Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • In December 2022, $1,981 was the typical monthly rent in

  • the United States.

  • A 7.4% increase from the year prior.

  • The Covid pandemic, along with record breaking

  • inflation, drove up rent prices in America to

  • unprecedented levels.

  • As the pandemic was alleviating, people were

  • going back into the housing market, and that created a

  • really significant pressure on supply.

  • In terms of what's happening right now, we are

  • already seeing those prices falling and they're falling

  • at a fairly rapid rate.

  • Rents are going down now.

  • We ended 2022 with four straight months of rent

  • cuts. And then in January, rents were flat for the

  • first time since the great financial crisis.

  • But while rent has begun to stabilize nationwide, rent

  • affordability still remains difficult for many

  • Americans.

  • All you need is one illness.

  • All you need is one pandemic to make your life

  • more difficult.

  • There's literally nowhere in the country where a tenant

  • is not burdened by their rent.

  • More than 19 million renters in America are rent

  • burdened, spending more than 30% of their income on

  • housing costs. Evictions are also climbing rapidly

  • with the end of Covid-era protections.

  • There have been more than 2 million evictions since

  • March of 2020.

  • Indeed, just ten states and 34 cities tracked by The

  • Eviction Lab. In response, support for rent control

  • policies has gained traction.

  • We've already seen rent control be implemented in

  • California, Oregon, in cities like Washington,

  • D.C., and New York City, as well as Saint Paul in

  • Minnesota. So I would say it's definitely making a

  • comeback.

  • So can policy make rent more affordable in the United

  • States? And if so, what would those policies be?

  • Rent regulation refers to laws that limit rental

  • prices in cities or states.

  • Generally, it comes in two types: rent control and rent

  • stabilization.

  • To me, they're basically the same for this kind of modern

  • generation of rent control laws, I think.

  • In New York City they do make a distinction between

  • rent control and rent stabilization.

  • That's basically because there is a very old housing

  • stock there built before the war, essentially 1940,

  • 47. Those are under true rent control, meaning that

  • they fixed the level of rent.

  • But then the modern wave of rent control policies

  • typically allows more flexibility in the amount of

  • rent increases. In California, the annual

  • allowable increase in rent is about 5% plus the changes

  • in local consumer price indices, or 10%, whichever

  • is lower.

  • Today just seven states, California, Maine, Maryland,

  • Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, and Oregon, and

  • District of Columbia have some form of rent control at

  • the state or local level.

  • Experts say that rent control policies that

  • specifically target low income tenants could be

  • beneficial.

  • When I talk about targeted rent control, I'm really

  • speaking about affordable housing programs like the

  • low income housing tax credit, where low income

  • households can qualify to live in a quality rental

  • property at a well below market rent.

  • And those rents are set based on income year after

  • year. And so it's a very positive program because

  • you're directing the aid specifically to those who

  • need it.

  • Tenants living with rent stabilization say it plays a

  • big role in their financial stability.

  • Thalia Da Costa, a New York City tenant living in a

  • rent-stabilized apartment, has experienced what it's

  • like firsthand.

  • The problem with working in the entertainment field is

  • that you don't know when your next gig is coming.

  • When Covid happened, I had no idea where rent was

  • coming from. Luckily, we had a lot of programs to

  • help out with that, but I was still down $60 to

  • $75,000. Once I learned the laws with rent

  • stabilization, like it's a totally different ball game.

  • They protect us.

  • They have to treat our apartment better.

  • So I feel really sorry for people who don't live in a

  • rent stabilized apartment because you have no idea if

  • your rent is going to go up $500.

  • Rent control could help boost a sense of community

  • by preventing unfair displacement and

  • gentrification.

  • This is where my grandmother bought a house in 1958.

  • This is where my mom moved at 15 and went to high

  • school up the street.

  • Rent stabilization keeps diversity.

  • A socioeconomic mix is why I live here.

  • There are people on welfare.

  • There are $4 million homes right on this street that I

  • was born on. I don't like the homogenized

  • neighborhoods that plague New York.

  • That's not New York.

  • This isn't the first time that rent control policies

  • have gained widespread support.

  • After the massive economic disruption caused by World

  • War II, the Federal Government once imposed rent

  • control on roughly 80% of rental housing between 1941

  • and 1964.

  • But over time, it was abandoned because prominent

  • economists unanimously argued against the policy.

  • That sentiment mostly continues today.

  • There's various surveys of economists. One done by IMG

  • showed that only 2% thought that rent controls in places

  • like New York and San Francisco were having a

  • positive impact on affordable housing.

  • There's been other studies showing that the removal of

  • rent control has actually had a positive impact on

  • communities.

  • Economists argue that rent control would deter

  • developers from building more houses, which would

  • only worsen the housing supply crisis in the United

  • States. America already suffers from a deficit of

  • 3.8 million homes, especially at low income

  • price points, according to Habitat for Humanity.

  • We have not invested as a nation in building a supply

  • of housing in a variety of communities and a variety of

  • different price points.

  • We've instead relied on the private sector to do so.

  • And the private sector has the expertise to leverage

  • that capital and the expertise and the knowhow to

  • build those units. But unless that money comes into

  • the market and investors see that as a better

  • investment than some other kind of equity or some other

  • kind of investment, they're not going to come.

  • Preventing healthy turnover in the housing market could

  • also hurt marginalized communities.

  • If there's a rent stabilization program in

  • place, you're really incentivizing the renter

  • that's in that unit today not to move.

  • And what does that mean for renters that want to be in

  • that neighborhood or want access to housing?

  • They're shut out because that private market capital

  • isn't available to build additional units.

  • And who's the most growing segment of our population?

  • It's people of color.

  • Not only are we not doing anything to help them, we're

  • actually hurting them by interfering with what would

  • otherwise be general healthy turnover in the

  • rental market.

  • Our research has shown that in the longer run it

  • actually leads to an overall reduction of

  • affordable rental housing supply and actually fuels

  • gentrification and increases the income

  • inequality. Our study do find evidence that are

  • consistent with landlords trying very hard and trying

  • actively to get out of rent control over the longer run

  • by substituting their rental units to other types

  • of housing that overall better cater towards higher

  • income residents.

  • So since I've lived here so long and there were people

  • who had lived here for decades, I knew that they

  • were trying to get me out.

  • I knew that they wanted to get rent stabilized people

  • out so that they could do renovations and hike up the

  • rent. My apartment was falling apart.

  • I had black mold, then I had paint falling down.

  • I found lead paint.

  • My super does not listen to me.

  • I knew exactly what they were doing.

  • It was ignoring me.

  • It was telling me I'm the only person that has any

  • problem out of all of their buildings.

  • All it said to me is that you want me out of this

  • apartment so that you can raise the rent $1,000.

  • That's what they wanted.