Name: Why plastic straw bans aren’t the answer.
Uploaded: 2021-06-12T11:59:06.000Z
Duration: 9 min 8 s
Description: Thousands of YouTube videos with English-Chinese subtitles! Now you can learn to understand native speakers, expand your vocabulary, and improve your pronunciation...

Basic passive voice

If hang around til the end, I'll give you a link to try 2-months of Skillshare for free!

Adverbs of manner

It's 3,000 BCE, and it's an unbearably hot day in Sumer, a civilization which thrived

Under the bright sun, two Sumerians quench their thirst with a nice wheat beer.

Their fermentation process often leaves some unwanted solid byproducts floating at the

top of their drink that are hard to avoid.

Crafted from bone, metal, or even organic materials like reed, Sumerians used the straw

as a way to safeguard their sipping activities from bugs, grain husks, and any sort of sediment

that may have happened to sneak into their drinks.

Fast-forward thousands of years and straws are still very much a staple across the globe.

But now these straws are plastic (and bendy).

A fact to which many environmentalists take umbrage.

So much so, that plastic straw bans have now been enacted in Vancouver, Seattle, as well

Despite the recent passage of these bans, I'm curious about their effectiveness.

Today, I want to figure out whether straw bans are effective, but more importantly,

what are the ramifications of banning plastic straws?

One number, at least for me, puts straw bans into a broader context: .025%.

According to Phys.org, plastic straws account for only .025% of the total mass of trash

According to the Ocean Conservancy's annual clean up report they pulled 643,542 straws

or roughly .26 metric tonnes from the ocean in 2018.

Scientists Denise Hardesty and Chris Wilcox estimate that there could be as much as 8.3

billion plastic straws on the world's coastlines.

But when you consider that a straw weighs .4 grams, 8 billion straws equate to roughly

While that is a large number, it's remarkably small compared to the 8 million metric tons

of pieces of plastic that enter the ocean annually.

So, straws are just a small part of a much larger ocean trash problem.

In fact, if we look at the make-up of trash in the Great Pacific Garbage Patch, fishing

So, plastic straws are not a large part of the piling mountain of trash, but they are

For that reason, the possibility of straw bans is cropping up in major metropolises

And part of the reason people are so eager to ban them is that they seem like low hanging

Most people can get away with not using them.

But this seemingly linear connection between banning single-use plastic straws and minimizing

environmental impact is more nuanced upon closer inspection.

In fact, calls for straw bans have experienced strong pushback from the people with disabilities,

Eliminating plastic straws is a prime example of eco-ableism.

But to understand straws and ultimately eco-ableism, we need to first discuss spoons.

In a blog post for the University of Alabama's Institute for Human Rights, Marlee Townsend

describes the concept of spoon theory initially coined by blogger Christine Miserandino.

Townsend writes that within this spoon theory metaphor, able-bodied people wake up every

day with an infinite amount of spoons, while people with disabilities only wake up with

Every activity, like putting on socks or brushing your teeth requires a spoon.

People with disabilities have to be deliberate with how they spend their spoons.

Otherwise, as Townsend writes, they'll be out of spoons before lunch, immobilized and

So not having access to a bendy straw, requires spending a spoon whenever someone wants to

In short, straw bans represent an instance of eco-ableism because in our haste to frontline

environmental concerns, able-bodied people have made the lives of disabled folks harder

At this point, you might be saying, “Hey, but what about the other straw alternatives!!”

You're right, there are currently paper, metal, and bamboo straws out there that restaurants

have started to use, but unfortunately they are not as easy to use, durable, and flexible

In an op-ed in The Guardian disability rights activist, Penny Pepper, tackles this issue

She notes that flexibility is one of the key reasons why plastic straws are so useful because

it's much easier to get the right angle for safe drinking, especially when you can't

hold a cup or even if another person holds it for you.”

Metal and bamboo straws are often too hard or wide, which can prove problematic for people

Alternatives also may be too costly, be a choking hazard, cause an allergic reaction,

or might not be able to hold up to high temperatures.

But to believe that people with disabilities are at odds with the environmental movement

In her op-ed Pepper goes on to write, “The irritating thing is that somehow disabled

people are tainted as not caring about environmental issues.

The truth, in my experience, is that many actually care more…

I don't actually want to use harmful chemicals in the interests of my personal care.”

In essence, straw bans seem to be such a small portion of ocean plastic.

The environmental good that bans will create will be minimal.

We have not listened to or considered the effects a straw ban will have on disabled

If indeed, cleaning up ocean trash is our goal, then the management of fishing nets

and refuse, which make up a larger percentage ocean trash, might be a much better use of

The point here is that straws are just a small piece of the plastic problem, and other areas

of waste management would have a greater effect on our global drawdown of plastic use.

Straw bans show environmental action can't be done unilaterally and without viable alternatives

It's not just that marginalized people will have it worse if the environmental movement

continues to ignore and create forms of oppression, it's that we cannot do any of this work without

Most oppressed communities experience the worst of the world and therefore also tend

to have the most radical solutions and build the most successful movements.

Despite the amount of time I spend honing my flashy graphics and slick visuals, the

hardest part about making videos is writing a well-crafted story.

At the end of the day, if the script isn't good, then the video isn't good.

That's why I've recently turned to Skillshare to learn more about developing strong narratives

Subtitles ListPlay Video

Why plastic straw bans aren’t the answer.

process

deliberate

access

eliminate