Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • How important is free speech on a college campus?

  • Here's what the Supreme Court said in 1957 in the landmark case Sweezy v. New Hampshire:

  • "Teachers and students must always remain free to inquire ...otherwise, our civilization

  • will stagnate and die." Inspiring words. And true... which is why what's happening at American

  • colleges and universities is so disturbing.

  • A study conducted by the Association of American Colleges and Universities in 2010, revealed

  • that only 30 percent of college seniors strongly agreed with the question; "Is it safe to hold

  • unpopular positions on this campus?"

  • Worse, the study found that students' confidence that that they can hold unpopular opinions

  • declines from freshman to senior year. How can it be that at the place where speech should

  • be the most free, the university, young people fear merely holding -- to say nothing of actually

  • expressing -- unpopular opinions?

  • The reason is that for decades now, students have been sent a clear message from their

  • schools: express dissenting opinions, violate political correctness, or even just criticize

  • the administration at your peril. After working for 12 years at the Foundation for Individual

  • Rights in Education, I have seen hundreds of examples of students in peril.

  • Here are just a few: At Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis,

  • a student employee was found guilty of "racial harassment" for publicly reading a book that

  • some of his fellow employees found offensive.

  • The book was Notre Dame vs. the Klan and it was available in the school's library. It

  • recounted and celebrated the defeat of the Ku Klux Klan when its members marched on Notre

  • Dame in 1924. So what did the university find offensive? The photo on the book's cover.

  • At the University of Delaware, students were forced to undergo ideological reeducation

  • as part of the university's compulsory student orientation program. The program was described

  • as "treatment" for students with incorrect attitudes and beliefs.

  • Students were taught to adopt highly specific university-approved views on politics, race,

  • sexuality, sociology, moral philosophy, and environmentalism. They were also required

  • to attend one-on-one meetings with their resident assistants where they were compelled to answer

  • intrusive, probing, and utterly irrelevant personal questions, such as ... "When did

  • you discover your sexual identity?"

  • And an increasing number of schools are trying to drive religious students off campus. Vanderbilt

  • University, for example, has enacted a policy that forbids faith-based student groups from

  • selecting members and leaders based on . . . their faith. As a result, 14 Christian groups have

  • been derecognized by the university.

  • Then there are "speech codes" at a majority of American colleges and universities.

  • What is a speech code? It is a university regulation or policy that limits or bans expression

  • written or verbal that is protected under the First Amendment. Such codes are applied

  • with glaring double standards against religious, conservative, or politically incorrect speech,

  • or simply speech that a particular campus administration happens to dislike. In other

  • words, there are things that you are completely free to say and write off campus that will

  • get you into serious trouble if you say or write them on campus.

  • These codes include polices that ban speech that administrators find "insulting," or "offensive".

  • One absurd code that appeared at multiple universities banned "inappropriately directed

  • laughter." And in Orwellian fashion, some schools even limit free speech to tiny sections

  • of campus called, "free speech zones."

  • Recently at the University of central Arkansas you were subject to disciplinary action if

  • you said or did something deemed annoying to another student.

  • In the most extensive study yet conducted of campus speech codes, the Foundation for

  • Individual Rights in Education found that 62 percent of America's top colleges maintain

  • serious restrictions on written and verbal expression, that violate First

  • Amendment protections.

  • What are the consequences of all this censorship by colleges and universities?

  • I explain that in detail in my book, Unlearning Liberty: Campus Censorship and the End of

  • American Debate, but for our purposes here, I will focus on just three.

  • First, campus censorship teaches students that they have a right not to be offended.

  • The moment society says that people have the right not to be offended, it has announced

  • the end of the right to free speech. Second, campus censorship teaches students

  • poor intellectual habits. It teaches them not to think critically lest they arrive at

  • a conclusion or express a thought that might offend someone. Further, students are taught

  • to ignore the timeless principle that educated people should actively seek out intelligent

  • people with whom they disagree for debate and discussion.

  • And third, it teaches students that they have fewer rights than they actually have; that

  • they must defer to arbitrary authority. A generation of students who don't know their

  • rights, and believe they must get permission before speaking their minds, is not thinking

  • like a free people and that is a threat to free society.

  • The rights embodied in the First Amendment shape American society. They foster America's

  • religious and cultural pluralism, spur scientific and scholarly innovation, and thus secure

  • our remarkable prosperity.

  • But today's universities with their censorship, speech codes, and political correctness are

  • putting the future of this unique experiment in freedom at risk. This is the very opposite

  • of what American Higher Education was founded to do.

  • I'm Greg Lukianoff, President of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, for Prager University.

How important is free speech on a college campus?

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it