Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • The presidency of Donald Trump.

  • The man voted "Least Edible" by Cannibal Magazine

  • -six years in a row. -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)

  • -A-- And I know, I honestly know

  • that the prospect of talking about Trump yet again

  • feels exhausting.

  • We're all so tired of him, every room in America

  • should have a sign on the wall that counts

  • the number of minutes that it's been

  • since someone brought up his fucking name.

  • -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING) -But-- But that is the thing.

  • Trump's presidency is like one of his handshakes.

  • It pulls you in, whether you like it or not.

  • He's had so many terrible moments this year,

  • you probably forgot about many of them.

  • Remember when he creepily told the French president's wife

  • -that she was in good shape? -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)

  • Or-- Or when his tacky golf resort was touted

  • on the States Department website?

  • Or, when he shoved the prime minister

  • of Montenegro out of the way, at a NATO event.

  • Look how proud of himself he is!

  • -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING) -Look how proud he is!

  • You should at least have to know that Montenegro is a country

  • before making a move that says, "Suck it, Montenegro."

  • And there were also quieter but no less alarming moments

  • like when he explained how hard he's been fighting

  • to bring "clean coal" back without appearing to understand

  • what that actually is.

  • It's just been announced

  • that a second brand new coal mine

  • where they're going to take out clean coal,

  • meaning they're taking out coal,

  • -they're gonna clean it, -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)

  • is opening in the state of Pennsylvania.

  • -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING) -Listen, is it possible

  • that Trump is well-versed in and is referring to

  • flue gas desulfurization, fluidized bed combustion,

  • and selective catalytic reduction?

  • Sure, it's possible,

  • but let's agree it's considerably more likely

  • that he thinks you just take a bunch of coal

  • and scrub-a-dub it with a big ol' sponge.

  • -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING) -Oh, yeah, that's right.

  • I'm saying the president fundamentally doesn't understand

  • what he's talking about, and you know what that means.

  • -We got him! -(AIR HORN BLARING)

  • -♪ (PRESIDENTIAL THEME SONG PLAYING) ♪ -We got him! We got him!

  • I got him-- wha-- I didn't get him?

  • -Did I not get him? -♪ (MUSIC FLUBS OUT) ♪

  • I thought-- I thought-- I thought we got him.

  • I thought-- I thought we got him that time.

  • Well, that's fair-- okay.

  • What? You think I don't hate myself, too? Alright!

  • -(AUDIENCE CHEERING) -The point is--

  • The point is tonight... let's pull back

  • from the daily Trump-induced chaos

  • and take a look at the norms that his presidency

  • has violated, and not the obvious ones,

  • like the fact that he never released his tax returns,

  • or that his own daughter and son-in-law

  • work in the White House, although, admittedly,

  • I am using the word "work" there so generously

  • that I should be able to deduct it

  • as a charitable donation on my taxes.

  • Or-- Or that instead of putting his assets

  • into a blind trust to help reduce conflicts of interest,

  • he simply showed America

  • that he has many large stacks of paper,

  • presumable containing the sentence

  • "I can't believe I'm getting away with this,"

  • printed 750,000 times.

  • No, instead, we're going to talk about Trump's assault

  • on something even more basic, the norms governing

  • how our leaders engage with us,

  • and how in turn, that affects the way

  • that we engage with one another.

  • It's why even the notion of "getting him"

  • can feel so hopelessly futile.

  • And let's first stipulate that it definitely doesn't help

  • that so often what Trump says is complete nonsense.

  • We often read transcripts of Trump's speeches,

  • and it's something that everyone should actually do

  • once in a while, because when you strip away

  • his blindly confident entertaining delivery

  • and just read his words, it is staggering

  • how incoherent he is.

  • Here is a word-for-word reading of a speech

  • where he talked about the Iran nuclear deal.

  • (MONOTONE VOICE READS ON-SCREEN TEXT)

  • -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING) -(READING CONTINUES)

  • -(AUDIENCE CACKLING) -Holy shit.

  • That is not a functional use of language,

  • that is a drunk driver crashing a pick-up truck

  • -full of alphabet soup. -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)

  • Trump's actual speech patterns

  • sound like when you write a long text

  • by choosing only the predictive text

  • your iPhone suggests for you.

  • Seriously, we wrote a message like that,

  • starting with the words, "the nuclear,"

  • and here is what we got.

  • (MONOTONE VOICE READS ON-SCREEN TEXT)

  • -(AUDIENCE CACKLING) -That makes exactly as much,

  • and potentially more sense, then Trump's speech

  • about the Iran nuclear deal, meaning an iPhone

  • would be a more coherent president of the United States.

  • But with Trump, we are familiar enough

  • with his speech patterns that you get the basic gist

  • of what he's trying to say.

  • The real damage isn't in how he says things,

  • but from three key techniques that he uses to insulate himself

  • from criticism and consequence.

  • And if we are not extremely careful,

  • all three could have serious impacts

  • that far outlast his presidency,

  • and let's start with the first one.

  • Delegitimizing the media.

  • Now, Trump has been attacking the press

  • since he declared his candidacy,

  • and in a broader sense, he's been waging war

  • on the very concept of truth

  • ever since he first turned to his mom and said,

  • "Dada," and she said, "No, I'm mama,"

  • and he said, "Fake news," and shit his pants.

  • -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING) -Now--

  • the difference now is, he's crying fake news

  • as President of the United States,

  • and he is openly proud of it,

  • to the point that he recently tried to take ownership

  • of the term itself.

  • The media is... is-- really the word--

  • I think one of the greatest of all terms

  • I've come up with is "fake."

  • I guess other people have used it perhaps

  • over the years, but I've never noticed it.

  • -(AUDIENCE GROANING) -He just took credit

  • for inventing the term "fake news,"

  • which, for the record, he did not,

  • meaning what he just said

  • was technically "fake" fake "news" news.

  • (AUDIENCE LAUGHING)

  • A-- And you can imagine him saying, "Well,

  • I'm not the first politician to criticize the press.

  • What about Hillary Clinton?

  • What about Barack Obama?

  • What about Bernie Sanders?

  • And that actually brings us to Trump's second technique,

  • something called "whataboutism."

  • It's the practice of changing the subject

  • to someone else's perceived wrongdoing.

  • Now, Trump does this all the time,

  • most famously when he was asked

  • why he hadn't forcefully condemned the neo-Nazis

  • in Charlottesville, and this was his response...

  • What about the alt-left that came charging

  • at the-- as you say, the alt-right?

  • Do they have any semblance of guilt?

  • What about the fact they came charging--

  • that they came charging with clubs in their hands,

  • swinging clubs?

  • Do they have any... problem?

  • Well, actually, no, because a Nazi killing someone

  • with a car is so heinous,

  • any other issues that might be up for debate,

  • under any other circumstances, kind of have to wait their turn.

  • You can be wearing Crocs with socks,

  • but if you're using those socked-Crocs

  • to kick Hitler in the balls, do you know what?

  • I'm suddenly not so fucking focused

  • -on the footwear. -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)

  • Now-- Now this technique of saying "what about..."

  • is actually an old Soviet propaganda tool,

  • and the reason it is dangerous is because it implies

  • that all actions, regardless of context,