Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Your brain is two brains.

  • Two hemispheres each doing half the work of being you.

  • Half your vision goes to each and half your movement directed by each.

  • Right controls left

  • and left controls right.

  • Your two brains co-ordinate through a wire of nerves, but

  • this wire can be cut, and was, for a time, used as an epilepsy treatment.

  • After the cut, people seemed the same, though their brain was split in-twain.

  • Except, some post-split patients described that while selecting their morning outfit with

  • right hand, left might come along to disagree.

  • Actually, left hand might quite often disagree, which these split-brain patients found frustrating.

  • What's happening?

  • To investigate, remember, right brain sees and controls one half, while

  • left brain controls and sees the other.

  • But only left brain can speak.

  • "Hello."

  • Because that's where the speech center is located.

  • Right brain, without this, is mute.

  • In normal brains, this doesn't matter because each half communicates across the wire with the other.

  • But, split-brains can't, and thus, you can show just the right brain a word, ask the person:

  • "What did you see?",

  • and you'll hear: "Nothing."

  • Because, left speaking brain saw nothing.

  • Meanwhile, right brain will use its hand to pick the object out of a pile hidden from left brain.

  • This is deeply creepy.

  • Ask "Why are you holding the object?" and speaking left brain will make up a

  • plausible sounding, but totally wrong, reason.

  • "I always wanted to learn how to solve one of these."

  • Left brain isn't lying; it's just doing what brains do:

  • creating a story that explains its past actions to its current self, a behavior which does rather cast doubt

  • onto the notion of free will (but that's a story for another time).

  • Creating reasons for why it does things is just something

  • left brains do.

  • It happens in normal, healthy humans all the time, and if you think about it closely, you

  • know you've done this.

  • Back to experiments.

  • Give right brain an object, ask the person "What's in your hand?" and they won't be able to say.

  • "I'm not holding anything."

  • And, when asked to draw, a split-brain can draw two separate objects

  • simultaneously, with each hand, in a way unsplit-brains find challenging.

  • These experiments on split-brain patients are deeply unsettling

  • because they really point in the direction of a mute separate... intelligence...

  • Something...

  • Living in the skull.

  • You can even ask questions of a split-brain and get disagreement on the answer.

  • So, if your brain is split, who is the 'you' in this situation?

  • From the outside, it's tempting to think of the part of the brain that's speaking as the person, but

  • something is hearing and answering questions.

  • And, though right brain can't speak, it does understand faces, which left brain can't.

  • If this is you, you don't know who your friends and family are in a crowd.

  • This act of cutting exposes two minds in one head, and the talking mind

  • doesn't know there's someone else in the house.

  • The left brain can describe the situation it's in, but nonetheless will constantly be surprised by

  • right brain's actions and explain them away.

  • There's a question to be asked here:

  • Why, after separation, does right brain not totally freak out, but instead plays

  • along helpfully, answering questions, and listening to left-brain's dumb stories about what's happening.

  • - It's the best pony... I don't know.

  • - Speculation time...

  • But, one answer is the cutting doesn't make right brain a separate... intelligence... consciousness... person?

  • but rather it has always been. In normal people, perhaps right brain rose up as a companion without a choice.

  • Feeling at first somewhat equal partners, but then, as speech develops that it can't participate in, that

  • increasingly becomes the central point of life, it resigns to mutely co-ordinate with left brain.

  • At this moment, in your normal head, there are two of you watching this video:

  • one having a 'mind = blown' moment, and the other mentally rolling its eye at the obviousness of it all.

  • In split-brains, right doesn't freak out because not a whole lot has really changed.

  • You might not agree, and maybe arguing right now at why it can't be possible, exactly as we would expect

  • talking left brain to do.

  • Speculation aside, split-brain patients show, at the very least, that in the mind, there is a separate...

  • something that can hear and understand and respond, given the right circumstances.

  • Your brain isn't entirely yours.

  • Who is you?

  • You is two.

  • [soft music]

  • [Grey's voice morphing into Kurzgesagt's voice] But we can go deeper. You are many.

  • [Kurzgesagt's voice] The pile of meat that's your body is made up of trillions of tiny individuals that have a life of their own.

  • [Kurzgesagt's voice] So, at which point do the many become one?

  • [Kurzgesagt's voice] What makes lots of tiny things you?

  • [Kurzgesagt's voice] Click here to go to our channel and watch the next part.

  • [Grey's voice] Seriously. If you haven't checked out Kurzgesagt, then you don't know what you're missing.

  • Kurgaset?

  • Kurtzgaset?

  • I never know.

Your brain is two brains.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it