Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • This is a chart showing the change in consumer prices in China.

  • As you can see, those prices have been falling a lot.

  • Many economists are concerned that China is slipping into a period of deflation, often an even worse scenario than high inflation.

  • At the country's legislative session in March, Premier Li Qiang said Beijing would issue special treasury bonds to help stimulate economic growth.

  • But some investors are skeptical it will succeed.

  • Here's why falling prices can be so dangerous, not just for China but also for the global economy.

  • To understand what's happening in China, let's look at Japan's recession in the 1990s or what many call its lost decade.

  • Japan in a way is the poster child for deflation that this huge sort of bubble in stock market and real estate burst.

  • Subsequent to that, the economy slowed down.

  • Prices fell, sending the economy into a deflationary spiral which can be really hard to escape.

  • That's because when consumer prices fall, people expect them to keep falling.

  • So they're more likely to wait to make that big purchase until sometime in the future when it's cheaper.

  • Lower spending means that companies make less profit that means they need less workers, so unemployment might go up.

  • Spending gets even lower prices fall further.

  • So you get into this sort of vicious circle where prices are spending to sort of chase each other lower.

  • One example of this was the Great Depression in the US, where deflation led to slow economic growth, then a big rise in unemployment.

  • Japan, where working-age population growth was turning negative, didn't really struggle with unemployment.

  • There's very strong social pressure on companies in Japan not to lay people off in the way that there isn't in the United States and lots of other Western economies.

  • Japan's lost decade is also commonly referred to as a balance sheet recession.

  • A term coined by economist Richard K which means put simply that everyone had kind of run up an awful lot of debt, particularly companies in the preceding decade or so.

  • And every penny they made went to servicing that debt.

  • So companies stopped spending and investing. They stopped hiring.

  • The Bank of Japan tried repeatedly over the years to stimulate economic growth from cutting interest rates to printing money.

  • But nothing quite got the economy back to where it was.

  • It took 34 years for its stock market to record a new high and the country's GDP per capita has hovered around $40,000 for a long time.

  • Some economists say it's hard to pin down whether deflation is directly responsible for Japan's slower growth.

  • But...

  • Deflation is more of a problem, the longer it lasts.

  • It's a difficult problem to definitely identify until possibly it's too late.

  • That's what economists are afraid is happening right now in China.

  • The economy grew 5.2% last year.

  • As far as China is concerned, it was not great.

  • I mean, China typically grows close to 6%, 7%.

  • Like Japan in the '90s, China is also experiencing a real estate bust.

  • The economy got to a point where it really relied on state investment.

  • The government decided that it had enough of this because there was too much debt building up.

  • And so they made a big effort to try and squeeze developers, property developers access to credit and that was in 2020.

  • And since then, the property market has just kind of been in free fall.

  • Many households are seeing the value of their homes drop which is driving down spending.

  • But unlike Japan, where real estate prices collapsed very quickly, in China, it's happening much more slowly.

  • One strange thing is prices haven't fallen quite as much as they ought to have, mostly because lots of local governments are propping them up.

  • And some economists certainly say that what needs to happen in China to get a real resolution to the real estate crisis is a much bigger fall in prices so that people start buying these apartments again.

  • Economists are split on whether China's economy is just struggling due to some short-term factors and will soon work itself out.

  • Or if this deflationary trend is spreading.

  • Falling prices were initially saw them very clearly in producer prices.

  • So the prices companies charge to take things out of their factories.

  • And then you started to see it in some categories of consumer prices, particularly things like pork, which is a big part of the Chinese diet and the important component of overall consumer price inflation.

  • Deflation in China isn't just a problem for China.

  • It's also a problem for the rest of the world.

  • Weak consumer spending in China means exporters have to ship goods overseas to find buyers.

  • And that's led to the price of Chinese exports falling too.

  • While cheaper prices are good for consumers, they're putting pressure on domestic manufacturers around the world because China can produce a lot of goods more cheaply.

  • In Europe, for instance, there's a lot of anxiety at the moment over automakers.

  • So Chinese companies are making a lot of cars, a lot of electric vehicles in particular and they're making them cheaply and they're selling them all over the world.

  • In response, countries like the US are imposing trade barriers against Chinese exports.

  • The type of bonds that China plans to issue a stimulus are typically reserved for economic emergencies.

  • This is only the fourth time in the past 25 years that China has issued bonds like these.

  • The fact that the three previous such bond issuances each followed an economic crisis, speaks to the deep sense of urgency that officials are feeling right now.

  • They're very familiar with what happened in Japan are determined to avoid it, whether they're taking the right lessons from it, I think is uncertain.

  • Japan when it entered into deflation and stagnation was the second-largest economy in the world.

  • China is the world's second-largest economy and to have that slide into deflation and stagnation would mean lower global growth overall.

  • So it definitely is a problem for the rest of the world.

This is a chart showing the change in consumer prices in China.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it