Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • - [Narrator] When people clock into work,

  • economists are watching.

  • Going back to the 1950s,

  • the change in the number of hours people work

  • has been a warning sign.

  • Before almost every recession,

  • that number has dropped,

  • and today it's happening again.

  • - The average number of hours worked each week

  • has declined from pretty high levels to 2019 levels

  • and even maybe a little bit below.

  • - [Narrator] But this time,

  • economists aren't so sure

  • this dip means the U.S. is headed for a recession.

  • Here's why hours worked is a recession indicator,

  • and why this slowdown could be different.

  • Hours worked is basically what it sounds like,

  • the amount of hours per week

  • that private sector employees punch in.

  • Since businesses are more likely to adjust hours

  • before hiring or laying off workers,

  • these changes can signal increases or decreases

  • in overall economic activity.

  • - But if the consumers are spending less,

  • spending less, spending less,

  • companies are gonna start to feel that pressure.

  • They're going to first start to cut hours,

  • if they have that ability,

  • because they don't really wanna cut workers.

  • - [Narrator] Economists have been looking at it for decades.

  • A scholar in the 1980s

  • said cutting hours in manufacturing

  • was so cyclically consistent

  • that it was a major leading indicator.

  • But despite this history,

  • some think this usually reliable recession indicator

  • could be a false alarm this time

  • because unusual post-pandemic factors are at work.

  • Today in the private sector,

  • manufacturing, transportation, construction,

  • retail and hospitality working hours are going down.

  • The overall average declined to about 34 hours in May.

  • That's down from a peak of 35 hours in January, 2021,

  • and is below the 2019 average before the pandemic.

  • - It's hard to argue

  • that the economy is struggling at this current moment.

  • The concern, and I guess

  • which is always the million dollar question,

  • is why can't you predict a recession or anything like that?

  • And that's because the turning point,

  • it happens very fast.

  • - [Narrator] Growth has begun to slow

  • or turn negative by one measure,

  • and some employers may be responding by cutting hours,

  • like engine company American Fleet.

  • - They had a huge overtime bill in 2021 and 2022.

  • They were just like,

  • were flooded with so much demand they couldn't keep up,

  • and now they've cut all those overtime hours

  • and they're having their workers

  • do sort of like random other stuff

  • and preparing for business to pick up again.

  • But yeah, no overtime hours anymore.

  • - [Narrator] The company said it isn't planning layoffs

  • and it'd do everything it could to keep workers.

  • And other employers are cutting regular hours too.

  • In June, the number of part-time workers

  • who want to work full-time jumped 452,000,

  • the biggest increase in three years.

  • - First thing they're gonna do is kinda cut back hiring,

  • and cut back hiring may necessarily

  • also be cutting back available opportunities

  • for part-time work.

  • And then the next piece would be cutting back hours

  • within the employees that work there already.

  • And then the final piece is letting them go.

  • - But while employers are cutting hours,

  • they're also adding workers,

  • something they don't usually do when layoffs are ahead.

  • In the first 1/2 of this year,

  • U.S. employers added an average of 278,000 jobs each month.

  • And in May, there were 14% fewer layoffs

  • than in the average month in 2019.

  • - This has been the toughest hiring environment

  • we've ever seen,

  • and we do not wanna be laying people off.

  • Nah, we're just gonna hang onto them and ride through this.

  • - [Narrator] By riding out tough times with more employees,

  • economists think workers can stop overworking

  • and return to manageable hours.

  • And one study from Washington University in St. louis

  • suggests many people are working less

  • because they want to.

  • - Maybe expectations about jobs have changed,

  • expectations about work-life balance,

  • working from home.

  • I think those are conversations

  • that we're still trying to work out in the labor market.

  • - [Narrator] Taking the post pandemic factors into account,

  • the hours worked indicator may defy history this time.

  • - Those make it seem

  • that the decline we're seeing right now

  • is maybe not as ominous as it would normally be.

  • (bright music)

- [Narrator] When people clock into work,

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it