Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Now, on nova,

  • Take a thrill ride into a world stranger than science fiction

  • Where you play the game,

  • By breaking some rules,

  • Where a new view of the universe,

  • Pushes you beyond the limits of your wildest imagination.

  • This is the world of string theory,

  • A way of describing every force and all matter

  • From an atom to earth,

  • To the end of the galaxies

  • From the birth of time to its final tick

  • In a single theory,

  • A theory of everything.

  • Our guide to this brave new world is Brian Greene,

  • The bestselling author and physicist.

  • And no matter how many times I come here,

  • I never seem to get used to it.

  • Can he help us solve the greatest puzzle of modern physics

  • That our understanding of the universe

  • Is based on two sets of laws,

  • That don't agree?

  • Resolving that contradiction eluded even Einstein,

  • Who made it his final quest.

  • After decades,

  • We may finally be on the verge of a breakthrough.

  • The solution is strings,

  • Tiny bits of energy vibrating like the strings on a cello,

  • A cosmic symphony at the heart of all reality.

  • But it comes at a price

  • Parallel universes and 11 dimensions,

  • Most of which you've never seen.

  • We really may live in a universe

  • With more dimensions than meet the eye.

  • People who have said that

  • There were extra dimensions of space

  • Have been labeled crackpots,

  • Or people who are bananas.

  • A mirage of science and mathematics

  • Or the ultimate theory of everything?

  • If string theory fails to provide a testable prediction,

  • Then nobody should believe it.

  • Is that a theory of physics, or a philosophy?

  • One thing that is certain

  • Is that string theory is already showing us that

  • The universe may be a lot stranger

  • Than any of us ever imagined.

  • Coming up tonight...

  • It all started with an apple.

  • The triumph of Newton』s equations

  • Come from the quest to understand the planets and the stars.

  • And we've come a long way since.

  • Einstein gave the world a new picture for

  • What the force of gravity actually is.

  • Where he left off,

  • String theorists now dare to go.

  • But how close are they to fulfilling Einstein』s dream?

  • Watch the elegant universe right now.

  • Fifty years ago,

  • This house was the scene

  • Of one of the greatest mysteries of modern science,

  • A mystery so profound that today

  • Thousands of scientists on the cutting edge of physics

  • Are still trying to solve it.

  • Albert Einstein spent his last two decades

  • In this modest home in Princeton, new jersey.

  • And in his second floor study

  • Einstein relentlessly sought a single theory so powerful

  • It would describe all the workings of the universe.

  • Even as he neared the end of his life

  • Einstein kept a notepad close at hand,

  • Furiously trying to come up with the equations

  • For what would come to be known

  • As the "theory of everything."

  • Convinced he was on the verge of the most important discovery

  • In the history of science,

  • Einstein ran out of time, his dream unfulfilled.

  • Now, almost a half century later,

  • Einstein』s goal of unification

  • Combining all the laws of the universe in one,

  • All-encompassing theory

  • Has become the holy grail of modern physics.

  • And we think we may at last achieve Einstein』s dream

  • With a new and radical set of ideas called "string theory."

  • But if this revolutionary theory is right,

  • We're in for quite a shock.

  • String theory says we may be living in a universe

  • Where reality meets science fiction

  • A universe of eleven dimensions

  • With parallel universes right next door

  • An elegant universe composed entirely of the music of strings.

  • But for all its ambition,

  • The basic idea of string theory is surprisingly simple.

  • It says that everything in the universe,

  • From the tiniest particle to the most distant star

  • Is made from one kind of ingredient

  • Unimaginably small vibrating strands of energy called strings.

  • Just as the strings of a cello

  • Can give rise to a rich variety of musical notes,

  • The tiny strings in string theory

  • Vibrate in a multitude of different ways

  • Making up all the constituents of nature.

  • In other words,

  • The universe is like a grand cosmic symphony

  • Resonating with all the various notes

  • These tiny vibrating strands of energy can play.

  • String theory is still in its infancy,

  • But it's already revealing

  • A radically new picture of the universe,

  • One that is both strange and beautiful.

  • But what makes us think we can understand

  • All the complexity of the universe,

  • Let alone reduce it to a single "theory of everything?"

  • We have r mu nu,

  • Minus a half g mu nu r—

  • You remember how this goes

  • Equals eight pi g t mu nu...

