Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Look at this painting.

  • It's Saint Francis and Pope Honorius III.

  • You can probably find the monks.

  • It's the hair.

  • This is not just a haircut.

  • The more you look, the more this haircut shows deep religious divides.

  • One style was even lost to time, after being banned by the Roman Catholic Church.

  • The scalp is a statement of faith, but it's also a battleground.

  • Hair's religious rite extends far beyond Christianity.

  • Some Buddhist monks shave their heads and some Orthodox Jews don't shave the corners

  • of their heads.

  • The Catholic monks were known for centuries for their particularly distinctive hairstyle.

  • This haircut, with the center shave, is called a tonsure.

  • It started in the 4th or 5th century.

  • And the most recognizable is the Coronal tonsure,

  • possibly modeled on Jesus' crown of thorns

  • on the cross.

  • It's actually one of three types.

  • The Coronal is the Roman, or Petrine tonsure, after Saint Peter.

  • There's also the Pauline tonsure, named after Saint Paul, and used more commonly in Eastern

  • Orthodoxy.

  • It is a fully shaved head.

  • But in the Dark Ages, there was a third tonsure too.

  • And that's the shape that largely disappeared from the Church.

  • That hairstyle was a visible symbol of diverging faiths and that's the reason that it was banned.

  • When Pope Gregory sent missionaries from Rome to the British Isles in the late 6th century,

  • he found differences between the Roman Catholic Church and Celtic Church.

  • Ones that revealed serious disagreements about religious practice.

  • Celtic Catholicism was out of sync with the Roman Catholic Church.

  • Roman Catholics would later use the differences between them to portray Celtic Catholicism

  • as Pagan or even as an offshoot celebrating the power-hungry magician, Simon Magus.

  • There were concrete disputes.

  • Most importantly, they disagreed on when to celebrate Easter and another significant disagreement

  • was the shape of the tonsure.

  • McCarthy wanted to learn the shape of this tonsure, because it represented the split

  • in the Roman Celtic Churches.

  • He thought the old guesses about its design were wrong.

  • You can't just scroll through photos of 7th century monk haircuts.

  • Figuring out the shape of the tonsure these monks use, is a detective story.

  • It required McCarthy to parse texts like the Book of Kells and records of old letters.

  • From that, he could figure out the shape.

  • These old texts and illustrations only gave

  • McCarthy a view of the front and back of the head.

  • To picture an aerial view, he had to build one.

  • These differences over tonsure were outward signs of a split in the Church.

  • When the Roman Catholic Church took Ireland, they slowly changed its tonsure too.

  • In 664, the king of Northumbria agreed on the Roman Catholic date for Easter and the

  • Roman Catholic tonsure.

  • The change wasn't instant, but over time the triangular tonsure disappeared.

  • Today some monks practice tonsure while others don't.

  • It varies across religion and monastery.

  • In the Roman Catholic Church, clerical tonsure ended in 1972.

  • When it was common, this unusual haircut was a powerful symbol of monastic separation and

  • the Church's power.

  • But it's actually not so strange.

Look at this painting.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it