Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Transcriber: Ivana Korom Reviewer: Joanna Pietrulewicz

  • OK, as an attorney, as a political commentator,

  • and frankly, as a former White House official,

  • I used to think I knew a lot

  • about how America picks a president.

  • I was wrong, I did not know.

  • And this year,

  • I've been doing some research into some of the fine print

  • and all the different things in our constitution

  • that we never talk about,

  • and I've discovered some legal loopholes

  • that shocked me,

  • I guarantee will shock you,

  • and could determine the way

  • that the presidential election of 2020 turns out.

  • For instance, did you know that under our constitution

  • a presidential candidate could actually lose the popular vote,

  • fail to get a majority in the electoral college,

  • refuse to concede,

  • manipulate hidden mechanisms in our government

  • and still get sworn in as the president of the United States of America?

  • That's a true fact.

  • I know it sounds like some crazy "House of Cards" episode,

  • and I wish it was,

  • because then we could just change the channel,

  • but I just described to you a real-world, real-life possibility

  • that could occur this year, the year I'm talking, in 2020,

  • or in some other year,

  • if we don't fix some of these glitches in our system.

  • So if you think, though,

  • that the American people's choice in a US presidential election

  • should actually be sworn in to become president of the United States,

  • please pay attention to this talk.

  • I'm going to teach you how to stop a coup, OK?

  • Now, where to begin?

  • Alright, how about this:

  • It turns out that one of the main safeguards of US democracy

  • is not in the constitution at all.

  • It's not in the law at all.

  • It's actually just a little tradition, it's a little custom.

  • And yet, this one voluntary gesture

  • is one of the main reasons

  • that you almost never have riots and bloodshed and strife

  • after a US election.

  • What I'm talking about is a concession speech.

  • OK, it's ironic,

  • it's the one speech no presidential candidate ever wants to give,

  • and yet, it is that public address

  • that is most important for the health

  • and the well-being of our nation.

  • It's that speech, you know, when a presidential contender gives,

  • it's after the advisers come and the media tells them,

  • "Look, you're not going to get enough votes

  • to be able to hit that magic number of 270 electoral college votes.

  • You're just not going to get there."

  • At that moment --

  • you don't think about this,

  • but the fate of the entire republic

  • is in the hands of a single politician

  • and their willingness to walk out there

  • and stand in front of their family and stand in front of the cameras

  • and stand in front of the whole nation

  • and say, "I am conceding the race, voluntarily.

  • Thank you to my supporters.

  • The other person has won now, congratulations to them,

  • let's unite behind them, let's move on, let's be one country.

  • God bless America."

  • You've seen it a thousand times.

  • Make no mistake,

  • this is a remarkable tradition in our country.

  • Because at that moment,

  • that candidate still has at her command

  • a nationwide army of campaign activists,

  • of die-hard partisans,

  • tens of thousands of people.

  • They could just as easily take up arms,

  • take to the streets,

  • they could do whatever they want to.

  • But that concession speech instantly demobilizes all of them.

  • It says, "Hey, guys, stand down.

  • Folks, it's over."

  • Moreover, that concession speech

  • helps the tens of millions of people who voted for that person

  • to accept the outcome.

  • Acknowledge the winner, however begrudgingly,

  • and then just get up the next morning,

  • go to work, go to school,

  • maybe disappointed

  • but not disloyal to America's government.

  • And even more importantly,

  • that concession speech has a technical function

  • in that it kind of allows all the other stuff

  • that our constitution requires after the voting,

  • and there are a bunch of steps like,

  • you've got the electoral college that has got to meet,

  • you've got Congress who's got to ratify this thing,

  • you've got an inauguration to be had,

  • all that stuff can just move ahead on automatic pilot

  • because after the concession speech,

  • every subsequent step

  • to either reinstate the president or elevate a new president

  • just happens on a rubber-stamp basis.

  • The constitution requires it, but it's a rubber stamp.

  • But we sometimes forget, candidates do not have to concede.

  • There's nothing that makes them concede.

  • It's just a norm in a year in which nothing is normal.

  • So what if a losing candidate simply refuses to concede?

  • What if there is no concession speech?

  • Well, what could happen might terrify you.

  • I think it should.

  • First, to give you the background,

  • let's make sure we're on the same page,

  • let me give you this analogy.

  • Think about a presidential election as a baseball game.

  • The end of the ninth inning,

  • whoever is ahead wins, whoever is behind loses.

  • That's baseball.

  • But could you imagine a different world

  • in which, in baseball,

  • there were actually 13 innings, or 14 innings, not just nine.

  • But we just had a weird tradition.

  • If you are behind in the ninth inning,

  • you just come out and concede.

  • Alright?

