them through it, which is a shame because having an undead Stark on their team is every Bolton's worst nightmare. Moving on to Sam and Gilly and oh look....I have said that without throwing up in my mouth. No no this time Sam & Gilly actually don't suck and I really did enjoy it mainly because of his family. That shot of Horn Hill when they're coming in on the horses was beautiful, I love how it kinda looks like the Parthenon in Greece but what really stole the scenes for me was James Faulkner as Randyl Tarly. Faulkner as Randyl is turning out to be one of the best casting choices the show has made in quite a while. He joins the ranks of Charles Dance as Tywin and Sean Bean as Ned Stark in this regard. Its almost like he was born to play that role. The silent treatment at dinner, the cold stare and the brutal remarks. Anybody whose had a shitty father figure in their life knows how that feels and I'm sure that hit home for a lot of you guys watching. Men and women. While a lot of you guys said that it could've been cut down? I'd disagree and would say that every scene with them was necessary and I wasn't bored by it. I did like seeing Gilly in something other than dish rags and Sam's family seemed quite nice. I will say it was kind of shitty foreshadowing for them to write in Randyl's lines towards the of dinner: "Sam you're a fat bitch. By the way that sword over there? its valyrian steel and no longer yours so fuck you and get out". It was a little obvious that Sam would've taken it and I can't wait to see his face when he sees that it's gone. But At this point, however, I can't see where Sam & Gilly are going to next considering he'll be on the run from his father but I'm actually excited to see how that'll play out. Hopefully he starts his training in OldTown by the end of this season. But like I said, I did enjoy Sam & Gilly this episode and I hope they continue to be interesting and meet new characters along the way that allow Sam's character to shine. Moving on to King's Landing which I thought could've been cut down a little and I wasn't really invested in it this time around as much as I wanted to be. Seeing Margaery being all religious is definitely weird but at the same time I know it's all an act to help get her brother out of there. I like that we finally get to see the Tyrell army and their unique armor, which every house already has, but they ended up doing nothing which disappointed the hell out of me. Not only that but Tommen is turning out to be the new Olly because holy shit kid...you fucking suck but I think there is a reason behind it this time which I will get into in a minute. What I mostly found fucked up in this episode was Jaime being let go of the Kingsguard by Tommen because we all know how much it meant to him. In season 4 Jaime declines being the Lord of Casterly Rock mainly because he wanted to do his best at his current position. He wants to fill the white book of brothers with heroic deeds and accomplishments while he was still a Kingsguard and it's sad to see that it can't happen anymore and I feel for Jaime because he doesn't deserve this but I think hes just a casualty of a bigger plan. As for the High Sparrow, he is shaping up to be a great character and player in the King's Landing political arena but at the same time I feel like the show is executing this a little late in the season. While I love Jonathan Pryce as the High Sparrow I feel like his character is just being used to lengthen the King's Landing scenes with speech after speech after speech. What I did like, however, is by sparing Margaery he sent the biggest fuck you to Cersei by not letting her do the walk of atonement. He was also able to get Tommen and the Kingsguard on his side but I think there is more to this and follow me here...if done correctly? this'll be the biggest comeback we've ever seen from Cersei. There was a scene several episodes back when Tommen and Cersei have a discussion in private and we never get to see what the contents are about. My theory here is that Cersei and Tommen are playing the High Sparrow by letting him think hes converted Tommen and the Kingsguard over to the Faith and just then, in that moment, when his guard is down and he thinks hes pulled one over on Cersei? she comes back at him in full force and annihilates all of them. As for Jaime being let go of the Kingsguard? well that was needed so the High Sparrow can feel like hes won. It should all be about making the enemy feel like they have the upper hand and then swiftly pulling the rug from under them for a deadly strike. Personally if I was on the show's writing team? that's what I would do. Make the audience think that the tiring old troupe of Tommen being a weak, naive little push over was happening again and in the end? we come to see that he isn't naive but he was playing the game. The audience has come to expect Tommen to be such a wimp at this point so I hope the show runners surprise us in the end by all this being Cersei's master plan and Tommen is in on it and assisting her with it. And the reason I think this is Cersei's master plan is mainly because...when Jaime was removed from Kingsguard and he was telling her how the High Sparrow has his claws in Tommen? she kept a calm and collective head. She also actively encouraged Jaime to go to the Riverlands and secure Riverrun for a certain reason which I won't go into right now considering its very spoilery but Cersei just seemed way too cool with all of this and I wouldn't be too surprised if she'll end up getting her revenge and the episode playing out with the rains of castamere like it always does. Now I forget who said this but I agree with the statement that...It's nice to see Masie Williams actually do something on the show than repeat the same lines over and over again. In Bravos Arya doesn't go through with the assassination of Lady Crane and I want to call your attention to something that I didn't notice in my first view of the episode. When Arya and Lady Crane were talking about how the Queen would've reacted completely different I kept thinking "Arya knows Cersei so well" but I was wrong. When Arya was giving the actress her thoughts on what would've really happened.... she wasn't talking about Cersei she was talking about herself and that really hit home for me. She was talking about how much she loved her father, and how she never got to say goodbye and how she wouldn't cry but she'd want to kill all the people who did those things to her. That's the moment when she realized she could never truely be "No One" and you could tell. Soon after this the Waif notices that Arya doesn't go through with it and reports back to Jaqen who orders Arya to be taken cared of. Now heres the thing: Jaqen's not an idiot. Even though he follows the assassin's creed and way of life he also knows Arya quite well considering he was the one conversing with her about the target and sensed she had some reservation to killing Lady Crane. My theory here is that Jaqen sent her on that mission knowing fully well that she wouldn't be able to go through with it all to give Arya her final test. Survive the Waif who, in my opinion, has grown a little too cocky for her own good. I think this is further backed by Jaqen saying "make sure she doesn't suffer" when he knows fully well that the Waif doesn't like Arya and hasn't from the very beginning. My guess is that Arya will either kill the Waif and escape Bravos back to Westeros or after she kills the Waif, Jaqen will come out of nowhere and congratulate on passing the test. I can't see Arya being killed off by the Faceless Men so easily but then again they're good at what they do so it's not impossible. For those of you a little frustrated that Arya's time as an assassin was too brief and the pacing was a bit off? please check out the books where they go into much detail about it and even offers some surprises on her character. And no I'm not trying to be some kind of jerk trying to sell you something but I feel like her time in the House of Black & White was a little too short for it to end as her being a rogue this quickly. But regardless, I really did enjoy the Arya stuff this episode, I love Maise Williams, she is an amazing actress and I'm really excited to see where this will go and how their confrontation will play out. And before we get to Dany lets check over with Walder Frey. Now It was a very short scene but its main purpose is to set up the return of Blackfish Tully taking back Riverrun. For those of you who don't remember Bryden Tully, also known as the Blackfish is the uncle of Catelyn and Edmure Tully and hes been missing ever since the Red Wedding. In the show it's been about a year since the Red Wedding took place but we, the audience,