Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • On this episode of China Uncensored,

  • a very controversial and sensitive topic.

  • Good thing I can say whatever I...

  • No!

  • Hi, welcome to China Uncensored,

  • I’m your host Chris Chappell.

  • Well gang,

  • were in trouble.

  • You may have heard about how YouTube

  • has rolled out some extremely vague,

  • nondescript guidelines

  • for what topics areadvertiser-friendly content.”

  • And YouTube says

  • that if I don’t create

  • advertiser-friendly content,”

  • they won’t place ads in my episodes.

  • In fact,

  • YouTube has been taking away ads

  • across the board

  • for thousands of YouTube creators.

  • If a video violates their vague prohibitions,

  • YouTube removes the ads before and during the video.

  • Great!

  • No ads!

  • Except that’s how everyone supports their shows.

  • Without advertising revenue,

  • shows like China Uncensored wouldn’t exist.

  • This story first broke last Wednesday

  • when big-time YouTuber Philip Defranco

  • called them out on it.

  • By taking away monetization it’s a form of censorship.

  • Why censorship?

  • Because those ads are the main way

  • we supports ourselves at China Uncensored.

  • That's how we can create episodes for you

  • three times a week.

  • So what’s notadvertiser-friendly content”?

  • According to YouTube’s guidelines,

  • it includes

  • controversial or sensitive subjects

  • includingsubjects related to war

  • orpolitical conflicts.”

  • That’s why I’ve been getting emails like this.

  • Hmmm

  • Maybe YouTube prefers I

  • praise China’s economic development?

  • Or maybe I should just cover food festivals?

  • Ok,

  • maybe not all food festivals

  • Now YouTube has responded to the outrage

  • from Youtube creators and fans

  • by saying this is not a new policy.

  • Theyve just implemented a new policy

  • that lets you know theyve stripped your revenue away

  • by sending you an email.

  • YouTube didn’t change their policy?

  • They used to take your money away without telling you?

  • Isn’t that even worse?

  • But actually,

  • this is new to me.

  • This month marks China Uncensored’s

  • 4-year anniversary on YouTube.

  • And until last month,

  • not once has a video of mine

  • had its ads stripped away like this.

  • But in the past week and a half,

  • six of my videos have been flagged,

  • costing the show potentially thousands of dollars

  • in revenue.

  • And guess what?

  • I only got emails about two of them.

  • YouTube is still not properly notifying me.

  • Now technically,

  • this isn’t censorship.

  • YouTube still keeps the videos online.

  • But it’s ad-censorship.

  • Because without ads,

  • this show can’t survive.

  • And doesn’t this ad-censorship incentivize all YouTube creators

  • to avoid sensitive and controversial topics?

  • Hmmm...

  • I wonder if this has anything to do with Google

  • trying to get back into China...

  • Okay,

  • probably not.

  • Maybe

  • But meanwhile,

  • the Chinese regime invests an estimated

  • 10 billion dollars a year

  • in what they call

  • external publicity work.”

  • That is,

  • spreading its propaganda message to the West.

  • The Communist Party has a giant billboard in Times Square,

  • broadcasting Chinese propaganda 24/7,

  • 365 days a year

  • since 2011.

  • They place their propaganda in newspapers

  • like the New York Times and Wall Street Journal.

  • Yes,

  • China Watch is a paid insert

  • in respectable Western newspapers.

  • State-run CCTV gives its propaganda news feed

  • to all the major US TV networks,

  • telling them

  • here’s the latest China news, for free!”

  • They even created an English language version of CCTV

  • and put its headquarters

  • seven blocks from the White House.

  • The Communist Party even buys airtime on American radio stations

  • without disclosing it.

  • That’s why I created China Uncensored -

  • to cut through all that and deliver truthful,

  • uncensored information about China,

  • and how it affects you.

  • But now,

  • YouTube is cutting off ad revenue

  • on controversial topics.

  • I’m not exaggerating when I say

  • this could kill China Uncensored.