  • Comes from varying the Einstein Hilbert action,

  • And we get the field equations and this term.

  • You remember what this is called?

  • No that's the scalar curvature.

  • This is the Ricci tensor.

  • Have you been studying this at all?

  • No matter how hard you try,

  • You can't teach physics to a dog.

  • Their brains just aren't wired to grasp it.

  • But what about us?

  • How do we know that we're wired to

  • Comprehend the deepest laws of the universe?

  • Well, physicists today are confident that we are,

  • And we're picking up where Einstein left off

  • In his quest for unification.

  • Unification would be

  • The formulation of a law that describes,

  • Perhaps, everything in the known universe from

  • One single idea, one master equation.

  • And we think that there might be this master equation,

  • Because throughout the course of the last 200 years or so,

  • Our understanding of the universe

  • Has given us a variety of explanations that are all pointing

  • Towards one spot.

  • They seem to all be converging

  • On one nugget of an idea that we're still trying to find.

  • Unification is where it's at.

  • Unification is what we're trying to accomplish.

  • The whole aim of fundamental physics

  • Is to see more and more of the world's phenomena

  • In terms of fewer and fewer

  • And simpler and simpler principles.

  • We feel, as physicists,

  • That if we can explain

  • A wide number of phenomena

  • In a very simple manner,

  • That that's somehow progress.

  • There is almost an emotional aspect

  • To the way in which the great theories in physics.

  • Sort of encompass

  • A wide variety of apparently different physical phenomena

  • So this idea that

  • We should be aiming to unify our understanding is inherent,

  • Essentially,

  • To the whole way in which this kind of science progresses.

  • And long before Einstein,

  • The quest for unification

  • Began with the most famous accident

  • In the history of science.

  • As the story goes,

  • One day in 1665,

  • A young man was sitting under a tree when,

  • All of a sudden,

  • He saw an apple fall from above.

  • And with the fall of that apple,

  • Newton revolutionized our picture of the universe

  • In an audacious proposal for his time,

  • Newton proclaimed that the force pulling apples to the ground

  • And the force keeping the moon in orbit around the earth

  • Were actually one and the same.

  • In one fell swoop,

  • Newton unified the heavens and the earth

  • In a single theory he called gravity.

  • The unification of the celestial with the terrestrial

  • That the same laws that govern the planets in their motions

  • Govern the tides and the falling of fruit

  • Here on earth

  • It was a fantastic unification of our picture of nature.

  • Gravity was the first force to be understood scientifically,

  • Though three more would eventually follow.

  • And, although Newton discovered his law of gravity

  • More than 300 years ago,

  • His equations describing this force

  • Make such accurate predictions that

  • We still make use of them today.

  • In fact

  • Scientists needed nothing more than Newton』s equations

  • To plot the course of a rocket that landed men on the moon.

  • Yet there was a problem.

  • While his laws

  • Described the strength of gravity with great accuracy,

  • Newton was harboring an embarrassing secret

  • He had no idea how gravity actually works.

  • For nearly 250 years,

  • Scientists were content to look the other way

  • When confronted with this mystery.

  • But in the early 1900s,

  • An unknown clerk working in the Swiss patent office

  • Would change all that.

  • While reviewing patent applications,

  • Albert Einstein was also pondering the behavior of light.

  • And little did Einstein know

  • That his musings on light

  • Would lead him to solve Newton』s mystery

  • Of what gravity is.

  • At the age of 26,

  • Einstein made a startling discovery

  • That the velocity of light is a kind of cosmic speed limit,

  • A speed that nothing in the universe can exceed.

  • But no sooner had the young Einstein published this idea

  • Than he found himself squaring off

  • With the father of gravity.

  • The trouble was,

  • The idea that nothing can go faster than the speed of light

  • Flew in the face of Newton』s picture of gravity.

  • To understand this conflict,

  • We have to run a few experiments.

  • And to begin with,

  • Let's create a cosmic catastrophe.

  • Imagine that all of a sudden,

  • And without any warning,

  • The sun vaporizes and completely disappears.

  • Now, let's replay that catastrophe

  • And see what effect it would have on the planets

  • According to Newton.

  • Newton's theory predicts that with the destruction of the sun

  • The planets would immediately fly out of their orbits

  • Careening off into space.

  • In other words,

  • Newton thought that gravity

  • Was a force that acts instantaneously across any distance.

