Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • - If one opens any dictionary

  • and you go to the entry of demon,

  • one of the entries refers to the scientific demons.

  • Descartes' demons, Laplace's demon, Maxwell's demon,

  • they're not considered to be real

  • when they're first mentioned,

  • they're considered to be possibly real.

  • They're trying to find a hole in their theories.

  • They immediately anthropomorphize this force.

  • So what they are, in the most literal sense,

  • are little creatures that are concocted by scientists.

  • When they're confronted with something

  • that they don't really understand,

  • these creatures that we have always thought of

  • as little entities that can bend or break

  • the laws of nature continue to be very useful

  • and very common ways to thinking in advancing our knowledge

  • and understanding of the natural world.

  • I'm Jimena Canales, I'm a historian of science.

  • I love science; I admire it tremendously.

  • That's why I started studying,

  • but there was this other aspect of it

  • that I felt that we had to talk about.

  • It was scientists discussing demons.

  • These demons share similar characteristics

  • to those other demons in the past,

  • like Beelzebub and Lucifer, they're usually very fast

  • or very big or very small.

  • They can break the laws of nature.

  • They're not necessarily evil,

  • but they create power imbalances.

  • They can be helpful or they can be mischievous.

  • And one of the strange things about it

  • is that you read scientists in their scientific papers,

  • actually talking about these creatures

  • and having other scientists name them

  • after the famous scientist.

  • Descartes' demon is very appropriate for us to start

  • because he's the demon of virtual reality.

  • He had the ability to install an alternate reality

  • right in front of your senses.

  • Therefore you could no longer tell if you were,

  • you know, living in the matrix,

  • if you couldn't tell what the real world

  • was in front of you.

  • This was a very scary thought for Descartes.

  • I think it is for everyone.

  • It's one of the themes that continue

  • to be brought up in science fiction.

  • It was also a fascinating thought

  • because we were all fascinated by spectacle

  • and by creating these situations in which

  • we can fool ourselves to think we have reality

  • in front of us, and it's really just

  • an alternative reality or virtual reality.

  • And that's why Descartes, trying to fend himself

  • against the possibility that some demon had taken over

  • his impressions, he actually became one of the founders

  • of Modern logic, and in his famous text where he uttered

  • the phrase, "I think, therefore I am."

  • He started to think about what were the few things

  • that this demon couldn't touch.

  • And he would say things like two plus three equals five,

  • or a circle is a circumference drawn around a certain point,

  • or a triangle is made up of three lengths in three angles.

  • They're very simple things, but those became the basis

  • of modern science, of Logic,

  • and they were inspired by the fear of this demon.

  • Maxwell was a scientist of the second Industrial Revolution

  • of the Victorian Empire.

  • He didn't name the demon Maxwell's demon,

  • but he was the first to come up

  • with the speculations about it.

  • And he was named the demon by William Thompson

  • in the second half of the 19th century, I believe 1874.

  • And it was very important for physics.

  • It still is, it's at the foundation of how we understand

  • the first and second laws of thermodynamics.

  • One of the things that happens with statistical laws

  • is that statistical laws allow exceptions.

  • If you have a container or a soup and you throw ice on it,

  • eventually it will reach temperature equilibrium.

  • But if this laws is statistical,

  • and the consensus and the science says that it is,

  • then there's a chance that the opposite might happen.

  • And the demon was invoked in order to make sense

  • of the statistical nature of the laws of thermodynamics.

  • So he's a tiny little being

  • who is atomic size, and he can manipulate atoms.

  • And if he's sitting in a container,

  • he can push the fast atoms to one side

  • and let slow ones be on the other side,

  • because we understand heat as having to do

  • with the movement of particles,

  • that means that one part of a container

  • can spontaneously heat up and another one can become cooler.

  • And if you have a difference in temperature,

  • then you can create a motor.

  • And with a motor, you can create further power imbalances.

  • Most of the electronic gadgets that are all around us

  • use the science of Maxwell's demon,

  • and scientists and laboratories all over the world

  • are still trying to build

  • better versions of Maxwell's demon,

  • and they're still researching him.

  • So Darwin was speculating about a being,

  • again, he didn't call it Darwin's,

  • it was only named Darwin's being later.

  • Before he wrote the origins of a species, he had this idea.

  • He said, "What would happen if there could be a being

  • that can produce a new race?"

  • Just like we are able to produce sheep

  • with particular qualities for our sweaters,

  • but then Darwin took a leap, and he said,

  • "What if somebody could do that to us?"

  • This was one of the fascinating questions

  • that drove his research.

  • Could this actually happen?

  • He ended up calling it natural selection.

  • So natural selection in a sense, became the substitute

  • or the embodiment of this early idea.

  • Then it was called Darwin's demon later on

  • by biologists in the 1960s.

  • I started more than a decade ago,

  • tracking the references to the word demon.

  • And it is tremendous fun,

  • you know, seeing the history of science

  • and the history of technology

  • in parallel with these great imaginary ideas.

  • It gives us a sense of how malleable and how powerful

  • our desires and our fears are for driving society forward.

  • As a historian, I think it is really important

  • that we think a little bit more carefully

  • about non-existent things,

  • about things that are not yet here.

  • I understand this is original and bizarre and strange

  • to try to move our thinking about history

  • and the past and the future based on non-existent things.

  • But if we don't start thinking about them,

  • the future development of our world

  • and our technological universe is really gonna escape us.

  • So I want us to take a step back

  • and think about what we're thinking about.

  • - Get smarter, faster with new videos every week

  • from the world's biggest thinkers.

  • To learn even more from the world's biggest thinkers,

  • get "Big Think+" for your business.

- If one opens any dictionary

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it