Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • This is Anna; she just graduated from college in the United States.

  • And this is Sophia.

  • She also just graduated from college in Finland.

  • Anna and Sophia both want to be middle school teachers.

  • But it turns out, there's a good chance their experiences will be very different.

  • So different that Anna is twice as likely as Sophia to leave teaching for good.

  • That's causing a problem.

  • The supply of new certified teachers in the United States is shrinking, but the number of public school students keeps growing.

  • Massive teacher shortages.

  • Warnings about teacher turnover.

  • Educators call Colorado's teacher shortage a crisis.

  • So, what makes Sophia stay and Anna leave?

  • And how can the United States keep more of its teachers in the classroom?

  • In the US, teachers work about nine and a quarter hours a day.

  • That's an hour and a half longer than the average for teachers in other countries in the Organization for Economic Development or OECD for short.

  • That's a group of mostly wealthy countries that economists often compare to one another.

  • Teachers in the US work more than two and a half hours longer than their colleagues in South Korea, Finland, and Israel.

  • There are some countries with similar teacher work hours to the United States, like New Zealand, Singapore, and the UK.

  • Teachers in Japan, for example, work nearly two hours more per day than teachers in the US, but in all of these countries, teaching hours are much lower.

  • Of the nine and a quarter hours that American teachers work every day, they spend about five and a half of those hours actually teaching.

  • That's more than the OECD average and significantly more than teachers in New Zealand, the UK, South Korea, Japan, and Singapore.

  • Teachers in these countries get more time for planning, grading, and collaborating with each other.

  • So, do all those extra teaching hours translate to better results?

  • Students in the US score slightly above the OECD average on the PISA exam, which tests 15-year-olds all over the world in reading, science, and math.

  • But they score lower than students in countries like Finland, South Korea, Japan, and Singapore, where teaching hours are much lower.

  • If we look inside Anna and Sofia's classrooms in the US and Finland, we'd see Anna teaching an hour and a half more per day than Sofia.

  • Anna also spends more time planning lessons, grading student work, and leading extracurricular activities.

  • But those extra hours aren't necessarily reflected in Anna's paycheck.

  • If you compare Sofia to other people in Finland with college degrees, she makes about 98 cents for every dollar that they make.

  • That's on par with the pay ratio between teachers and college graduates in similar countries.

  • But Anna and other American middle school teachers only make about 65 cents for every dollar that their college-educated peers make.

  • Still, as politicians in the US never tire of pointing out,

  • - ... we spend more... - We spend more per student than almost....

  • - ... any country I think... - ... than nearly every other country in the developed world.

  • But that figure varies a lot by state.

  • New York spends twice as much as California on each student.

  • Mississippi spends less than half as much as Alaska.

  • And American schools generally spend a lot more on security and other non-instructional costs than schools in other countries.

  • Plus, if you look at the share of its national wealth, or GDP, that each country spends on education, you can see there are plenty of countries spending a bigger share than the US.

  • There's one other difference between Anna and Sofia.

  • When they're asked whether people in their country value teachers, two out of three Finnish teachers say yes.

  • But just one in three American teachers agree.

  • There are a lot of reasons why teachers like Anna leave the classroom, but if the US wants to keep more of them around, we might want to take a few pages from Finland's book.

This is Anna; she just graduated from college in the United States.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it