Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Antiperspirant: it exists to make us smell better, but a new study finds - the opposite

  • is true. And it actually - makes us smell worse!

  • Hey guys, Tara here for Dnews, and for most of us - antiperspirant is as much a part of

  • our daily routine, as brushing our teeth. 90% of Americans use some form of it every

  • single day - but what if it’s doing more harm than good? Aside from all the potential

  • health side effects we hear about, could it actually be making us smell WORSE? Well, according

  • to a new study published in the Archives of Dermatological Research - that’s exactly what it does.

  • Before we get into this, let’s examine what actually causes body odor. It all starts with

  • sweat. The sweat we secrete through our armpits, contains lipids and amino acids - that get

  • broken down by bacteria, and that process is what creates the distinctive body odor smell.

  • Deodorants contain antimicrobial agents that kill off that bacteria, but they also contain

  • chemicals that replace the bad odors with good ones. Antiperspirants work the opposite

  • way, by physically plugging up our sweat glands with aluminum-based compounds. So where deodorants

  • can only mask the smell, antiperspirants actually prevent the sweat that causes it. Of course

  • most antiperspirants are also deodorants - so as far as body odor goes, theyre effectively working double duty.

  • It seems too good to be true, and like most things - it probably is. Messing with our

  • body’s natural composition of bacteria, typically comes with side effects. So to test

  • how these products affect us, a team of researchers at the University of Ghent in Belgium, asked

  • 6 men and 2 women to stop using any kind of deodorant and antiperspirant for an entire

  • month. Specifically, 4 of the subjects stopped using deodorant - and the other 4 stopped using antiperspirant.

  • As a control, they recruited another subject who didn’t use either one regularly - and

  • asked them to start using deodorant for the duration of the month.

  • At several points, before, during, and after the trial, researchers analyzed each subject’s

  • armpit bacteria - and found that switching hygiene habits significantly altered the bacterial

  • communities of each and every person. Specifically, they noticed one common trend among every

  • subject: which is that antiperspirants led to a clear increase of Actinobacteria.

  • Actinobacteria is just one of many kinds of bacteria living in the armpit, but it also

  • happens to be the smelliest kind, and it’s predominantly associated with BO. Meaning

  • the very substance that’s supposed to prevent body odor, is actually making us smell worse.

  • Now, why on earth would something like this happen?

  • Well, the author of the study believes the aluminum compounds in antiperspirant - are

  • killing off all of the good bacteria, and allowing the bad, more smelly ones to dominate.

  • Which explains why only antiperspirant is to blame. By comparison, the study found that

  • subjects who used deodorant - actually experienced a decrease in Actinobacteria.

  • So, what’s the take home message here? Should we all just forgo antiperspirant, and start

  • wearing deodorant instead? Wellyes and no. In the long run, deodorant is probably

  • better for you - but it still doesn’t address the root cause of the issue, which is the

  • bacteria that causes odors. All deodorant does is mask them. So really, it’s the lesser

  • of 2 evils. But there’s gotta be a better solution out there, right?

  • Well, there is - and it’s exactly what the author of this study is working on: armpit

  • bacterial transplantation. It’s when you take away the bad bacteria from someone with

  • body odor - and replace it with the good bacteria from a relative of that person, who doesn’t

  • have body odor. So far, theyve tried it on over 15 people,

  • and for most subjects - they say it brings immediate improvement, that’s often times

  • permanent. Obviously, a procedure like this would be used for only the most extreme cases

  • - but for now, it seems like a natural - and more effective - alternative to deodorant

  • and antiperspirant. I’ll say this much - and it’s probably

  • TMI - but I stopped using antiperspirant regularly a couple years ago - now I use it maybe 2,

  • 3 times a week - and I’ve actually noticed that even though I sweat slightly less on

  • the days I use it, I also smell more. So, I’m not entirely convinced it’s really

  • done a whole lot to improve my life. That’s just me though - I’m sure some of you out

  • there do a lot more strenuous activities than I, so maybe consult your significant other

  • before you throw your deodorant in the trash. It is a courtesy, after all.

  • [YOUTUBE] Now to completely switch gears for a second,

  • I wanna mention another show we have here at Discovery, called TestTube - that’s hosted

  • by Trace and myself. It’s a daily show, like Dnews - but geared towards current events.

  • Trace did an episode earlier this week on why the US and China are investing so much

  • money into Africa, and it’s a fascinating angle on that whole discussion. So if youre

  • interested in learning more about that, just head over to youtube.com/testtubenetwork - and

  • you can watch all of our episodes in one neat webpage.

Antiperspirant: it exists to make us smell better, but a new study finds - the opposite

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it