Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • In Dostoevsky's /The Brother's Karamazov/, he warns us to be careful of the ideas we

  • plant in others, because the ideas we plant in others can tilt them towards being a better

  • person or a worse one, and whether people move towards a better or worse version of

  • themselves has a profound impact on the world we all collectively live in.

  • And how do the ideas we plant in others impact the world we live in?

  • Dostoevsky wrote, “all is like an ocean, all flows and connects; touch it in one place

  • and it echoes at the other end of the world.”

  • Everything is connected, and all life depends on other life.

  • So the quality of the world we live in depends on the quality of our relationships, and the

  • quality of our relationships depends on how we treat each other, and how we treat each

  • other depends on what we believe, and what we believe is based on our experiences with

  • each other, and our experiences with each other determine what kind of seeds we plant

  • in one another.

  • So the seeds we plant in each other play a critical role in determining the kind of world

  • we will live in.

  • And what kinds of worlds can we live in?

  • In the final analysis, I think there are only two worlds we can ultimately move towards:

  • a world of division or a world of unification, a world of power or a world of love, a world

  • of deadly competition or a world of liberating cooperation.

  • Let's take a look at the first world: the world of division.

  • What exactly is it?

  • Imagine a world where every exchange you have with others is unfair.

  • In this world, people lie, steal, cheat, and take advantage of you to get ahead.

  • What do you think is gonna happen to you in this world?

  • I'll tell you.

  • Your trust in other people will start to erode, because bad seeds have been planted inside

  • of you, and now you're nurturing them.

  • And as you nurture these seeds, you'll start to take advantage of other people too, and

  • as you take advantage of others, you'll teach them to do the same.

  • And so you'll plant bad seeds in them which they might nurture and pass on.

  • And this process creates a downward spiral.

  • Everyone begins developing mistrust for one another and living in a selfish way, since

  • living honestly only means you'll get taken advantage of.

  • And as everyone becomes more divided, the world gets progressively worse for everyone,

  • until the game becomes a pure struggle for power: everyone is divided against everyone

  • else.

  • Everyone is in constant fear, looking over their shoulders, expecting to be attacked,

  • taken advantage of, or betrayed, and peace becomes relatively rare, as life becomes a

  • war for survival.

  • But how does that compare to the second world: the world of unification?

  • Imagine a world where every exchange you have with others is fair.

  • In this world, people make honest trades with you and support your growth, and no one tries

  • to benefit at your expense.

  • What do you think is gonna happen to you in this world?

  • I'll tell you.

  • Your trust in other people will increase, because good seeds have been planted inside

  • of you, and now you're nurturing those.

  • And as you nurture those seeds, you begin to trade more fairly with others, and as you

  • trade more fairly with others, you teach them to do the same, and so you plant good seeds

  • in them.

  • And this entire process creates an upward spiral.

  • Everyone develops a greater trust in each other, and they live in a more honest way,

  • since living honestly increases their freedom.

  • And as everyone becomes more unified, the world gets progressively better for everyone,

  • until the world becomes a pure expression of love: everyone unified with everyone else.

  • No one has fear, because they completely trust one another, and peace becomes the norm.

  • So what determines whether we move reality towards unification or division?

  • The seeds we plant in each other and the ones we nurture in ourselves.

  • And how do we go about planting good seeds in others and nurturing them in ourselves?

  • It all comes down to how you get what you want from others and how you allow them to

  • get what they want from you.

  • And there are really only two ways to get what we want from others.

  • As Dostoevsky wrote, “'Shall I take it by force, or by humble love?'”

  • The first strategy to get what you want out of life is force.

  • If you use force as a strategy, you don't really care what the other person wants.

  • You're only interested in getting what you want from others, whatever the cost may be.

  • You'll take advantage of people's trust to get ahead in life, and so every interaction

  • you have with others will plant a bad seed in them, because you will undermine their

  • trust in the world.

  • And as a person's trust in the world decreases, they start to live more selfishly, and so

  • the world moves towards greater division.

  • The second strategy to get what you want out of life is humble love.

  • If you use love as a strategy, you're always interested in what the other person wants.

  • You're interested in making fair trades with others, and only getting what you want

  • by benefitting the other person too.

  • You never take advantage of people's trust to get ahead in life, and so every interaction

  • you have with others will plant a good seed in them, because you build up their trust

  • in the world.

  • And as a person's trust in the world increases, they start to live in a more cooperative way,

  • and so the world moves towards greater unification.

  • So in the end, you have two strategies you can use to get what you want out of life:

  • love or force.

  • And the strategy you use will determine what kind of seeds you plant in others.

  • And it will be up to each of us to tend the gardens of our own minds and choose which

  • seeds to nurture.

  • How will we allow others to get what they want from us?

  • Through force or love?

  • And this combination of planting seeds in one another and nurturing the seeds we're

  • given will determine the reality we live.

  • So what strategy will you use: love or force?

  • And where do you wanna go: towards unification or division?

  • That concludes my exploration of Dostoevsky's teaching in /The Brothers Karamazov/.

  • As always, this is just my opinion and understanding of Dostoevsky's teaching, not advice.

  • Feel free to use this information however you like, and if you have a different take

  • on the his words, I'd love to hear your perspective in the comments.

  • If you liked the video, please consider liking the video.

  • And if you're looking for another video to watch after this one, I recommend watching

  • my videoDostoevsky - Don't Become A Slave to Pleasure”.

  • I'll put a link to it in the description below and in the top right

  • of

  • the screen

  • right now.

In Dostoevsky's /The Brother's Karamazov/, he warns us to be careful of the ideas we

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it