Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Are ordinary people able to do terrible things?  

  • And if so, how many would give a strong  electric shock to an innocent other,  

  • just because they are following an orderTo answer these questions, we can look at  

  • the controversial work of a man who just wanted  to find answers to his family's horrific past.

  • In 1961, Stanley Milgram, a young  psychologist, wanted to find out how  

  • ordinary citizens were able to commit acts of  unspeakable evil in Nazi Germany. His theory:  

  • some people do horrific things because they obey  even the most wicked leaders. To test his theory,  

  • Milgram designed a clever experiment that changed  our understanding of human behavior forever.

  • The Milgram Experiment involved 3 people:  

  • An authority, called the experimenter, who  was dressed in a lab coat to appear powerful.  

  • A volunteer, who was assigned to be the  teacher. And a victim, the so-called student.  

  • The teacher was the test subject, whereas the  experimenter and student were both actors.

  • Following orders, the teacher should test  a student, who is sitting in another room,  

  • by asking them questions. For every  wrong answer the experimenter would  

  • ask the teacher to inflict an electric  shock up to a life threatening 450 volts.

  • Before he began, Milgram asked his colleagues  what they expected the outcome to be.  

  • Almost all of them agreed that only a few of the  volunteers would obey and inflict electric shocks  

  • on innocent others. What do you think? Would  anyone administer shocks higher than 300 volts?

  • Milgram then advertised his experiment as a  "study on memory and learning" at the campus of  

  • Yale university. People signed up without any idea  of what they were really getting themselves into.

  • The experiment began with the volunteers meeting  the other participants. The volunteers then pulled  

  • a card to draw their role. Little did they  know that they could only draw the teacher.  

  • Next, they would be givensample of a light electric shock  

  • in order to experience firsthand what  the others would have to go through.

  • To start, the experimenter and the  teacher were seated in one room,  

  • and the student was strapped  to a chair in an adjacent room.  

  • The Teacher and student were able to  communicate, but not see each other.

  • The experimenter then gave the teacher  a list of questions. The teacher would  

  • then read out the questions and the student  would press a button to indicate a response.  

  • For every false answer, the  teacher would administer a shock,  

  • starting at 15 volts and increasing  in 15-volt increments up to 450

  • What the teacher did not know was that the  student didn't actually receive any shocks.  

  • Instead, a tape recorder was used to play various  responses. In the beginning the teacher would  

  • hear protest, or bangs against the wall. If shocks  would increase the reactions would become louder.  

  • And in case someone would go all the  way, the learner would fall silent.

  • In case the teacher became hesitant and asked  to stop, the experimenter would resort to the  

  • following four prompts. First, he would say:  "Please continue". If that was unsuccessful,  

  • he would go on with: "The experiment requires  that you continue”. Then: "It is absolutely  

  • essential that you continue”. And lastly:  "You have no other choice; you must go on".

  • Along the way, the volunteers displayed signs  of extreme tension such as sweating, trembling,  

  • and even uncontrollable laughing fits. The  experiment would be stopped only after all  

  • four prompts had been used or the maximum  voltage of 450 volts had been given three times.

  • Milgram found that of all participants,  100% gave at least 300 volts and 65%  

  • went all the way to 450 volts. The experiment was  later criticized for being unethical because it  

  • deceived innocent people into performing  what seem to be terrible acts of violence.

  • However, his experiment was  successfully replicated many times,  

  • involving different populations  and leading to similar findings.

  • Milgram himself left us with this to think  about: “It may be that we are puppets - puppets  

  • controlled by the strings of society. But  at least we are puppets with perception,  

  • with awareness. And perhaps our awareness  is the first step to our liberation.”

  • What do you think? Would you follow or  question the orders if you were one of  

  • Milgram's participants? And what can we as  a society teach future generations to help  

  • prevent horrific acts that can happen when  ordinary people blindly follow an authority?  

  • Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.

  • This and all other Sprouts' videos are  licensed under the Creative Commons.  

  • That means teachers from all around the world  can use them in classrooms, online courses or 

  • to start projects - and  today, thousands already do!

  • To learn how it works and  download this video without  

  • Ads or background music, checkout our  website or read the description below.

  • If you want to support our  mission and help change education 

  • visit our Patreon - that's patreon.com/sprouts.

Are ordinary people able to do terrible things?  

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it