Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • So spooky action at a distance was Einstein’s kind of appellation for the idea of nonlocality.

  • Non-locality is the technical term for it. So the example I often give is two coins.

  • So you can treat some of these particles as having two possible outcomes of a measurement.

  • And you can think about it as heads or tails of a coin. So you create two of them. You

  • give one to your friend. Your friend goes off somewhere and you keep the other. And

  • you both flip the coin and you come up with heads, they come up with heads. You come up

  • with tails, they come up with tails. Heads, tails. It just goes back and forth. And yet

  • theyre the same answer on both sides.

  • So this non-local connection among these particles or whatever kind of object is bearing that

  • connection seems to violate our intuition from Einstein’s Theory of Relativity. So

  • that theory among other things said that influences in nature are limited by the speed of light.

  • So you can’t have any kind of subspace radio or answerable like they have in science fiction.

  • There has to be a limit to the speed at which influences the signals can propagate. So these

  • particles which can exist on the opposite sides of the universe seem to disobey that

  • principle. But the situation’s kind of subtle and the reason it’s subtle is that the particles

  • are unable to send an ordinary communication. You can’t use them to radio signal or have

  • some kind of telemetry or remote control across that gap. And the reason is quite simple.

  • The reasons are the outcomes of those particle experiments or the flips of the coin are random.

  • So they just come up heads or tails and heads or tails and you can’t decide is it heads

  • or is it tails. So youve got no way to manipulate the coin and thereby produce an

  • outcome at the distant location. So you can’t communicate. You can’t send a signal. So

  • on the one hand the phenomena seems to violate relativity theory. But on the other hand it

  • kind of pulls back from the precipice. It doesn’t actually violate it in a practical

  • sense. You can’t send a signal faster than light.

  • It still however poses kind of a theoretical conundrum. Why are these particles able to

  • coordinate their behavior even though theyre so far apart. So there’s a tension with

  • Einstein’s Theory of Relativity not perhaps an outright observed contradiction of the

  • theory.

  • The question of why these particles can coordinate, why these coins can land on the same side

  • no matter where they might be is really it could be very perplexing. And Einstein was

  • troubled by it. He thought the particles for instance were basically had a mechanism in

  • them or some kind of like gimmick built into them like a magician would have kind of a

  • trick coin. And he thought the particles were also like trick coins that they were preprogrammed

  • to land on one side or the other. But in the 60s and 70s that particular explanation was

  • ruled out. So the other possibility is that there might be some kind of signal going between

  • them. But that seems to be ruled out because you couldn’t do the experiment kind of in

  • synchrony. You can do it at the same time and yet the coins can still act in a coordinated

  • way. So youre kind of left with like what’s going on. It’s just a mystery here. There’s

  • almost like a magical magic wand or Obi-Wan sensing the disruption of all Alderaan kind

  • of situation going on here. It’s kind of a magical situation. So the thinking today

  • is that it represents a violation, a kind of undermining of space, the very fabric of

  • space.

  • That things in the universe seem to be located far apart from one another. They have individual

  • locations and they need to interact by mechanisms that propagate within space. And these particles

  • violate that expectation so it seems to indicate that space itself is somehow not fundamental.

  • It’s not a real or deep feature of reality.

So spooky action at a distance was Einstein’s kind of appellation for the idea of nonlocality.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it