Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • On this episode of China Uncensored,

  • China’s secret plan to take over the world!

  • What’s that Shelley?

  • It’s not a secret?

  • They just held a huge conference about it in Beijing?

  • Dozens of world leaders were there?

  • And we have footage?

  • Hi, welcome to China Uncensored.

  • I’m your host, Chris Chappell.

  • It’s the biggest global economic investment project

  • in modern times.

  • Bigger even than Newt Gingrich's

  • proposed moon colony.

  • Yeah, remember when that was the weirdest thing

  • that happened in a presidential election?

  • Anyway, this global economic investment project

  • involves more than 60 countries

  • and one trillion dollars.

  • Which is more than the combined GDP

  • of the smallest 97 nations.

  • Or the price of 28 moon colonies.

  • And the whole thing is being led

  • by the benevolent leadership

  • of the Chinese Communist Party.

  • It’s calledOne Belt, One Road.”

  • Or for short,

  • OBOR.

  • On Sunday,

  • heads of state from 29 countries

  • gathered at Beijing’s Great Hall of the People

  • for theBelt and Road Forum.”

  • Or for short, BARF.

  • Which is how I feel right now.

  • Especially because all of China’s favorite

  • political strongmen were there!

  • Turkish president-for-life with sweeping new powers,

  • Recep Erdoğan.

  • Filipino president and proud killer of drug suspects,

  • Rodrigo Duterte.

  • And Russian president and former KGB agent,

  • Vladmir Putin.

  • Just look at that swagger.

  • Jinping,

  • I could take you in fight.

  • Maybe not wife.”

  • So why is China trying to gather

  • all these nations together?

  • Well, as Xi Jinping explained on Monday,

  • countries need to stick together

  • like swan geese.

  • Because, quote,

  • Swan geese are able to fly far and safely

  • through winds and storms

  • because they move in flocks

  • and help each other as a team.”

  • Yes!

  • Swan geese fly together!

  • Swan geese fly together!

  • Quack, quack, uh, I mean,

  • honk, honk, honk!

  • The point is,

  • Xi is clearly expecting winds and storms

  • and is looking for strength in numbers.

  • So what is this trillion-dollar

  • flying V-shaped globalization initiative,

  • with China at the helm?

  • I’ll let China’s state-run English TV network,

  • CGTN explain.

  • China states that the Belt and Road Initiative

  • is a systematic project,

  • which should be built upon the principle

  • ofextensive consultation,

  • joint contribution,

  • and shared benefits.’”

  • Could we go back to the swan geese part,

  • because that was easier to understand.

  • If only someone could explain One Belt, One Road

  • in a simple way.

  • Like for children.

  • The Belt connects the land

  • The Road moves on the sea

  • The promise that they hold

  • Is joint prosperity

  • Ok, I get the belt part.

  • It’s a metaphor for how Xi Jinping

  • keeps his pants so high.

  • But a road that moves on the sea?

  • Wait a minute,

  • is this about those artificial islands

  • in the South China Sea?

  • Are they building moving roads now

  • to connect all of them?

  • Anyway, state-run New China TV,

  • please continue.

  • With our lines and our cables

  • Diplomacy tables

  • Well share in a world of prosperity!

  • OH~

  • The future’s coming now

  • OH~OH~OH~OH~

  • The Belt and Road is How

  • OH~OH~OH~OH~”

  • The Belt and Road is Hao?

  • As in, the Chinese word forgood”?

  • Oh oh oh oh oh.

  • Oh.

  • Congratulations to Chinese state-run media

  • for really upping their propaganda game.

  • But maybe youre still not clear

  • what One Belt, One Road actually is.

  • Maybe one of the other children’s videos

  • by Chinese state-run media can explain.

  • Once upon a time,

  • several routes led from China

  • to Central Asia to Europe

  • It was called the Silk Road.

  • Well, a few years ago,

  • China's president Xi Jinping proposed

  • making new routes like the old routes.

  • But even bigger.”

  • That’s pretty much the gist of it.

  • China wants to be the new world leader.

  • Not through actually colonizing the world

  • with military force

  • which frankly never turns out well;

  • ask the British.

  • No, China wants to rule with economic force.

  • One Belt, One Road is about building

  • giant infrastructure projects in Asia,

  • Europe, and Africa.

  • Mainly things like roads,

  • rail lines, tunnels, bridges,

  • seaports, and power plants.

  • In theory, this will bring

  • resources and power to China,

  • and money and goods to everyone.

