Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • MIRANDA GREEN: OK, here we go.

  • We're going to try again.

  • Boris's Brexit Map--

  • ROBERT SHRIMSLEY: Part Two.

  • MIRANDA GREEN: So Robert, two weeks ago we

  • tried to map Boris Johnson's options

  • to get us through the Brexit morass.

  • ROBERT SHRIMSLEY: Model of clarity.

  • MIRANDA GREEN: A model of clarity

  • as our viewers can see here before us.

  • Time's been ticking.

  • It's now only 20 days to the October 31st Brexit deadline,

  • but a lot has actually changed since we last spoke.

  • So should we have another go--

  • ROBERT SHRIMSLEY: We'll do this again.

  • MIRANDA GREEN: --and try to work out what happens next?

  • ROBERT SHRIMSLEY: I don't think there's anything in here that

  • has yet proved to be wrong, but that we

  • have got more information.

  • So let's have another go.

  • MIRANDA GREEN: So let's move on.

  • Let's move on.

  • Let's move on.

  • The things that we definitely do know, the deadline--

  • 31st October.

  • And then before that, the 19th of October.

  • So here we are, 11th, 12th.

  • And then there's the summit on the 16th.

  • The summit.

  • So it looks like here we all are we actually

  • have more of a chance of a deal than no deal,

  • or certainly than last time we spoke.

  • It's cheered up a bit because discussions

  • between the UK and Ireland--

  • ROBERT SHRIMSLEY: It's definitely cheered up

  • this week.

  • It looked really grim for most of the week,

  • and then Boris Johnson and Leo Varadkar met in the Wirral

  • on Thursday.

  • And to a lot of people's surprise, I think,

  • the noise out of it were much more positive.

  • Varadkar said he saw a pathway to a deal, which is obviously

  • not the same as a deal.

  • One analyst I saw raised the chances from 5% to 10%.

  • So we should keep some sense of perspective.

  • But we will know, I think, within the next 24 to 48 hours

  • whether the European Union thinks

  • there is enough movement for it to be worth

  • starting to negotiate.

  • So it's far too early at the moment

  • to say there's going to be a deal,

  • but it looks a little less unlikely than it

  • did earlier this week.

  • But no deal is definitely still alive as a possibility.

  • MIRANDA GREEN: So sticking to the deal for now,

  • there's the question of whether Boris Johnson can strike a deal

  • with the EU that satisfies both the Republic of Ireland

  • and the Northern Ireland Unionists-- the DUP--

  • and his own right wing, and possibly tempt across 20 to 30

  • Labour MPs to support it in the House of Commons.

  • How on earth do you get a deal that satisfies

  • all those groups of people?

  • Because their needs are mutually exclusive.

  • Or do you think just the pressure of getting further

  • along this timeline is making people

  • more likely to compromise?

  • ROBERT SHRIMSLEY: Well, I don't know the odds.

  • Getting a deal that everybody can sign up to

  • is really difficult, especially a deal

  • that the Democratic Unionists and the Republic of Ireland

  • can sign up to.

  • And we know how hard that is, because we watched the Good

  • Friday Agreement, and we know how long it took.

  • And almost by definition, the moment one of those sides

  • is happy, the other one's unhappy.

  • So it is very tricky.

  • We know Boris Johnson talked to Arlene Foster in the DUP

  • before his meeting with Varadkar.

  • So whatever concessions he has put forward,

  • he must at least have talked to the DUP about them

  • and felt able to go a bit further.

  • So we shall see.

  • The numbers remain absolutely horrible and incredibly tight.

  • And I think there are two dynamics here, one of which

  • is that there are all these people just

  • desperate not to leave without a deal,

  • and don't really want an election where no deal could

  • become viable at the end of it.

  • MIRANDA GREEN: Absolutely.

  • ROBERT SHRIMSLEY: And then the others who think,

  • but if we sign up for this deal, it's Brexit, it's happened.

  • And our hopes for a referendum, our hopes of getting

  • this reversed are gone.

  • So the numbers in parliament are horribly tight.

  • The referendum had an interesting point,

  • and I know you think this has got more likely.

  • MIRANDA GREEN: I do.

  • So one thing that we have left off are groups of people he has

  • to satisfy actually-- apart from the EU,

  • which I definitely add--

  • is also the sort of one nation Tories, who

  • are extremely concerned that if we get to a general election

  • where Brexit has not been resolved either

  • through an election referendum or some other means,

  • that the Tory Party manifesto will make it possible

  • for them to claim after the election

  • that they have a mandate for no deal.

  • So one of the things that's happened since we last spoke

  • is that this group has become much more vocal

  • in trying to put pressure on Number 10

  • on the subject of no deal.

  • The other thing that I think is really interesting

  • is that the chances of all of these groups in Parliament

  • who essentially don't agree on what should be in a Brexit deal

  • might be persuaded to sign up to it

  • and at least pass it on condition that it's then

  • put to a referendum.

  • And I think the chances of that have gone up.

  • ROBERT SHRIMSLEY: Before we get to the referendum,

  • can we just stick on this for a minute?

  • Because I think there has been a lot of briefing and counter

  • briefing.

  • This is one of the really important things

  • is the noises of.

  • And [INAUDIBLE] and the one nation Tories, up to 50 of them

  • said they couldn't support a Conservative manifesto

  • in a general election, which essentially the party ran

  • on no deal.

  • And the reason they said that is because if it

  • is a no deal into a general election,

  • the Brexit Party have made lots of noises saying they

  • can't support the Conservatives unless it's no deal,

  • or as they also like to call it, clean Brexit.

  • They have a flair for phraseology.

  • Whether these people really mean it-- thus far,

  • the one nation Tories that have stayed in the party I've

  • been a tower of jelly.

  • So whether they would really go through with it, I don't know.

  • I think they are still desperate to get a deal

  • over the line, almost any deal.

  • Which is why I think the referendum point comes back

  • into play.

  • MIRANDA GREEN: So the one nation Tories

  • are really worried that you'd end up with a Tory Party

  • standing on a platform that even if it wasn't promising no deal,

  • would commit them to it, facilitate it.

  • And would mean that if they won a general election, won

  • a majority or even the largest party again, they could say,

  • we have a mandate to do this.

  • We have a mandate to crash Britain out.

  • I've also spoken to some of the Labour MPs who,

  • although they are sort of softening their red lines as it

  • were, they've started to say, so long as the EU is happy,

  • we're happy.

  • Which is quite interesting in and of itself, I think.

  • But those Labour rebels are also really worried about the idea

  • of having a general election in which it turns into a proxy

  • Brexit referendum where people vote on lots of other issues,

  • and you end up with no deal.

  • Because these Labour rebels, they might be willing

  • to support a deal.

  • They sure as hell are not willing to support a no deal

  • Brexit.

  • So you've got these--

  • ROBERT SHRIMSLEY: Of course, then they're going to lose.

  • MIRANDA GREEN: Well, that's right, exactly.

  • They wouldn't be worried if they thought Jeremy Corbyn was going

  • to sweep the board, clearly.

  • But I think the other intervention this week

  • that's been interesting is Tony Blair,

  • the former Labour prime minister, who's always--

  • he has always, we should say, been