  • And so we would immediately feel

  • The effect of the sun's destruction.

  • But Einstein saw a big problem with Newton』s theory,

  • A problem that arose from his work with light.

  • Einstein knew light doesn't travel instantaneously.

  • In fact,

  • It takes eight minutes for the sun's rays

  • To travel the 93 million miles to the earth.

  • And since he had shown that nothing,

  • Not even gravity, can travel faster than light,

  • How could the earth be released from orbit

  • Before the darkness resulting from

  • The sun's disappearance reached our eyes?

  • To the young upstart from the Swiss patent office

  • Anything outrunning light was impossible,

  • And that meant

  • The 250-year old Newtonian picture of gravity

  • Was wrong.

  • If Newton is wrong,

  • Then why do the planets stay up?

  • Because remember,

  • The triumph of Newton』s equations come from the quest

  • To understand the planets and stars

  • And particularly the problem of

  • Why the planets have the orbits that they do.

  • And with Newton』s equations

  • You could calculate the way that the planets would move.

  • Einstein's got to resolve this dilemma.

  • In his late twenties,

  • Einstein had to come up with a new picture of the universe

  • In which gravity does not exceed the cosmic speed limit.

  • Still working his day job in the patent office,

  • Einstein embarked on a solitary quest to solve this mystery.

  • After nearly ten years of wracking his brain

  • He found the answer in a new kind of unification.

  • Einstein came to think of the three dimensions of space

  • And the single dimension of time

  • As bound together in a single fabric of "space-time.".

  • It was his hope

  • That by understanding

  • The geometry of this four-dimensional fabric of space-time,

  • That he could simply talk about things

  • Moving along surfaces in this space-time fabric

  • Like the surface of a trampoline,

  • This unified fabric is warped and stretched

  • By heavy objects like planets and stars.

  • And it's this warping or curving of space-time

  • That creates what we feel as gravity.

  • A planet like the earth is kept in orbit,

  • Not because the sun reaches out and

  • Instantaneously grabs hold of it,

  • As in Newton』s theory,

  • But simply because it follows

  • Curves in the spatial fabric

  • Caused by the sun's presence.

  • Let's rerun the cosmic catastrophe.

  • Let's see what happens now if the sun disappears.

  • The gravitational disturbance that results

  • Will form a wave that travels across the spatial fabric

  • In much the same way that

  • A pebble dropped into a pond

  • Makes ripples that travel across the surface of the water.

  • So we wouldn't feel a change in our orbit around the sun

  • Until this wave reached the earth.

  • What's more,

  • Einstein calculated that these ripples of gravity

  • Travel at exactly the speed of light.

  • And so, with this new approach,

  • Einstein resolved the conflict with Newton

  • Over how fast gravity travels.

  • And more than that,

  • Einstein gave the world a new picture

  • for what the force of gravity actually is

  • It's warps and curves in the fabric of space and time.

  • Einstein called this new picture of gravity

  • "general relativity,"

  • And within a few short years

  • Albert Einstein became a household name.

  • Einstein was like a rock star in his day.

  • He was one of the most widely known

  • And recognizable figures alive.

  • He and perhaps Charlie Chaplin

  • Were the reigning kings of the popular media.

  • People followed his work.

  • And they were anticipating...

  • Because of this wonderful thing

  • He had done with general relativity,

  • This recasting the laws of gravity out of his head...

  • There was a thought he could do it again, and they,

  • People want to be in on that.

  • Despite all that he had achieved

  • Einstein wasn't satisfied.

  • He immediately set his sights on an even grander goal,

  • The unification of his new picture of gravity

  • With the only other force known at the time,

  • Electromagnetism.

  • Now electromagnetism is

  • A force that had itself been unified

  • Only a few decades earlier.

  • In the mid-1800s,

  • Electricity and magnetism

  • Were sparking scientists' interest.

  • These two forces seemed to share a curious relationship

  • That inventors like Samuel Morse

  • Were taking advantage of in new fangled devices,

  • Such as the telegraph.

  • An electrical pulse

  • Sent through a telegraph wire to a magnet

  • Thousands of miles away

  • Produced the familiar dots and dashes of Morse code

  • That allowed messages to be transmitted across the continent

  • In a fraction of a second.

  • Although the telegraph was a sensation,

  • The fundamental science driving it

  • Remained something of a mystery.

