Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • On my way to the grocery store.

  • Mentally preparing myself for the sticker shock.

  • Here we are. Wish me luck.

  • Got my diapers.

  • It might be something else for you.

  • For me, diapers is really where, like, I notice inflation the most.

  • One of the things that's interesting about this particular period of inflation that we're in is this is a worldwide phenomenon.

  • Hi, Vox. My question is about inflation: What is the real cause?

  • Is it just COVID or we have others to blame? Thank you.

  • Diapers in the US, food in Ghana, and home prices in India - what actually caused all this inflation?

  • And is there something we can do about it?

  • If you watch cable news in the US, you will see one explanation for inflation that gets a lot of attention.

  • "Still too much money chasing too few goods."

  • Too much money chasing too few goods.

  • Say I have a car dealership.

  • Today, we're in a global pandemic.

  • Factories are shutting down periodically and I'm just not able to keep as many cars on my lap.

  • My inventory is low.

  • But at the same time, I have customers willing to spend money on my cars.

  • My inventory starts to dwindle, and now there is more customers than there are cars.

  • So I can just increase the price.

  • Too much money chasing too few goods.

  • Economists like this guy, Larry Summers, he's been sounding the alarm bell about this kind of inflation from the beginning.

  • I am much more worried that we'll have inflation.

  • This is the least responsible macroeconomic policies we've had in the last 40 years.

  • He is talking about those pandemic relief checks.

  • Before we can figure out if Larry Summers is right, we need to take a closer look at exactly how inflation is measured in the first place.

  • Once a month, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics puts together what it calls a market basket.

  • These data are specific to the US but you can find similar numbers around the world.

  • The BLS looks at the prices for different goods and services like housing, electricity, apparel, prescription drugs, bakery products, dairy.

  • They look at the price we're paying this month and then compare it to the price for the same good or service last month or last year.

  • Then they calculate a single percentage that captures all of that change and that's the Consumer Price Index, or CPI.

  • And it's true the consumer price index has been rising steadily for the past couple of years.

  • Here's when those stimulus checks went out.

  • But now let's take a closer look at some of the specific goods and services that make up the CPI.

  • Some things are way more expensive than this time last year like fuel oil, airline fares, gas, baked goods, dairy products.

  • But there is some stuff that's held fairly steady.

  • In a normal, healthy economy, the Federal Reserve expects for inflation to be about 2% a year.

  • And for stuff like clothing, prescription drugs, and education, prices are only slightly above that 2% mark.

  • For used cars and trucks, gasoline, and communication (that's your phone plan, Internet streaming), prices are actually lower than this time last year.

  • It seems a bit more complicated than simply: People have too much money.

  • If that were the only problem, wouldn't everything be more expensive?

  • So unfortunately for me, the Bureau of Labor Statistics doesn't actually track the price of diapers as part of the CPI.

  • But I did find a private research firm, Nielsen IQ, that does.

  • So, Nielsen looks at something called the unit price.

  • Basically, they take the box of diapers, divide it by how many diapers are in the box and that gives you the unit price.

  • They get a bunch of different brands and then come up with this average.

  • So in 2019, the average unit price for diapers was 16.1 cents.

  • If prices had gone up at that expected 2% annual inflation rate, January of 2023 would have seen me paying 17.4 cents per diaper.

  • But of course, that's not what the last few years have looked like.

  • If the price of diapers had increased at the same rate as the CPI, I would be paying 19 cents per diaper in January of 2023.

  • But no, no, no, no.

  • I am currently paying 21 cents per diaper an increase of over 30%.

  • So why is it that the price of diapers is rising so much faster than the price of all these other goods?

  • You can think of the costs of a business in a couple of ways.

  • There's the wages that you pay for workers, their investments in capital and the machinery itself, and all of that adds up to the cost of production.

  • And then there's the cost you actually sell the good at.

  • And the difference between those two costs are called a markup.

  • One of the things that makes it difficult to report on inflation is that reporters and consumers, we don't know how much it costs companies to pay their workers.