  • Without income,

  • I’ll have to stop doing the show for you.

  • And my YouTube revenue has plummeted

  • in the last few weeks.

  • Unbelievably,

  • it’s less than it was a year ago,

  • when I had only 120,000 subscribers

  • and half as many staff to support.

  • And another challenge is this:

  • Even on my videos that YouTube doesn’t ad-censor,

  • I’ve been losing a lot of revenue.

  • For a typical episode I publish,

  • about 30,000 of you use ad blockers.

  • Look,

  • I get it.

  • YouTube ads can be annoying.

  • But it’s how YouTubers like me

  • can afford to make content for you.

  • But there is a way you can help keep this show going.

  • Support China Uncensored on Patreon.

  • Patreon is a website that lets people like you

  • directly support your favorite creators on YouTube.

  • Sort of like how during the European Renaissance,

  • patrons would provide financial support to artists

  • so they could focus on their craft.

  • I started working with Patreon a year ago,

  • and the extra income has allowed me to do things like:

  • Hire Zach, our researcher;

  • hire Seamus, our video editor,

  • so I could make more episodes every week;

  • travel to South Korea,

  • hold fan events,

  • buy costumes and props,

  • and much more.

  • But so far,

  • Patreon has only been a third of our revenue.

  • YouTube ads have been the majority.

  • Until now, I’m afraid.

  • So your Patreon support is more crucial than ever before.

  • If youre already one of my Patreon supporters,

  • thank you so much!

  • Youve been a huge help so far,

  • and I hope youll continue.

  • And if you can afford it,

  • please consider expanding your monthly limit,

  • And if you aren’t a Patreon supporter yet,

  • please become a supporter now.

  • Sign-up is super easy;

  • it takes less than five minutes.

  • The link is below.

  • And to commemorate our challenges with YouTube,

  • I’ve created a new support level:

  • China Uncensored Uncensorer!

  • That official title will be yours,

  • to all of you who contributes 5 cents or more per episode.

  • Because if all 30,000 of you who use ad blockers

  • contribute even 5 cents per episode,

  • you can make up for it in a big way.

  • Our most popular level of support,

  • of course,

  • is 50 cents -

  • where you can become an official member

  • of my 50-Cent Army.

  • I’ll also give you some cool wallpaper to download

  • Check out the even cooler rewards

  • like music downloads

  • for people who contribute more.

  • Now recently,

  • I asked a few hundred of you in my Market Research Team

  • what you’d like to see from me.

  • And the most common request was:

  • Behind-the-scenes stuff.

  • So,

  • wish granted.

  • Starting now,

  • for everyone who supports China Uncensored on Patreon,

  • I’ll start posting behind-the-scenes stuff

  • that only you get access to.

  • Because your support will keep China Uncensored uncensored.

  • So please,

  • share this video.

  • Get the word out there that YouTube is censoring creators

  • by not placing ads on controversial videos.

  • And again,

  • please support the show on Patreon if you can.

  • The link is below.

  • Once again, I’m Chris Chappell.

  • Thanks for watching China Uncensored.

  • And one more thing:

  • China Uncensored has never had ads,

  • except the ones YouTube places automatically,

  • haha less so now.

  • The only exception was Mania,

  • the South Korean tailor who gave me suits and ties earlier this year

  • in exchange for making that ad -

  • the kind of ad that goes here,

  • in what we call theend card.”

  • I take the integrity of this show very seriously

  • and have been reluctant to have

  • product sponsors for the show,

  • even though that’s extremely common on YouTube,

  • and advertisers have been reaching out to me for a long time.

  • Now I see that if China Uncensored is to continue,

  • I’m also going to need to do this.

  • But I just want you to know

  • that if you ever see me promoting a product,

  • it will be something I personally approve of.

  • And never will any advertiser control the content of the show.

  • China Uncensored is

  • and will remain

  • independent and uncensored.

On this episode of China Uncensored,

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it