Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Welcome back folks! Before we go on with our show, let me introduce you, to our second guest, Martha Nussbaum!!

  • She is an American philosopher,

  • with a particular interest in political philosophy, feminism,

  • and ethics,

  • including animal rights she is the professor of law and ethics at the

  • including animal rights. at the University of Chicago.

  • And, author of several books

  • Including,

  • , "Liberty of Conscience", and "Not for Profit:".

  • Without further ado,

  • let's welcome! Martha Nussbaum!!

  • Martha, welcome to our show, Speak Out Loud!

  • It's great to be here!!

  • Before we proceed,

  • I want to ask something to Taslima! There seems to be a conflict between,

  • feminism,

  • one supporting,

  • the ban of burkha,

  • and the other opposing it.

  • I will take your comments, right after these two videos.

  • i..i believe that burkha or Islamic veil is a

  • sign of

  • oppression.

  • So, I

  • of course,

  • do not advice any women

  • to wear this.

  • But, of course some feminist

  • says that, they have rights to

  • wear it, I don't call them feminist.

  • You know, of course some feminist,

  • I don't actually

  • like to call them feminist. Because

  • uh.. They think that,

  • they should be treated as sexual object.

  • And the

  • uh...

  • then they don't know, they do not believe in

  • equality to men

  • and women

  • What's your comment?

  • I will stick with my statement!

  • Do you know, Martha is a feminist,

  • who is against

  • banning of burkha?

  • Yes, she is one of those so called feminist!!

  • It is easier said than done

  • Anyways!

  • Martha, you have an article in New York Times, defending burkha.

  • Even though not being a Muslim.

  • What is your reason behind the article!? Andrew,

  • do you know?

  • France is the first country in Europe, to publicly ban burkha?

  • and some region In Germany, forbids public school

  • to wear burkha on the job.

  • Although, the nuns and priests, are permitted to dress according to their

  • religious belief!. Why are there two sets of rule ?

  • do we treat all citizens with equal respects

  • Do we treat, all citizens with equal respects? My article is about,

  • disproving the banning of burkha. Martha, it is a matter of national security.

  • In public place,

  • people are required to show their face.

  • I agree! And burkha also make transparency difficult.

  • Then, why doesn't it apply to everyone ?

  • For example, in cold weather, when we walk, we pull down our hats

  • over our, ears and eyebrows

  • we tighten up our scarf

  • around our necks. Now

  • tell me

  • there isn't any problem of either transparency or security. What inspires

  • fear, and mistrust, clearly is not covering in general!!, but only Muslim

  • covering?

  • You do not know, what burkha is?

  • Let me tell you a little bit about my life, I was born in 1962

  • to a Muslim family in a small town called Mymensingh Taslima!, enough with your

  • story, please!

  • Come to the point.

  • My point is, burkha is a symbol of male domination

  • that objectifies women.

  • Andrew,

  • frankly,

  • no offence to Taslima!!

  • People who make these argument, Don't know much about Islam, and The most

  • amazing flaw, in that argument is that

  • our society is filled with symbols of male supremacy which treat women as

  • objects.

  • Such as Sex magazines,

  • Nude photos,

  • tight jeans, high hills, plastic surgery, our media culture? Is not much of this

  • done,

  • to satisfy men? Aren't these objectifying women ?

  • True, there's no point in denying it? Supporters of the banning of burkha, even participate in them.

  • Instead of protesting.

  • Both, burkha and sexism,

  • dehumanize women to mere sexual objects.

  • Let's say, someone force you to wear bikini,

  • just to make you look good, and get benefit, as used, in advertisement.

  • What do you have to say? This is a pure case of sexism !

  • these people, will treat me as sex object.

  • We should never let these men, take advantage of us.

  • Taslima,

  • now you are contradicting with your own philosophy.

  • How is that?

  • On one hand,

  • you are saying, women shouldn't be treated as sex object , on the other you are

  • doing the same, by opposing against burkha ? You are telling women, how to dress?

  • How to live their life?

  • It's another way of controlling women.

  • And those who support these Are not just going against human rights!,

  • but also violating democracy!

  • If a woman wants to wear burkha, why are we violating their rights, and freedom ?

  • You have a point!

  • Those who truly care about women,

  • always project the real picture,

  • they don't desire the fame or glory ! What do you mean !!??

  • Do you want to say!, I am here, for fame and glory?

  • I never, never wanted to be the center of attention,

  • I am no drama queen, missy

  • What is wrong with you!? I did not say your name, why are you acting like this ?

  • I don't like your tone, Martha,, How could you accuse me of something like this ?

  • Taslima, please sit down! Let's be civilized, there is nothing to be aggressive about!

  • All my life, i supported women.

  • I am the one fighting for their rights?

  • because I care,

  • Do you really care ?

  • Yes, of course!!

  • Then, let's talk about your latest controversy,

  • regarding Sunil Gong go pad die. In twitter you said, Sunil , was for book

  • banning.

  • He sexually harassed you,

  • & many other women.

  • Yes. It must been a tough time for you.

  • Yes, I shared my painful experience!

  • Sunil harassed me,

  • Long back.

  • I had just returned from France, and was putting up at a city hotel.

  • One evening,

  • Sunil came to my room,

  • Along with his friends, for dinner.

  • Once we were done,

  • came the parting hug,

  • Sunil suddenly molested me.

  • I was numb. Didn't know, whether to forgive him ? Or protest ?

  • I suffered from that psychological trauma!

  • He sexually exploited me, and also, many other girls and women.

  • I was a well-established feminist writer, If he did not spare me,

  • then whom did he spares? Even though, Sunil said, that if i had been sexually

  • harassed by him, which must happened long time ago',

  • some media, and some men Try to blame me for 'lying against the saint'!

  • They are definitely angry with me. I must not accuse, a famous male writer of

  • any abuse! Or anything, no matter what ever his crime is!

  • People raise questions,

  • if Sunil did sexually harass you,

  • why were you so silent at that time?

  • Why did not I complain when it happened?

  • As if, if I don't share my painful experience,

  • within a certain time,

  • I should be disqualified.

  • As if, if I complained then, something different could have happened, as if people could

  • have blamed him!

  • And i did mention about, Sunil, in my poem,

  • "Rastar shele , ebong kobi".

  • which was Published in 2002, in my poetry book, "Khali Khali lage".

  • Do you really think,

  • writing a poem, in a poetry book was enough to protest ?? It's not my fault,

  • If media didn't notice then, but notice now I am pretty sure media had better things

  • to do,

  • rather than reading your awful poems.

  • Taslima,

  • No hard feelings!! Don't worry, we did experienced it , few minutes ago ,

  • she read Masturbation!

  • What? She did Masturbation?? No! No! She read her poem Masturbation!! Ha, ha ,hah, anyway ,

  • apart from all those

  • jokes! , Taslima,

  • You have gone through, so many interviews,