Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • This is gonna sound like a scam, but I found a way to make extremely small amounts of money online.

  • So, the one that caught my eye here is Pinterest, whichwe all know and love Pinterest.

  • "Determine the topical relatedness between pieces of text", 40 cents.

  • Wait, there's one moreso, this one's "find info from an email" for 3 cents.

  • They're just gonna email me, and then I, like, find info from it?

  • Which seems cool.

  • It turns out, Amazon runs an online marketplace that farms out basic tasks computer programs have a hard time with.

  • It's called Mechanical Turk, named after a robot from the 1700's.

  • But people just call it MTurk.

  • So, what I wanna do now is, Leonard Monteiro will pay me 3 cents to write the prices shown in an image.

  • I'm not totally sure why this is, like, worth-doing money, but, okay, let's do it.

  • It looks like a parking meter?

  • I hope that this is for a good cause somehow, that this is, like, this app is helping people rather than just sending bills to people.

  • So, I feel like on the other end of this task, there's some sort of automated parking meter app, which is weird.

  • But it turns out, stuff like this happens all the time.

  • Nearly every successful AI product has human beings behind it.

  • You just don't see them until you look at the big picture.

  • So, what's going on here?

  • Is there actually an app that claims to read parking meter fines, but it's actually humans doing it?

  • Or, am I helping train their AI and these meters are just hypothetical examples?

  • To figure that out, I asked a resident AI expert James Vincent.

  • So, I did a little Googling here, and, yeah, sorry, Russell, this is not a parking meter at all.

  • This is actually a little gadget you put in supermarkets and you scan barcodes to check the prices.

  • Now, the bigger question is: Why does someone want you to write down all these prices?

  • And I have two answers for you.

  • In the first case, creating training data.

  • Say you want to make a machine vision system that automatically does what you're doing.

  • How does it actually know where to look in the picture?

  • How does it know what thewhat this barcode scanner looks like?

  • To teach it that information, you need to feed it labeled data.

  • You need to get a human to do that labeling, in this case, Russell.

  • He labels the data, it goes into the system, and the system learns what these things look like.

  • Oh, there's so much more!

  • That is how you train an AI system.

  • But, sometimes, these systems, they don't work, right?

  • So, you use case number twowhat's that?

  • Well, that might be where the AI system actually can't do what it says it can do.

  • It might be that there's too much glare in the picture and it can't read the numbers on the screen very well.

  • In those cases, you need to throw the data to someone who has the intelligence to work out what's going on.

  • That's not a machine, that's a human, like Russell.

  • And they will label the data for the machine and return it back to the end user.

  • Sometimes companies are upfront about this, and sometimes they lie about it, too.

  • Sometimes, they will say, "Yes, we've got a whizzy AI system that's doing all this automatically."

  • And, actually, they don't.

  • Turns out that that AI is a lot of low-paid workers on a system like Mechanical Turk, like Russell, providing this data in the background.

  • If you've ever filled out a CAPTCHA, you've probably done some of that work yourself.

  • In theory, those tests are meant to verify that you're human, but Google has started using them to collect data for other products, too.

  • Typing out this blurry word could help the character recognition algorithm in Google Books.

  • These skewed numbers are probably helping confirm an address in Google Street View.

  • The most recent CAPTCHAs ask you to identify all the squares of a picture that have a car in it, at the same time, the Google's Waymo branch is trying to train self-driving cars.

  • Even a simple task like setting a timer with Google Assistant can require an army of contractors manually annotating the data, as a recent "Guardian" investigation showed.

  • Sometimes, users do the labeling themselves.

  • Facebook has some of the best facial recognition data in the world because they already have dozens of pictures of your face.

  • You added them yourself.

  • Multiply that across billions of users, and it's all the data you need to build a facial recognition system, which can then start automatically tagging your friends in the next set of pictures you upload.

  • Suddenly, Facebook has one of the most advanced facial recognition systems in the world, and they didn't have to pay a dime for it.

  • When researchers at Google were trying to build a depth-sensing camera, they went even further.

  • What they really needed were a bunch of videos where mobile cameras explored static space from different angles.

  • But where would they find that?

  • Google downloaded 2,000 mannequin challenge videos, fed them into an algorithm, and a new kind of depth-sensing software was born.

  • Think about it: Every minute, 500 new hours of content are added to YouTube.

  • If you're training an AI, that's a lot of video to draw on.

  • And there are no copyright restrictions on what you can use for training data.

  • The same goes for websites, images, Wikipedia pagesit's all just there for the taking.

  • This has been a huge driving force for the AI boom.

  • These systems need lots of examples to recognize even the most basic patterns.

  • That used to mean months of data entry, but now you can scrape everything you need from the internet in a matter of hours.

  • And the people who made the mannequin challenge videos, they didn't think they were encoding depth information.

  • If the researchers hadn't talked about their training system, it would feel like they'd done it all on their own.

  • The remarkable thing about AI systems is that even though they are built on a foundation of human intelligence,

  • they regularly transcend that and do something that surprises us or goes beyond what we thought was possible.

  • One fantastic example of this is the AlphaGo program, which was designed by DeepMind, which is Google's AI lab here in London.

  • And in 2016 and 2017, it played and beat the human champions of the ancient board game, Go.

  • There's one particularly famous momentit's now known simply as move 37.

  • It was a move that was so unusual, so counter to human expectations, that the match's commentators thought it was a mistake.

  • But it wasn't.

  • It was a beautiful play that completely undermined Lee's match, and led to AlphaGo winning the game.

  • And it was something that humans couldn't teach; it was something that the machine had learned by itself.

  • Yes, it started from a foundation of human intelligence, but it went beyond that.

  • This, I think, is where people get so excited by AI.

  • We're a long, long way away from building computers that are as flexibly intelligent and, sort of, sophisticated as humans,

  • but we can still build algorithms and systems that exceed human intelligence, even in very specific domains.

  • But that's AI at its best.

  • The flip side is when an app needs a description of what's in a photo, and the photo-recognizing algorithm just doesn't work.

  • So you get a human being to fill it in, usually through a post on Mechanical Turk.

  • That's a very old trick, going all the way back to the machine that gave the site its name.

  • The original Mechanical Turk was this guy, a master chess-playing robot, hundreds of years before there was anything we would think of as a computer.

  • The Turk could beat most chess players, playing so well that people thought it was a technological marvel.

  • But, really, it was just a trick.

  • There was a human being inside, hiding under the table and directing the moves from below.

  • It was a human being dressed up as a machine, a trick no one had thought of until then.

  • And as Amazon can tell you, the trick still works.

  • Thanks for watching; I hope you liked the video.

  • If you wanna know more about AI, we did a whole video about, sort of, what these changes look like at a social scale, whether AI's destroying jobs or gonna make everything free.

  • So, you can check that out here or like and subscribe.

This is gonna sound like a scam, but I found a way to make extremely small amounts of money online.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it