  • But to a Scottish scientist named James Clark Maxwell,

  • The relationship between electricity and magnetism

  • Was so obvious in nature that it demanded unification.

  • If you've ever been on top of a mountain

  • During a thunderstorm

  • You'll get the idea of

  • How electricity and magnetism are closely related.

  • When a stream of electrically charged particles flows,

  • Like in a bolt of lightning, it creates a magnetic field.

  • And you can see evidence of this on a compass.

  • Obsessed with this relationship,

  • The scot was determined to explain the connection

  • Between electricity and magnetism

  • In the language of mathematics.

  • Casting new light on the subject,

  • Maxwell devised a set of four

  • Elegant mathematical equations

  • that unified electricity and magnetism

  • in a single force called "electromagnetism."

  • And like Newton』s before him,

  • Maxwell's unification took science a step closer

  • To cracking the code of the universe.

  • That was really the remarkable thing,

  • That these different phenomena were really

  • Connected in this way.

  • And it's another example of

  • Diverse phenomena coming from a single underlying

  • Building block or a single underlying principle.

  • Imagine that everything that you can think of

  • Which has to do with electricity and magnetism

  • Can all be written in four very simple equations.

  • Isn't that incredible?

  • Isn't that amazing?

  • I call that elegant.

  • Einstein thought that this was

  • One of the triumphant moments of all of physics

  • And admired Maxwell hugely for what he had done.

  • About 50 years after Maxwell

  • Unified electricity and magnetism,

  • Einstein was confident

  • That if he could unify his new theory of gravity

  • With Maxwell』s electromagnetism,

  • He'd be able to formulate a master equation

  • That could describe everything, the entire universe.

  • Einstein clearly believes

  • That the universe has an overall grand

  • And beautiful pattern to the way that it works.

  • So to answer your question,

  • Why was he looking for the unification?

  • I think the answer is simply

  • That Einstein is one of those physicists

  • Who really wants to know the mind of god,

  • Which means the entire picture.

  • Today, this is the goal of the string theory.

  • To unify our understanding of everything

  • From the birth of the universe

  • To the majestic swirl of galaxies

  • In just one set of principles,

  • One master equation.

  • Newton had unified the heavens and the earth

  • In a theory of gravity.

  • Maxwell had unified electricity and magnetism.

  • Einstein reasoned all that remained

  • To build a "theory of everything"-

  • A single theory

  • That could encompass all the laws of the universe

  • Was to merge his new picture of gravity with electromagnetism.

  • He certainly had motivation.

  • Probably one of them might have been aesthetics,

  • Or this quest to simplify.

  • Another one might have been just the physical fact

  • That it seems like the speed of gravity

  • Is equal to the speed of light.

  • So if they both go at the same speed,

  • Then maybe that's an indication of some underlying symmetry.

  • But as Einstein began

  • Trying to unite gravity and electromagnetism

  • He would find that the difference in strength

  • Between these two forces would outweigh their similarities.

  • Let me show you what I mean.

  • We tend to think that gravity is a powerful force.

  • After all, it's the force that, right now,

  • Is anchoring me to this ledge.

  • But compared to electromagnetism,

  • It's actually terribly feeble.

  • In fact, there's a simple little test to show this.

  • Imagine that I was to leap from this rather tall building.

  • Actually, let's not just imagine it.

  • Let's do it. you'll see what I mean.

  • Now, of course,

  • I really should have been flattened.

  • but the important question's

  • What kept me from crashing through the sidewalk and

  • Hurtling right down to the center of the earth?

  • Well, strange as it sounds,

  • The answer is electromagnetism.

  • Everything we can see,

  • From you and me to the sidewalk,

  • Is made of tiny bits of matter called atoms.

  • And the outer shell of every atom contains

  • A negative electrical charge.

  • So when my atoms collide with the atoms in the cement

  • These electrical charges repel each other with such strength

  • That just a little piece of sidewalk

  • Can resist the entire earth's gravity

  • And stop me from falling.

  • In fact the electromagnetic force

  • Is billions and billions of times stronger than gravity.

  • That seems a little strange,

  • Because gravity keeps our feet to the ground,

  • It keeps the earth going around the sun.

  • But, in actual fact,

  • It manages to do that only because

  • It acts on huge enormous conglomerates of matter,

  • You knowyou, me, the earth, the sun

  • But really at the level of individual atoms,

  • Gravity is a really incredibly feeble tiny force.