  • We don't know how much it costs them to import the materials that they need, but we can guess.

  • Take labor costs, for example.

  • We know that from 2019 to 2023, the average hourly wage for someone working in manufacturing rose by about 17%.

  • Now, that is faster than what you would expect under normal 2% annual inflation.

  • But when you consider the fact that corporations have successfully kept wages so low in the years leading up to that point that they were actually declining relative to inflation,

  • this recent bump starts to look more like a kind of return to normalcy.

  • Okay, but what about the cost of materials?

  • I went to the Pampers website and looked at what goes into making a diaper.

  • It turns out this stuff is made out of wood and these are all plastics which are made by refining petroleum in slightly different ways

  • According to the Federal Reserve's Producer Price Index, the average price for both of these materials wood pulp and plastic products has risen significantly over the past five years.

  • But both of these rising input costs still don't completely explain the price hike in diapers.

  • One of the reasons I really wanted to talk to Rakeen is that she and her colleagues have listened to hundreds and hundreds of hours of earnings calls.

  • What we found is big corporations who are jacking up prices beyond what their production cost would justify.

  • These are some transcripts of those earnings calls that Rakeen and her colleagues have been listening to.

  • The CEO of Hostess Brands, for example, says of these price hikes, "Consumers get used to it." "When all prices go up, it helps."

  • A Tyson Foods executive claimed that price increases for beef "more than offset the higher costs."

  • VISA's CEO says that historically "inflation has been a positive for us."

  • All three of these corporations experienced record profits over the past three years.

  • But what they did with those profits is instructive.

  • They paid that money out to their shareholders and raised prices for the rest of us.

  • So we have our three theories for this current moment of inflation:

  • Too much money floating around,

  • supply shocks,

  • and massive markups.

  • Unfortunately, it's probably going to be months or maybe even years before we have all of the data necessary to figure out which one of these 3 explanations holds the most weight.

  • But there are still things we can do to help bring prices down.

  • We think of inflation in a really singular way. I think that really limits the vast panoply of tools that we actually have to fight this problem.

  • Let's start with the tool that the Federal Reserve has already busted out: raising interest rates.

  • The way that works is it makes it more expensive for companies to borrow money, which makes it harder for them to invest in new projects and hire new people.

  • So far, the Fed has raised interest rates 8 times and the unemployment rate has stayed pretty low.

  • But that could change if the Fed keeps raising rates.

  • The last time inflation got super high back in the early 80s, the Fed did huge interest rate hikes and inflation did go down.

  • But look what happened to unemployment.

  • It shot way up.

  • By 1982, one in ten people were out of work.

  • In the last month of 2022, prices were starting to come down in some key areas: dairy, fruits and veggies, airline fares.

  • Prices for these two items, gasoline and fuel oil are way down.

  • And the reason likely has very little to do with raising interest rates.

  • Over the past 12 months, President Biden released millions of barrels of oil from the US emergency stockpile, which increased global supply and drove down the price.

  • There's precedent for doing this in other areas of the economy.

  • In 1939, US President Franklin Roosevelt asked Congress for nearly $900 million to help the airline industry quadruple their output.

  • "Ships, planes, tanks, guns. That is our purpose and our pledge."

  • Something Rakeen told me about diapers got me thinking about a third way we might start bringing prices down.

  • Turns out that somewhere between 70 and 80% of all the diapers produced in the US are made by two companies.

  • This honestly threw me a little bit, but then I went back and looked at some of that footage that I shot in the grocery store:

  • Luvs, Pampers, Ninjamas, those are all made by Procter & Gamble;

  • Huggies, Pull-Ups, Goodnites, all made by Kimberly-Clark.

  • So while it looks like parents have a lot of choices in the diaper aisle, we actually don't.

  • Policymakers have allowed really rampant deregulation that has facilitated these companies having so much power in a way that they can jack up prices without any cost to them.

  • That's supply dial and that corporate power dial.

  • We've let them get dusty.

  • We do not and we never did have to throw workers under the bus in order to bring down prices .

On my way to the grocery store.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it