Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • - Right now, we're living in a society in which 'Collective Illusions'

  • may be the defining feature.

  • Simply put, Collective Illusions are situations

  • where most people in a group go along with a view

  • they don't agree with because they incorrectly believe

  • that most people agree with it.

  • It's not just that we're misreading a few people,

  • it is that the majority thinks the majority

  • believes something that they don't.

  • What's most interesting is that in all of our research,

  • one of the largest illusions of all is actually about trust itself.

  • No matter how we've asked it, the vast majority of Americans

  • see themselves as trustworthy and value being trustworthy.

  • However, they believe most everybody else in society today

  • does not care about being trustworthy, and is not trustworthy.

  • There is no bigger illusion in society today

  • than the illusion of distrust itself.

  • The biggest consequence of that is that we've

  • stopped trusting each other,

  • which is fatal to free society.

  • Given the profound lack of trust in society today,

  • we often look for the cause of that in each other.

  • I don't believe that's true.

  • Frederick Taylor is probably the most important person

  • that most people have never heard of.

  • Over 100 years ago,

  • he wrote a book called "Scientific Management,"

  • which- they were about his ideas about how you create

  • a productive economy.

  • And he felt like the biggest problem in society

  • was that we weren't very efficient.

  • And so, "Scientific Management" literally said, 'Wait.

  • The first thing you got to stop doing is trusting people.'

  • He went about implementing a systems-first approach

  • to a top-down society governed by managers.

  • In fact, he invented the term manager,

  • and he made us all cogs, where the system matters most.

  • Because of the way our institutions treat us,

  • by removing choice from us

  • and fundamentally treating us as untrustworthy,

  • we have come to see each other through that lens.

  • But here's the thing

  • when you actually study honesty and trustworthiness,

  • what you find over and over again

  • is that the vast majority of people

  • are in fact trustworthy.

  • One of my favorite studies

  • it's a pretty famous German study. Here's what they did:

  • They literally just randomly called people

  • and said that there was a contest going on,

  • and all they needed to do

  • was flip a coin themselves.

  • And if it landed on tails,

  • they got a gift certificate.

  • If it landed on heads, they got nothing.

  • Now, what's important is

  • nobody knows how the coin lands

  • except for the person on the phone.

  • So you would have expected

  • everybody says tails, takes the gift certificate,

  • and the aggregate results are like, well, it's 100% tails

  • who would have thought, right?

  • That's not what happened.

  • It was almost 50/50 heads or tails.

  • And in fact, it was slightly more in favor of heads,

  • which tells me most people,

  • if not all people, were telling the truth

  • about how the coin landed

  • when no one else could possibly have known.

  • So it matters to us

  • not just that we are trustworthy,

  • but that we are viewed that way.

  • And yet we live in a society where our institutions

  • continue to remind us that this is not true,

  • that we are in some way untrustworthy.

  • We can only interact with each other in one of two ways.

  • We can trust people to make choices for themselves,

  • or we can control those choices for them.

  • It is a fundamental tenet of democracy

  • that institutions serve people.

  • But ever since Frederick Taylor,

  • we have flipped that relationship.

  • As a free people in a free society,

  • it is unacceptable

  • that our public institutions

  • treat the people as distrustful

  • because now we know that whatever efficiency

  • you get from that top-down control model,

  • the consequences in terms of human dignity

  • and social trust are so damaging

  • that that trade-off is not worth it.

  • What we need is to trust communities

  • to make decisions for themselves,

  • trust families to make decisions for themselves,

  • trust people to.

  • If you want a trusting society,

  • work to dislodge this top-down view of our institutions

  • and give more power to people.

  • Insist that our institutions

  • treat the public with trust.

  • - This series is brought to you by Stand Together,

  • a community of changemakers tackling our biggest challenges.

- Right now, we're living in a society in which 'Collective Illusions'

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it