Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Narrator: This salmon fillet didn't come from the sea.

  • It was grown in a lab to look just like the real thing.

  • There are a lot of questions that people have.

  • No. 1 question is what does it taste like?

  • Narrator: Salmon is one of the most popular fish in the US.

  • And it usually comes from massive farms like this,

  • which can cause all kinds of environmental problems.

  • Growing it from cells might one day offer an alternative.

  • It's going to be a long, very hard journey to get there.

  • Narrator: Foods made this way

  • aren't yet approved for sale in the US,

  • or anywhere in the world except Singapore.

  • And even if they were, are consumers likely

  • to see them on a menu anytime soon?

  • We went to San Francisco to try and find out.

  • For thousands of years, salmon were abundant

  • in what's now North America.

  • But in 1866, European settlers in the Pacific Northwest

  • started preserving salmon by canning it.

  • It was the start of a massive commercial fishing operation.

  • Soon, fisheries were catching millions

  • of pounds of salmon every year.

  • For a while, the supply of salmon seemed limitless.

  • But it wasn't.

  • In fact, wild salmon populations were already declining

  • by the late 1800s, and less a century later,

  • some were at risk of disappearing forever.

  • Reporter: Is there a possibility

  • of salmon becoming extinct at this rate?

  • Oh, there's no question about it.

  • Narrator: The idea of farming salmon came about

  • in the late '60s.

  • By the early 2000s, around two-thirds of the salmon Americans

  • were eating was grown on farms.

  • But that industry comes with its own problems.

  • Farmed salmon are prone to parasite infestations,

  • which can spread to wild populations.

  • And salmon feed is made partially from other fish.

  • Roughly 12% of all fish caught every year

  • are turned into feed for fish farms,

  • and that has a huge impact on global fish populations,

  • especially in places like Peru and Senegal.

  • We just need another source of fish,

  • and that's what we're here to provide.

  • Narrator: This is Aryé Elfenbein and Justin Kolbeck.

  • They cofounded Wildtype back in 2016.

  • Narrator: Their goal was to figure out

  • how to grow a piece of salmon from cells.

  • Aryé: I started to think about a lot of my background

  • in stem cell biology and wondered,

  • do we need animals to have meat?

  • Justin: One last piece. Aryé: It's yours.

  • Narrator: Wildtype isn't yet letting cameras

  • inside the lab where it grows the salmon

  • because the process is still in development.

  • Instead, Aryé explained how it all works.

  • So the first step for us

  • was to basically isolate the cells.

  • Narrator: Wildtype got the cells

  • from coho and Chinook salmon.

  • The cells go into a steel tank, like the kind you'd see

  • in a brewery, with nutrients like sugars and amino acids.

  • The tanks have the right temperature, pH,

  • and oxygen level for the cells to grow

  • and replicate the same way they would inside a fish.

  • But what comes out afterward still looks nothing

  • like a piece of salmon.

  • That's where something they call scaffolds come in.

  • So if the product is going to be a block of salmon,

  • we'll create scaffolds that are those same dimensions,

  • and then the cells will grow into those dimensions.

  • Narrator: They also help the cells mimic the textures

  • of muscle and fat.

  • The cells attach to the scaffolds and grow

  • into a shape similar to the salmon fillet you

  • would buy at a store.

  • And that, over time, becomes the final product.

  • Narrator: The growing process takes four to six weeks.

  • Compare that to the roughly three years it takes

  • to raise farmed salmon.

  • If it's still hard to wrap your head

  • around how this is possible, you're not alone.

  • Aryé and Justin introduced us to Adam Tortosa,

  • a restaurant owner and chef.

  • He works with Wildtype to test how lab-grown salmon looks,

  • tastes, and feels in real dishes.

  • Adam: This is crazy that they're growing salmon,

  • (laughs) to be honest.

  • Narrator: He says it finally looks

  • and feels pretty close to the real thing.

  • Adam: I think if you like, blindfolded me and had me cut,

  • I couldn't tell the difference.

  • This one I would dip in the soy sauce.

  • Narrator: But it wasn't always this way.

  • They walked into the restaurant and brought prototype one.

  • It was kind of wet salmon jerky, maybe.

  • Narrator: Now, he says even the taste is close.

  • Adam: It has the same mouthfeel, same fattiness.

  • Narrator: Of course, we had to try it for ourselves.

  • The flavor was mild,

  • but it really did have a texture that was close to salmon.

  • I would be happy to serve it to guests right now.

  • Narrator: Adam's restaurant is the type of place

  • where Wildtype hopes to see its salmon one day.

  • When you go to the sushi bar,

  • you're in an exploratory mindset.

  • The idea was if we're going to introduce a new way

  • to make this product, why not introduce it in a place

  • where people are already seeking out a new experience?

  • Narrator: The company decided to focus

  • on raw salmon for its initial product launch.

  • Justin: When we decided this was the way we wanted to go,

  • we had a lot of people on the team thinking like,

  • "Couldn't we start with something a little easier?"

  • Because it was very audacious.

  • Somehow, when I make cut rolls,

  • they look not as good as this.

  • Aryé: I can never get it quite right.

  • Justin: You can taste oceanic notes, not the funky fish flavor.

  • Justin: These fancy dishes are hard to eat from.

  • Aryé: This is just one starting point for the wide variety

  • of different flavors that this product is capable of.

  • Narrator: But there are still two big problems.

  • The first is that it isn't even legal

  • to sell cell-cultured foods in the US.

  • That's because the FDA is still figuring out

  • how to regulate foods that are made like this.

  • And that process just takes time, right?

  • To share how the technology works

  • and just get the people who oversee the safety

  • and security of our food system very comfortable

  • with our inputs, our processes.

  • Narrator: But it's unclear when the FDA

  • will make a decision.

  • We hope it'll be soon.

  • Narrator: The second challenge is cost.

  • Aryé: A couple pieces of nigiri these days

  • would probably cost 40 or 50 bucks, ballpark.

  • Narrator: That's the production cost,

  • which means if they started selling it right now,

  • the cost for consumers would be even higher.

  • Justin: Nobody's ever created and scaled a company

  • like this before, and we're trying as hard as we can

  • to move that along, but it is really hard.

  • Narrator: Wildtype says as they scale up,

  • the costs will come down.

  • But building large, sterile facilities is expensive,

  • and some journalists who have covered the industry,

  • like Joe Fassler, say we shouldn't expect labs

  • to create competitively priced products anytime soon.

  • I think the more realistic voices I talk to

  • in this space understand that it may be decades

  • before these products are anything more than a novelty

  • for the wealthy.

  • Narrator: It's a challenge that doesn't seem

  • to have scared investors away.

  • Wildtype recently raised $100 million,

  • with reported investments from some big names

  • like Leonard DiCaprio and Jeff Bezos,

  • even though a survey of US consumers showed

  • that only 19% were eager to try cell-cultured foods.

  • Adam: This is New Zealand farmed salmon.

  • It's what we use in the restaurant in San Francisco.

  • This is the Wildtype salmon.

  • Joe: I think lab-grown meat at the moment

  • is incredibly divisive.

  • There are some things that really recommend it,

  • and there are some things that are potentially drawbacks.

  • And there's also just a lot that we don't know.

  • Narrator: Aryé and Justin say they

  • don't expect lab-grown salmon to become the only option.

  • Aryé: Our goal is to provide a new source of fish,

  • to take the pressure off our oceans.

  • Narrator: Lab-grown salmon

  • is still a long way from that goal.

  • Justin: But I think at the end of that road lies very nutritious,

  • very accessible foods that are built on 21st-century values.

Narrator: This salmon fillet didn't come from the sea.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it