Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • - [Host] Thanks to Skillshare for sponsoring this episode.

  • This was humanity's first introduction

  • to nuclear power, the atomic bomb.

  • - And this is a nuclear power plant,

  • which you may know from all the times

  • that they've broken down in history

  • and scared the crap out of people.

  • Hello, HBO's Chernobyl.

  • - But you've actually been lied to about nuclear energy.

  • And in order to understand those lies,

  • we first have to talk about where the energy comes from.

  • - In 1938, scientists discovered nuclear fission.

  • They did this by slamming an atom of uranium with a neutron.

  • It would divide into two

  • and release a large amount of energy.

  • Not only this, but during the nuclear fission reaction

  • up to three neutrons are ejected,

  • which can trigger further fission reactions of more atoms,

  • meaning more energy is released.

  • This is known as a chain reaction.

  • - During World War II,

  • America would use the same technology

  • to create the first atomic bomb.

  • But it wasn't until 1955 that the same scientific principles

  • were used to create the first nuclear power plant

  • that generated electricity.

  • - In the 1970s, psychologists started to map

  • people's anxieties about nuclear destruction

  • and the past cold war, onto nuclear power plants,

  • which were now cropping up around the world.

  • Then came the 1979 thriller, The China Syndrome,

  • a movie about a fictional nuclear reactor meltdown.

  • Which was released on March 6th, 1979.

  • And just 22 days later,

  • a real partial nuclear reactor meltdown

  • happened at Three Mile Island.

  • Talk about free advertisement for your movie.

  • The coincidence of a Hollywood film

  • and this cultural nuclear reactor breakdown

  • coming together really shot into the mainstream

  • this negative connotation with nuclear energy.

  • From the release of this movie to 1988,

  • 67 planned nuclear power plants were canceled.

  • In 1986 Chernobyl happened, which was caused by human error.

  • As the temperature of the reactor core became too high

  • and an explosion created a nuclear cloud across Europe.

  • I scream cried while watching Chernobyl.

  • I remember thinking to myself, okay,

  • is nuclear energy a truly invisible horror?

  • Right after that, in 1989, we got The Simpsons

  • where we see people diving into nuclear waste.

  • And our favorite idiot, Homer,

  • who we all picture as a safety inspector

  • at a nuclear reactor.

  • As recent as 2011, we have the Fukushima nuclear disaster.

  • And all of this combined made it really hard

  • to not be afraid of nuclear energy.

  • - But when you look more into it, you find that

  • no one died at Three Mile Island.

  • And most epidemiological studies found

  • that it had no detectable health consequences.

  • After 30 years, only 51 people died from

  • the incident at Chernobyl.

  • And scientific studies found few health risks

  • connected to radiation exposure after Fukushima.

  • - Take this recent In a Nutshell video

  • linked in the description.

  • It shows how using coal, oil, natural gas,

  • and biomass has killed 100 million people

  • in the past 50 years.

  • This was due to pollution created by

  • the byproducts of burning fossil fuels.

  • - The World Health Organization explains

  • that it's safer to work in a nuclear power plant

  • than in a big city office,

  • as the urban air pollution of ozone, sulfur dioxide,

  • carbon monoxide, and nitrogen dioxide

  • causes 7 million deaths annually

  • - Only 0.005% of the average American's

  • yearly radiation dose comes from nuclear power.

  • This is 200 times less than a cross country flight,

  • a hundred times less than what we get from coal,

  • and about the same as eating one banana per year?

  • Wait, so if I'm scared of nuclear energy

  • I also have to be scared of a banana?

  • But like peanut butter and bananas on toast is my culture.

  • Also being gay, I hate holding bananas like this

  • 'cause it just reminds me of getting bullied.

  • - [Host] There's also this study, showing that a CT scan

  • of the abdomen involves about 10 times

  • the radiation exposure that the average

  • nuclear worker gets in a year

  • - Or that living in a big polluted city

  • increases your mortality risk by 2.8 times

  • that of a Chernobyl cleanup worker.

  • So what is happening?

  • Is nuclear energy dangerous or safe?

  • - But just before we get to that,

  • we wanna thank today's sponsor Skillshare.

  • The first 1,000 people to use the link in our description

  • get a free trial of Skillshare premium membership.

  • So go check it out because it goes fast.

  • Skillshare's actually how I improved

  • my own animation skills to animate this channel

  • with Greg's drawings.