  • It would be an uphill battle

  • For Einstein to unify these two forces

  • Of wildly different strengths.

  • And to make matters worse,

  • Barely had he begun

  • Before sweeping changes in the world of physics

  • Would leave him behind.

  • Einstein had achieved so much in the years up to about 1920

  • That he naturally expected that

  • He could go on by playing the same theoretical games

  • And go on achieving great things.,

  • And he couldn't.

  • Nature revealed itself in other ways in the 1920s and 1930s

  • And the particular tricks and tools that

  • Einstein had at his disposal

  • Had been so fabulously successful,

  • Just weren't applicable anymore.

  • You see, in the 1920s

  • A group of young scientists stole the spotlight from Einstein

  • When they came up with an outlandish

  • New way of thinking about physics.

  • Their vision of the universe was so strange,

  • It makes science fiction look tame,

  • And it turned Einstein』s quest for unification on its head.

  • Led by Danish physicist noels boor,

  • These scientists

  • Were uncovering an entirely new realm of the universe.

  • Atoms,

  • Long thought to be the smallest constituents of nature,

  • a found it's consisted a even small parties

  • The now-familiar nucleus of protons and neutrons

  • Orbited by electrons.

  • And the theories of Einstein and Maxwell were useless

  • At explaining the bizarre way these tiny bits of matter

  • Interact with each other inside the atom.

  • There was a tremendous mystery about

  • How to account for all this,

  • How to account for what was happening to the nucleus .

  • As the atom began to be pried apart in different ways

  • And the old theories were

  • Totally inadequate to the task of explaining them.

  • Gravity was irrelevant.

  • It was far too weak.

  • And electricity and magnetism was not sufficient.

  • Without a theory to explain this strange new world,

  • These scientists were lost in an unfamiliar atomic territory

  • Looking for any recognizable landmarks.

  • Then, in the late 1920s,

  • All that changed.

  • During those years,

  • Physicists developed a new theory

  • Called "quantum mechanics,"

  • And it was able to describe the microscopic realm

  • With great success.

  • but here is the thing

  • Quantum mechanics was so radical a theory

  • That it completely shattered

  • All previous ways of looking at the universe.

  • Einstein's theories demand

  • That the universe is orderly and predictable,

  • But noels boor disagreed.

  • He and his colleagues proclaimed that

  • At the scale of atoms and particles,

  • The world is a game of chance

  • At the atomic or quantum level, uncertainty rules.

  • The best you can do,

  • According to quantum mechanics,

  • Is predict the chance

  • Or probability of one outcome or another.

  • And this strange idea .

  • Opened the door to an unsettling new picture of reality

  • It was so unsettling

  • That if the bizarre features of quantum mechanics were

  • Noticeable in our everyday world,

  • Like they are here in the quantum cafe,

  • You might think you'd lost your mind.

  • The laws in the quantum world

  • Are very different from the laws that we are used to.

  • Our daily experiences

  • Are totally different from anything

  • That you would see in the quantum world.

  • The quantum world is crazy.

  • For nearly 80 years,

  • Quantum mechanics has successfully claimed

  • That the strange and bizarre are typical

  • Of how our universe actually

  • Behaves on extremely small scales.

  • At the scale of everyday life,

  • We don't directly experience

  • The weirdness of quantum mechanics.

  • But here in the quantum cafe,

  • Big, everyday things sometimes behave

  • As if they were microscopically tiny.

  • And no matter how many times I come here,

  • I never seem to get used to it.

  • I'll have an orange juice, please.

  • I'll try.

  • "I』ll try," she says.

  • You see,

  • They're not used to people

  • Placing definite orders here in the quantum cafe,

  • Because here everything is ruled by chance.

  • While I'd like an orange juice,

  • There is only a particular probability

  • That I'll actually get one.

  • And there's no reason to be disappointed

  • With one particular outcome or another,

  • Because quantum mechanics suggests that

  • Each of the possibilities like getting a yellow juice

  • Or a red juice may actually happen.

  • They just happen to happen in universes

  • That are parallel to ours,

  • Universes that seem as real to their inhabitants

  • As our universe seems to us.

  • If there are a thousand possibilities,

  • And quantum mechanics cannot,

  • With certainty, say which of the thousand it will be,

  • Then all thousand will happen.

  • Yeah, you can laugh at it and say,

  • "well, that has to be wrong."

