Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Why can't robots check the box that says "I'm not a robot."

  • I mean, robots can do heaps of complex things these days.

  • So what is stopping them from ticking a simple check box?

  • Well, the box is a newer version of a system that used to be called CAPTCHA.

  • CAPTCHA: completely automated public turing test to tell computers and humans apart.

  • You might remember they used to look like this.

  • But as robots got smarter CAPTCHAs got harder and they became completely inaccessible to the vision impaired.

  • And the rest of us.

  • Is that even a fucking letter?

  • By 2014, Google had designed A I software that could pass 99.8% of CAPTCHA tests while humans were only passing 33% of them.

  • Maybe it's a magic eye.

  • I think I see a dolphin.

  • Meanwhile, spammers without supercomputers could still get around CAPTCHAs by paying workers in digital sweatshops to solve them at a rate of 30 US cents per 1000 CAPTCHA sold.

  • Now these services are still online today.

  • What's their address?

  • So that's why Google invented the box.

  • They call it reCAPTCHA.

  • So now I just click the box that says I'm human and that's it?

  • In this case, yep.

  • Well, why can't a robot do that?

  • Well, they can.

  • But the click isn't the test, the test comes before the click.

  • Like the way your mouse moves towards that box.

  • Google tracks that kind of thing.

  • A cursor controlled by a bot moves in a suspiciously straight line at a consistent speed.

  • Whereas your mouse movements are, well, uh they're only human.

  • Exactly.

  • If the side's still unsure, you'll have to click on the squares with fire hydrants or crosswalks or traffic lights.

  • Google hasn't told us how reCAPTCHA works exactly.

  • But experts think this traffic light section might also be a mouse movement test, which is why you passed even though you missed two millimeters of traffic light room in the second square.

  • Well, I'm only human. -So true.

  • So what's stopping spammers from paying sweatshops to beat these new CAPTCHAs?

  • Nothing.

  • Their workers get paid a whole $1 to complete 1000 CAPTCHAs.

  • But there is just one, tiny other little thing.

  • Yeah?

  • Modern reCAPTCHAs also examine your browsing history. - What?

  • Your previous internet activity is the clearest giveaway of who is human and what's a bot.

  • Bots for instance, don't generally Google themselves while perving on pictures of young King Charles and looking into forehead reduction surgery.

  • I did not give them permission to do that.

  • You gave Google permission to. - I did not.

  • Yes, you did check the privacy link.

  • It takes you straight to Google's privacy statement which has this video.

  • We also collect info as you use our services like the searches you make, ads you interact with and visits to websites that use our services.

  • Google assumes permission to track you all the time.

  • In fact, the latest versions of reCAPTCHA don't even need you to tick a box.

  • They just use your tracking info.

  • And well done, you pass by exhibiting incompetence at every turn.

  • You must be human.

  • What?

  • Don't worry, human error looks really good on you, girl.

  • Anyway, thank you for the intel. Plato humans.

Why can't robots check the box that says "I'm not a robot."

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it