  • So all those other innings don't matter.

  • That's really how the presidential elections work in America.

  • Because the constitution actually spells out

  • two different sets of innings.

  • You've got the popular election process that everybody pays attention to.

  • And then you've got the elite selection process

  • that everybody essentially ignores.

  • But in a close election,

  • if nobody concedes,

  • the second invisible process,

  • these extra innings if you will,

  • they actually matter a whole lot.

  • Let me explain.

  • That first set of innings, popular election,

  • it's what you think about

  • when you think about the presidential election.

  • It's the primaries, the caucuses, the debates,

  • the conventions, it's election night,

  • it's all that stuff.

  • Most of the time, the loser on election night

  • at that point just concedes.

  • Why? "The American people have spoken."

  • All that.

  • But according to the constitution, the game is technically not over.

  • After the cameras go away,

  • after the confetti's swept away,

  • the constitution requires this whole other set of innings.

  • This elite selection process stuff,

  • and this is all behind closed doors,

  • it's among government officials.

  • And this process goes from the end of the vote counting in November,

  • through December all the way and then January.

  • You just never think about it,

  • because for so many generations,

  • these extra innings haven't mattered much

  • because the election-night loser just concedes.

  • So this other stuff is just a formality.

  • Even in 2000,

  • vice president Al Gore gave up

  • as soon as the Supreme Court ordered an end to the vote counting.

  • Gore did not continue the fight into the state legislatures,

  • into the electoral college,

  • into Congress,

  • he didn't try to discredit the results in the press.

  • Frankly, he didn't send his supporters out into the streets

  • with protest signs

  • or pitchforks or long guns.

  • As soon as the court said the vote count is done,

  • he just conceded to George W. Bush.

  • Because that's what we do,

  • that's just kind of how we do things around here.

  • You don't fight in the extra innings.

  • Until maybe 2020,

  • when one major candidate is already saying

  • he may not accept the results of the vote counting.

  • Curse you 2020.

  • So what can happen instead?

  • Instead of conceding,

  • a losing candidate could launch a ferocious fight to grab power anyway.

  • Or to hold onto power anyway.

  • In the courts, yes.

  • But also in the state houses, electoral college, even in Congress.

  • They could file, for instance, dozens of lawsuits

  • attempting to block the counting of millions of, like, mail-in ballots,

  • saying they should all be thrown out, they're all fraudulent.

  • Then, they could demand

  • that the states refuse to certify the election

  • because of all this alleged fraud,

  • or interference from a foreign power.

  • Or the loser's party could send a rival slate of electors

  • to the electoral college or to Congress,

  • and say, "We're the real electors,"

  • and create a whole situation with that.

  • Any of this stuff could create such a mess

  • in the electoral college and the Congress,

  • that the whole matter just winds up in front of the House of Representatives

  • for the first time since the 1800s.

  • Now, here's where it gets totally crazy.

  • If the presidential election winds up in the House of Representatives,

  • they don't have to pay any attention at all to the popular vote

  • or the electoral vote.

  • It's like the election never happened.

  • And then it gets even crazier.

  • The final tally in the House is taken not by delegates

  • but by delegation.

  • In other words,

  • individual congresspeople don't get to vote.

  • It's done by states.

  • Now, get your head wrapped around this.

  • In 2020, the majority of Americans live in blue states,

  • but there are more red states.

  • So there's a possibility

  • that the Republicans in the House of Representatives

  • could just anoint their candidate to be president,

  • even without the popular vote,

  • or a majority in electoral college.

  • That could happen.

  • Now some people would call that outcome

  • a perfectly legal,

  • perfectly constitutional coup

  • against the very idea of majority rule in the United States.

  • That is possible under our constitution,

  • and it can happen this year.

  • So what can you do about it?

  • OK now, keep in mind,

  • if the margin of the victory is so massive,

  • it's truly massive,

  • the losing candidate's political party is going to walk away

  • and just let their leader go down.

  • Nobody is going to risk a constitutional crisis

  • to save somebody who is super unpopular.

  • But if the race is close,

  • all bets are off.

  • And then the fight could continue long past election night.

  • You could be, you know, trying to deal impact

  • this whole other process you never heard of before.

  • You're going to have to be lobbying,

  • protesting, speaking out, contacting lawmakers,

  • a whole other process you've never done before.

  • So landing in this completely unfamiliar scenario,

  • what can you do?

  • How are we supposed to act?

  • What are we supposed to do in this situation?

  • There's basically three things that matter.

  • Number one, get informed.

  • A number of progressive organizations are already working hard

  • to warn Americans about this growing threat to our democracy.