  • But there are so many other things in physics which-

  • At the time that people came up with

  • Had to be wrong, but it wasn't.

  • Have to be a little careful, I think,

  • Before you say this is clearly wrong.

  • And even in our own universe,

  • Quantum mechanics says there's a chance

  • That things we'd ordinarily think of as impossible

  • Can actually happen.

  • For example

  • There's a chance that particles can pass

  • Right through walls or barriers

  • That seem impenetrable to you or me.

  • There's even a chance that I

  • Could pass through something solid,

  • Like a wall.

  • Now, quantum calculations do show

  • That the probability for this to happen

  • In the everyday world is so small

  • That I'd need to continue walking into the wall

  • For nearly an eternity

  • Before having a reasonable chance of succeeding.

  • But here, these kinds of things happen all the time.

  • You have to learn to abandon those assumptions

  • That you have about the world

  • In order to understand quantum mechanics.

  • In my gut, in my belly, do I feel like

  • I have a deep intuitive understanding of quantum mechanics?

  • No.

  • And neither did Einstein.

  • He never lost faith

  • That the universe behaves in a certain

  • And predictable way.

  • The idea that all we can do is calculate the odds

  • That things will turn out one way or another

  • Was something Einstein deeply resisted.

  • Quantum mechanics says that

  • You can't know for certain the outcome of any experiment;

  • You can only assign a certain probability

  • to the outcome of any experiment.

  • And this, Einstein disliked intensely.

  • He used to say "God does not throw dice."

  • Yet, experiment after experiment showed

  • Einstein was wrong.

  • And that quantum mechanics really does describe

  • how the world works at the subatomic level.

  • So quantum mechanics is not a luxury,

  • something that you can do without.

  • I mean why is water the way it is?

  • Why does light go straight through water?

  • Why is it transparent?

  • Why are other things not transparent?

  • How do molecules form?

  • Why are they reacting the way they react?

  • The moment that you want to understand

  • anything at an atomic level,

  • As non-intuitive as it is,

  • At that moment,

  • you can only make progress with quantum mechanics.

  • Quantum mechanics is fantastically accurate.

  • There has never been a prediction of quantum mechanics

  • that has contradicted an observation,

  • Never.

  • By the 1930s,

  • Einstein's quest for unification was floundering,

  • While quantum mechanics was unlocking the secrets of the atom.

  • Scientists found that gravity and electromagnetism

  • are not the only forces ruling the universe.

  • Probing the structure of the atom,

  • they discovered two more forces.

  • One, dubbed the "strong nuclear force",

  • acts like a super-glue,

  • holding the nucleus of every atom together,

  • Binding protons to neutrons.

  • And the other,

  • called the "weak nuclear force,"

  • allows neutrons to turn into protons,

  • giving off radiation in the process.

  • At the quantum level,

  • the force we're most familiar with,

  • Gravity, was completely overshadowed by electromagnetism

  • and these two new forces.

  • Now, the strong and weak forces may seem obscure,

  • But in one sense at least,

  • we're all very much aware of their power.

  • At 5:29 on the morning of July 16th, 1945,

  • that power was revealed by an act

  • that would change the course of history.

  • In the middle of the desert, in New Mexico,

  • at the top of a steel tower about

  • a hundred feet above the top of this monument,

  • the first atomic bomb was detonated.

  • It was only about five feet across,

  • but that bomb packed a punch

  • equivalent to about twenty thousand tons of TNT.

  • With that powerful explosion,

  • scientists unleashed the strong nuclear force.

  • The force that keeps neutrons and protons

  • tightly glued together inside the nucleus of an atom.

  • By breaking the bonds of that glue

  • and splitting the atom apart,

  • vast, truly unbelievable amounts

  • of destructive energy were released.

  • We can still detect remnants of that explosion

  • through the other nuclear force--

  • the weak nuclear force.

  • Because it's responsible for radioactivity.

  • And today, more than 50 years later,

  • the radiation levels around here are still

  • about 10 times higher than normal.

  • So, although in comparison to electromagnetism and gravity

  • the nuclear forces act over very small scales,

  • their impact on everyday life is every bit as profound.

  • But what about gravity?

  • Einstein's general relativity?

  • Where does that fit in at the quantum level?

  • Quantum mechanics tells us

  • how all of nature's forces work in the microscopic realm

  • except for the force of gravity.