  • I also taught myself Photoshop using Skillshare.

  • And it's just an amazing way to continue

  • to learn and grow your brain.

  • - Skillshare is an online learning community

  • with thousands of classes for curious and creative people.

  • You can explore new skills or deepen current passions.

  • Like this course that I took for beginner birders,

  • where it actually taught me

  • to correctly identify mourning doves.

  • It was so exciting.

  • It turns out that their wings make a specific type of noise.

  • Eek!

  • I'm obsessed with birding.

  • Or this class about electricity generation,

  • where you can take a deep dive

  • into solar, wind, and nuclear energy.

  • And actually understand the physics

  • and mechanics of generating this electricity.

  • This was integral for me making this video

  • - It's curated specifically for learning,

  • meaning that there are no ads.

  • And they're always launching new premium classes.

  • At the cost of $10 a month with an annual subscription,

  • which is amazing.

  • - So you can help our show

  • by clicking the link in the description.

  • And the first 1,000 people will get

  • a free trial of premium membership.

  • This genuinely is how you guys can support us

  • here at ASAP Science.

  • Now let's get back to the core of this video,

  • about the nuclear reactor's core.

  • These reactors use low enriched uranium

  • and controlled chain reactions to heat pressurized water,

  • which in turn heats other water in a secondary circuit

  • that causes steam to rotate a turbine,

  • which is linked to a generator that creates electricity.

  • Cool water from a river or ocean can be pumped in

  • to cool the water in the secondary circuit.

  • Or, sometimes cooling towers are built.

  • Like these iconic bad boys

  • that we all know and love from The Simpsons.

  • - Current research has found that American opinions

  • haven't changed much on nuclear energy since the cold war,

  • which is weird because it feels like culture has shifted.

  • Kids no longer learn to hide under their desks

  • in preparation for nuclear war.

  • Now they learned to hide under their desks

  • for preparation of a mass shooter.

  • In fact, 54% of Americans still oppose nuclear energy today.

  • So let's talk nuclear power plant safety.

  • A Harvard study found that newer generations

  • of nuclear reactors, particularly what is called

  • pebble-bed reactors, are designed so that

  • the nuclear chain reaction cannot run away

  • and cause a meltdown.

  • Even in the event of a complete failure

  • of the reactor's machinery.

  • And that with the advent of modern reactors,

  • such as the pebble-bed reactor,

  • and careful selection of plant sites,

  • nuclear accidents like the one in Fukushima

  • are actually not possible.

  • But some people think that emphasizing safety

  • actually just emphasizes fear.

  • Airlines don't advertise how safe they are

  • because then you would just be thinking about

  • crashing the whole time you were on the plane.

  • And the fact that you need to look

  • next to the stranger beside you and be like,

  • I love you, I'm sorry, goodbye.

  • While you're screaming, and the plane's shaking,

  • and you have to cover your head,

  • and apparently your legs break on impact.

  • - So maybe nuclear energy should use the airline's approach

  • and stop explaining why they're safe,

  • and start unapologetically explaining how great they are.

  • Nuclear reactors, such as Diablo Canyon,

  • which will be closed in 2024 due to cost upkeep,

  • accounts for roughly 9% of California's energy

  • but occupies fewer than 600 acres.

  • Honestly, that's wowsers to think of that much energy

  • coming out of that little Diablo Canyon.

  • There are currently 56 nuclear power plants

  • operating in the US that provide the country

  • with roughly 20% of the electrical supply.

  • That's more than half of the US's low carbon electricity.

  • The NASA Goddard Institute predicts that

  • nuclear power has prevented 1.84 million deaths

  • that would have occurred if the energy

  • was produced by fossil fuels.

  • This is 370 times more lives saved

  • than have been lost to any nuclear power plant issues

  • in the last 40 years.

  • At this point, I feel very lied to.

  • But, what about the nuclear waste?

  • - 97% of the waste created by nuclear plants

  • is classified as low or intermediate level waste.

  • All the nuclear waste in the US is often compared to

  • the size of a football field piled 50 feet high.

  • The world nuclear association describes that

  • the waste is encapsulated in highly engineered casks,

  • in stable vitrified form, and is placed at depths

  • well below the biosphere.

  • Such long-term geological storage solutions

  • are designed to prevent any movement

  • of radioactivity for thousands of years.

  • So even in the event of an earthquake or a natural disaster

  • these repositories will keep the waste

  • from reaching the surface and releasing radiation.