  • Some organizations you could look into and research for yourself:

  • choosedemocracy.us,

  • electiontaskforce.org,

  • protectdemocracy.org,

  • mobilize.us,

  • allamericans.org,

  • civicalliance.com

  • and the Fight Back table at demos.org.

  • All these groups are working on this.

  • Now, on the right, if that's your cup of tea,

  • you could also check out The Heritage Foundation

  • or the Government Accountability Institute.

  • They are focused on voter fraud.

  • But you've got to get informed, no matter what side you're on.

  • Also, number two,

  • you've got to get loud.

  • You've got to get loud.

  • Situation like this, these days, everybody is a media channel.

  • You are the media.

  • So use your own voice.

  • And when you do, my advice:

  • speak to universal American values, not the partisan stuff, OK?

  • Speak to the American values that every American should be down with,

  • no matter what party they're in.

  • The idea that every voter counts

  • and that every vote should be counted,

  • that's an American value, period.

  • The notion that the majority should rule in America,

  • that's an American value.

  • The idea that an incumbent president

  • should concede honorably and graciously

  • and ensure a peaceful transfer of power,

  • rather than trying to use every trick in the book

  • to hang on to power,

  • that's an American value too.

  • If you stick with those values,

  • you're going to be heard by a lot more people

  • and help bring the country together.

  • And lastly, sorry folks, voting is not enough,

  • You're going to have to get active, get involved.

  • You could join and support with your money.

  • Some existing organizations, powerful groups,

  • like the Leadership Conference on Civil Rights,

  • the ACLU,

  • NAACP, Legal Defense Fund,

  • Indivisible, ColorOfChange.org,

  • these groups are going to be fighting in the courts,

  • fighting in Congress,

  • to try to make sure that we have a fair outcome.

  • Those groups could use your help and your donations.

  • But if it gets to the point

  • where you feel

  • that you have to take it to the streets,

  • that you're going to have to go outside

  • and demonstrate and march and protest,

  • please do it peacefully.

  • This is not just philosophy or morality.

  • A lot of studies have shown

  • that it's the peaceful protests

  • that are more successful at challenging these would-be dictators

  • and reversing coup attempts.

  • It's the peaceful ones, why?

  • Because when the protests turn violent,

  • all that chaos and carnage actually chases away supporters.

  • So rather than demonstrations getting bigger,

  • and the protests getting bigger,

  • they start to shrink.

  • Then the government looks reasonable when it cracks down.

  • So it's actually a lot better

  • to follow the guidance of the late great Gene Sharp.

  • Now he has written beautifully and well

  • about how strategically you can roll back a coup

  • just using very smart, very disciplined, very nonviolent protest.

  • And a lot of his best ideas, and people have been influenced by that,

  • are available in a new guidebook called,

  • "Hold the Line."

  • You can look it up,

  • it's called "Hold the Line, The Guide to Defending Democracy."

  • You can get that at holdthelineguide.com.

  • And that can give you a real good framework

  • to move forward in a smart, peaceful way

  • if you feel that you've got to take it to the streets.

  • Now look,

  • I know all this stuff is overwhelming,

  • and I've got to admit, some of these steps may not be enough.

  • A truly rogue president

  • could call on private armed militia

  • to try to intimidate lawmakers into keeping him or her in power.

  • Or they could just abuse their emergency powers

  • and try to stay in office indefinitely.

  • So we've got some real problems in our system.

  • The best way to stop a coup

  • is to update and strengthen our democratic system

  • as soon as this election is over.

  • Maybe we need to rethink, reimagine or just get rid of

  • this whole electoral college, extra inning thing in the first place.

  • I know for sure

  • we've got to do a better job of protecting voter rights,

  • of prosecuting voter intimidation

  • and also making sure we've got the technology

  • that nobody needs to be afraid of voter fraud.

  • These are the steps that we're going to have to take

  • to make sure that we have a democracy and the democracy endures.

  • Because never forget this:

  • in the long sweep of human history,

  • a democratic republic

  • is the rarest form of government on earth.

  • Democracies are fragile.

  • Democracies can fail.

  • And what citizens do or fail to do in a moment of crisis

  • can determine the final fate

  • of government of, by and for the people.

  • So let's do our best, vote, but this time,

  • we've got to stay vigilant and active,

  • even after the ballots have been counted.

  • We've got to stay active all the way through

  • to inauguration day.

  • But I want to say to you,

  • I will support the winner of a free and fair election

  • no matter which candidate wins,

  • and I will oppose any so-called winner

  • who prevails by twisting the process beyond recognition.

  • Because any American should be willing to concede an election,

  • but no American should concede

  • the core principles of democracy itself.

  • Thank you.

Transcriber: Ivana Korom Reviewer: Joanna Pietrulewicz

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it