  • Absolutely no one

  • could figure out how gravity operates

  • when you get down to the size of atoms

  • and subatomic particles.

  • That is,

  • no one could figure out how to put general relativity

  • and quantum mechanics together into one package.

  • For decades,

  • Every attempt to describe the force of gravity

  • in the same language as the other forces -

  • the language of quantum mechanics -

  • has met with disaster.

  • You try to put those two pieces of mathematics together,

  • they do not coexist peacefully.

  • You get answers that the probabilities

  • of the event you're looking at are infinite.

  • Nonsense, it's not profound,

  • it's just nonsense.

  • It's very ironic because it was the first force

  • to actually be understood

  • in some decent quantitative way.

  • But, but, but it still remains split off

  • and very different from, from the other ones.

  • The laws of nature are supposed to apply everywhere.

  • So if Einstein's laws are supposed to apply everywhere,

  • and the laws of quantum mechanics

  • are supposed to apply everywhere.

  • Well you can't have two separate everywhere.

  • In 1933, after fleeing Nazi Germany,

  • Einstein settled in Princeton, New Jersey.

  • Working in solitude,

  • he stubbornly continued the quest

  • he had begun more than a decade earlier,

  • to unite gravity and electromagnetism.

  • Every few years, headlines appeared,

  • proclaiming Einstein was on the verge of success.

  • But most of his colleagues believed his quest was misguided

  • and that his best days were already behind him.

  • Einstein, in his later years,

  • got rather detached from the work of

  • Physics in general and,

  • and stopped reading people's papers.

  • I didn't even think he knew

  • there was such a thing as the weak nuclear force.

  • He didn't pay attention to those things.

  • He kept working on the same problem

  • that he had started working on as a younger man.

  • When the community of theoretical physicists

  • begins to probe the atom,

  • Einstein very definitely gets left out of the picture.

  • He, in some sense,

  • chooses not to look at the physics

  • coming from these experiments.

  • That means that the laws of quantum mechanics

  • play no role in his sort of further investigations.

  • He's thought to be this doddering,

  • sympathetic old figure who led an earlier revolution

  • but somehow fell out of it.

  • It is as if a general who was a master of horse cavalry,

  • who has achieved great things as a commander

  • at the beginning of the first world war,

  • would try to bring mounted cavalry

  • into play against the barbwire trenches

  • and machine guns of the other side.

  • Albert Einstein died on April 18, 1955.

  • And for many years

  • it seemed that Einstein's dream

  • of unifying the forces in a single theory

  • died with him.

  • So the quest for unification becomes a backwater of physics.

  • By the time of Einstein's death in the '50s,

  • almost no serious physicists

  • are engaged in this quest for unification.

  • In the years since, physics split into two separate camps,

  • One that uses general relativity

  • to study big and heavy objects,

  • things like stars, galaxies and the universe as a whole.

  • And another that uses quantum mechanics

  • to study the tiniest objects,

  • like atoms and particles.

  • This has been kind of like having two families

  • that just cannot get along and never talk to each other

  • living under the same roof.

  • There just seemed to be no way to combine quantum mechanics

  • and general relativity in a single theory

  • that could describe the universe on all scales.

  • Now, in spite of this,

  • we've made tremendous progress

  • in understanding the universe.

  • But there's a catch,

  • There are strange realms of the cosmos

  • that will never be fully understood

  • until we find a unified theory.

  • And nowhere is this more evident

  • than in the depths of a black hole.

  • A German astronomer named Karl Schwarzschild

  • first proposed what we now call black holes in 1916.

  • While stationed on the front lines in World War I,

  • he solved the equations of Einstein's general relativity

  • in a new and puzzling way.

  • Between calculations of artillery trajectories,

  • Schwarzschild figured out that an enormous amount of mass,

  • like that of a very dense star,

  • concentrated in a small area,

  • would warp the fabric of space-time so severely that nothing,

  • not even light, could escape its gravitational pull.

  • For decades,

  • physicists were skeptical

  • that Schwarz child』s calculations

  • were anything more than theory.

  • But today

  • satellite telescopes probing deep into space

  • are discovering regions with enormous gravitational pull

  • that most scientists believe are black holes.

  • Schwarz child』s theory now seems to be reality.