  • You know, “joint prosperity.”

  • China is pledging around a trillion dollars,

  • with tens of of billions spent so far.

  • According to China’s Caixing Magazine,

  • 50 Chinese state-owned enterprises

  • have invested in nearly 1,700 projects

  • since Xi Jinping first announced the initiative

  • in 2013.

  • Those include 60 energy-related projects,

  • like gas pipelines from Russia and Kazakhstan

  • to China.

  • They also include high-speed train routes,

  • like the 4-billion-dollar rail line

  • that will send trains from Ethiopia into Djibouti.

  • Now in theory,

  • China spending billions of dollars to invest in,

  • you know,

  • thejoint prosperityof dozens of nations

  • is in theory a good thing.

  • If countries have real economic needs,

  • and China helps fulfill them,

  • then China will be doing a great thing.

  • But there are serious concerns

  • that that's not how it’s going to turn out.

  • Let's take Laos for example.

  • Laos is a poor southeast Asian country

  • with a GDP of less than 14 billion.

  • A Chinese joint venture is building

  • a 6-billion-dollar railway project there.

  • How can Laos afford such a huge investment,

  • one that’s projected to lose money

  • for the first eleven years?

  • No problem!

  • Chinese banks will loan them the money!

  • And if they can’t pay it back...

  • I guess Laos will just owe the Chinese Communist Party

  • some favors.

  • Political favors,

  • like supporting China in the UN.

  • Or economic favors,

  • like signing away their mineral rights to China.

  • Or the Chinese Communist Party could just

  • break their kneecaps.

  • And Laos is just one example

  • of how China’s skein of geese

  • might turn out to be more like a kettle of vultures.

  • A lot of poor countries are concerned

  • that the Chinese Communist Party

  • wants to use these infrastructure projects

  • to make it easier for Chinese companies

  • to extract their natural resources

  • and get rich at the expense of the locals.

  • I mean, in theory this wholejoint prosperityslogan

  • is supposed to mean a win-win for everyone.

  • At least that’s what the happy,

  • multi-ethnic children would have you believe.

  • But a lot of the infrastructure is designed

  • to exploit oil and minerals,

  • or move goods

  • and not to create housing, schools,

  • or access to clean drinking water.

  • And that’s especially an issue

  • in poor African countries

  • like Ethiopia and Djibouti.

  • Corrupt local officials might get rich,

  • but the general public?

  • Probably not.

  • And there’s another problem.

  • China doesn’t exactly have a great track record

  • of successful infrastructure projects

  • to begin with.

  • This Oxford Review of Economic Policy paper,

  • analyzes three decades of Chinese investment data.

  • It says,

  • Far from being an engine of economic growth,

  • a typical infrastructure investment

  • has destroyed economic value in China

  • due to poor management of risks.”

  • So basically,

  • extensive, long-term data

  • shows that the majority

  • of Chinese infrastructure investments

  • actually lose money.

  • So ten years from now,

  • we might see a lot of busted kneecaps.

  • There are other concerns

  • that affect wealthier regions, too.

  • Like the European Union.

  • According to this article in the Guardian,

  • the 28 member states of the EU

  • decided not to support Beijing’s draft statement

  • about trade issued at the end

  • of this past weekend’s...BARF summit.

  • They really have to work on those acronyms.

  • The problem?

  • Members wanted guarantees that projects

  • would be economically and environmentally sustainable

  • and subject to fair tendering processes.”

  • Well, I believe that Chinese leaders

  • have pledged to treat these projects

  • like theyre in China’s own backyard,

  • so I’m sure theyll be environmentally sustainable.

  • As for fair tendering processes...

  • yeah, youre on your own.

  • Look, I’m not saying it’s wrong for China

  • to look out for its own interests.

  • Of course every country wants to make sure

  • they get an advantage out of working

  • or investing in other countries.

  • But One Belt One Road

  • is a way that the Communist Party

  • can exploit poorer countries for China’s

  • economic and political gain,

  • all disguised under the idea of

  • shared benefitsandjoint prosperity.”

  • It sounds good on paper,

  • or in a song,

  • or a bedtime story,

  • but it’s not so clear

  • whether all of these swan geese

  • are really going to get off the ground.

  • So what do you think about One Belt, One Road?

  • Leave your comments below.

  • Thanks for watching

  • this episode of China Uncensored.

  • Once again, I’m your host, Chris Chappell.

  • See you next time.

On this episode of China Uncensored,

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it