  • In addition, 96% of this waste can be recycled

  • to make new fuel and byproducts.

  • - So the nuclear power industry

  • puts their waste in monitored concrete casks,

  • deep into the ground, but the coal, oil,

  • and natural gas industries release their waste

  • into the atmosphere.

  • Where it causes pollution

  • and kills thousands of people a year,

  • and like all the birds.

  • And these greenhouse gases contribute to

  • the sixth largest mass extinction that we are currently in,

  • and to the climate crisis that we are currently in.

  • So is it safe?

  • Well, nuclear energy is definitely safer

  • than the fossil fuels that we are addicted to right now.

  • - The fear of nuclear energy is getting in the way

  • of us having an honest discussion of how it can work

  • with renewable energy to get us to a zero carbon future.

  • As stated, the US gets 20% of its electricity

  • from nuclear power plants.

  • France gets 70% from nuclear.

  • Impressive research at MIT analyzed 1,000 scenarios

  • of getting to our zero carbon future.

  • And all the cheapest paths involved nuclear

  • helping renewable energy, get to where it needs to be.

  • - Focusing in on America,

  • there is a scenario where you can get to

  • a zero carbon future with just renewables

  • and leaving the existing nuclear power plants on.

  • But this is specific to America

  • because America is rich in renewable energy opportunities.

  • It's got the windy Texas, the super sunny California.

  • Many other parts of the world do not have the ability

  • to rely on renewable energy in this way.

  • It's for this reason that the UK has put nuclear

  • front and center for how it's gonna get to

  • zero carbon emissions, 'cause they can't really

  • rely on solar and wind in the same way.

  • China is also currently building nuclear reactors

  • due to their increasing consumption of energy.

  • - Now, up to this point, we've ignored

  • a really important part of this conversation.

  • The economics.

  • Explained really well in this real engineering video,

  • linked in the description,

  • nuclear power plants are extremely expensive to create.

  • Since 1996, only one nuclear power plant

  • has been made in the US.

  • And likely due to the cost, not fear.

  • Take the crappy scenario in South Carolina

  • where a $9 billion nuclear plant wasn't finished.

  • And now the people of South Carolina are paying for it,

  • even though it's releasing no energy.

  • - But innovation in the nuclear power space

  • could make reactors that are smaller

  • and much more cost-effective.

  • We all know that we need to scale up renewable energy.

  • And there have been amazing strides made across the Earth.

  • But we can't allow our irrational fear

  • of nuclear energy to stop its ability to innovate.

  • A great start would be to look at

  • the climate platform drafted by John Kerry and AOC,

  • which included a plan to create cost effective pathways

  • for developing innovative reactors.

  • The biggest lie about nuclear energy

  • is the way it's been depicted towards us in culture.

  • Whether it's from The Simpsons,

  • which honestly made me honestly scared about nuclear energy.

  • That lie is real.

  • I feel like I was so scared about nuclear energy

  • until I started to do all this research about

  • the climate crisis and realized that we probably need it.

  • - I think the biggest takeaway from this

  • is that we need to stop the infighting.

  • We're all against the fossil fuel industry.

  • And we wanna save this planet.

  • And we wanna get to net zero carbon emission as a society.

  • And it's a great option for us to come together.

  • - Whenever we talk about nuclear energy on our channel

  • the comments are heated.

  • It's like a cold war, okay.

  • People who are pro-nuclear are like,

  • if we don't use nuclear

  • we're gonna become tree hugging lefties

  • and like marry a solar panel.

  • And people who are anti-nuclear energy are like,

  • if we use it we're all gonna die.

  • And I'm just like, okay, we need to stop this infighting

  • because we need to be talking about

  • the dangerous fossil fuels that we know

  • and are currently killing all of us.

  • So where do we go from here?

  • We want your help with this.

  • This is not a simple answer.

  • So please, in the comments, let us know what you think.

  • Have you been scared of nuclear energy?

  • Is nuclear energy something that you believe in,

  • something that you're against?

  • We will be there and we will be responding to you.

  • - And maybe we'll be talking about

  • the new nuclear fusion reactor as well, which is so cool.

  • So check out the links in the description

  • and we'll see you there.

  • - Thank you so much for watching

  • and we will see you next week for a new science video,

  • or maybe a climate change video.

  • Peace. - See ya.

- [Host] Thanks to Skillshare for sponsoring this episode.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it