  • So here's the question,

  • If you're trying to figure out

  • what happens in the depths of a black hole,

  • where an entire star is crushed to a tiny speck,

  • do you use general relativity

  • because the star is incredibly heavy

  • or quantum mechanics

  • because it's incredibly tiny?

  • Well, that's the problem.

  • Since the center of a black hole is both tiny and heavy,

  • you can't avoid using both theories at the same time.

  • And when we try to put the two theories together

  • in the realm of black holes,

  • they conflict. It breaks down.

  • They give nonsensical predictions.

  • And the universe is not nonsensical; it's got to make sense.

  • Quantum mechanics works really well for small things,

  • and general relativity works

  • really well for stars and galaxies.

  • But the atoms, the small things, and the galaxies,

  • they're part of the same universe.

  • So there has to be some description

  • that applies to everything.

  • So we can't have one description for atoms and one for stars.

  • Now, with string theory,

  • we think we may have found a way

  • to unite our theory of the large and our theory of the small.

  • And make sense of the universe at all scales and all places.

  • Instead of a multitude of tiny particles,

  • string theory proclaims that everything in the universe,

  • all forces and all matter is made of one single ingredient,

  • tiny vibrating strands of energy known as strings.

  • A string can wiggle in many different ways,

  • whereas, of course, a point can't.

  • And the different ways in which the string wiggles

  • represent the different kinds of elementary particles.

  • It's like a violin string,

  • and it can vibrate just like violin strings can vibrate.

  • Each note if, you like, describes a different particle.

  • So it has incredible unification power,

  • It unifies our understanding

  • of all these different kinds of particles.

  • So unity of the different forces and particles is achieved

  • because they all come from different kinds of

  • vibrations of the same basic string.

  • It's a simple idea with far-reaching consequences.

  • What string theory does is it holds out the promise that,

  • "look, we can really understand questions that

  • you might not even have thought were scientific questions:

  • questions about how the universe began,

  • why the universe is the way it is

  • at the most fundamental level".

  • The idea that a scientific theory

  • that we already have in our hands

  • could answer the most basic questions

  • is extremely seductive.

  • But this seductive new theory is also controversial.

  • Strings, if they exist, are so small,

  • there's little hope of ever seeing one.

  • String theory and string theorists do have a real problem.

  • How do you actually test string theory?

  • If you can't test it in the way that we test normal theories,

  • it's not science, it's philosophy,

  • and that's a real problem.

  • If string theory fails to provide a testable prediction,

  • then nobody should believe it.

  • On the other hand,

  • there is a kind of elegance to these things,

  • and given the history of

  • how theoretical physics has evolved thus far.

  • It is totally conceivable

  • that some if not all of

  • these ideas will turn out to be correct.

  • I think, a hundred years from now,

  • this particular period,

  • when most of the brightest young theoretical physicists

  • worked on string theory,

  • will be remembered as a heroic age

  • when theorists tried and succeeded

  • to develop a unified theory of all the phenomena of nature.

  • On the other hand, it may be remembered as a tragic failure.

  • My guess is

  • that it will be something like the former

  • rather than the latter.

  • But ask me a hundred years from now,

  • then I can tell you.

  • Our understanding of the universe has come

  • an enormously long way during the last three centuries.

  • Just consider this.

  • Newton,

  • who was perhaps the greatest scientist of all time, once said,

  • "I have been like a boy playing on the sea shore,

  • diverting myself in now and then finding a smoother pebble

  • or a prettier shell than usual,

  • while the great ocean of truth lay before me,

  • all undiscovered."

  • And yet,

  • two hundred and fifty years later,

  • Albert Einstein, who was Newton's true successor,

  • was able to seriously suggest that this vast ocean,

  • all the laws of nature,

  • might be reduced to a few fundamental ideas

  • expressed by a handful of mathematical symbols.

  • And today,

  • a half century after Einstein's death,

  • we may at last be on the verge

  • of fulfilling his dream of unification

  • with string theory.

  • But where did this daring and strange new theory come from?

  • How does string theory achieve

  • the ultimate unification of the laws of the large

  • and the laws of the small?

  • And how will we know if it's right or wrong?

  • No experiment can ever check up what's going on

  • at the distances that are being studied.

  • The theory is permanently safe.

  • Is that a theory of physics or a philosophy?

  • It isn't written in the stars that we're going to succeed.

  • But in the end

  • We hope we will have a single theory

  • that governs everything.

Now, on nova,

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it