Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Being middle class, I feel like you're really just in between a rock and a hard place.

  • So there are certain kinds of assumptions around being a middle class person that have sort of

  • shattered.

  • And wages, really in some ways, are a reflection of the productivity and skills of American

  • workers.

  • Four in ten Americans say that money affects them negatively and the state of their mental health.

  • The consumers that have a whole lot of debt really are struggling to survive.

  • The middle class was once a symbol of the American dream.

  • But the American middle class today paints quite a different picture.

  • Being middle class, I feel like you're really just in between a rock and a hard place, you know.

  • You're in a spot where everyone's like, Hey, you're doing better than, you know, low class.

  • You're doing great. You should be fine.

  • And you're underneath the people who are actually doing fine.

  • It was at least a secure category.

  • Your kids would go to a school that you felt at least okay about.

  • You probably owned a car or two and you owned your own home and you could pay for your kids'

  • college educations.

  • So there were certain kinds of assumptions around being a middle class person that have sort of

  • shattered. A survey in 2018 found that a third of middle income adults don't have $400 to

  • cover an unexpected expense.

  • In polls, when people are asked about being middle class, they frequently are less likely to say so.

  • And more people now urge the pollsters to suggest that they're working class.

  • So I think that many people who maybe in prior years would have thought of themselves as middle

  • class now no longer think of themselves that way.

  • So when we think about economic status, we think about it as some static, you know, state of the

  • world. That you are either poor or not poor, you're middle class or you're not.

  • But in fact, the reality is that many middle class families will experience one or a few years

  • in poverty. In fact, most American families will have years where they'll be poor or near poor.

  • That precarity, that uncertainty, that is now a feature of the middle class experience for most

  • U.S. families.

  • So what exactly happened to the American middle class?

  • A study by the Pew Research Center discovered that the middle class, which was once comprised of

  • the majority of Americans, has steadily shrunk since the 1970s.

  • About 61% of American adults were considered middle class in 1971, compared to just

  • 51% in 2019.

  • However, the issue still remains widely debated.

  • When people think about the state of the middle class and whether or not it's shrinking, it really

  • is a difficult question, and I think the reason why is that as a nation, we've not actually

  • established a formal definition of middle class.

  • I was at a seminar recently where somebody literally said, there is no middle class anymore.

  • The middle class is gone.

  • And I thought, oh, dear, you know, that's political rhetoric.

  • And I understand that it's a sort of a standard for saying that folks in the middle are hurting,

  • but it's just really not accurate.

  • We looked at the size of the middle class in these 16 rich countries in 1985 and again in 2016.

  • And one of the things that surprised me was the size of the middle class in the United States did

  • not change. It was about 59% in 1985, and it was 59% in 2016.

  • Experts instead prefer the term "squeezed" to describe what's happening to the middle class

  • today.

  • Even if the middle class hasn't statistically shrunk, I do think that the middle class faces

  • more in the way of pressures to maintain or even build upon their position.

  • What it takes to actually live a middle class life, to have quality of life, in many American

  • cities is not what it once was.

  • They're not necessarily able to pay their rent easily.

  • They can't own a property.

  • If they're in their thirties, they may not feel comfortable having kids because they realize that

  • having a child would be too expensive.

  • And forget about medical care.

  • If you have one thing happen to you physically, often people don't have good enough medical care,

  • they don't have any insurance.

  • This all goes into making somebody part of the squeezed middle class.

  • As the middle class lifestyle grows more expensive and uncertain, it's also moving farther beyond the

  • reach of younger generations.

  • In 2019, just 60% of millennials were part of middle income households in their twenties,

  • compared with almost 70% of baby boomers.

  • Meet Chantal Jacob.

  • Chantal lives in suburban Texas with her husband and one child.

  • And while a household income of just over 100,000 should put her family in the middle income tier,

  • she says that her family is still struggling toward financial stability.

  • Sounds great. Six figures.

  • But once we got married, the taxes that come out of my check before I even get any money, before

  • all of my benefits, $500 come out of my check automatically.

  • And then you add in insurance, life insurance for my spouse, myself and my son.

  • And I also have money going aside for my son's college fund.

  • It's not a lot because I can't do that much, but I want to have something for him.

  • You know, my check that starts off at about $3000 goes down to $2200 before I even get to touch

  • it. Our rent's about $1700.

  • Electricity is about $150.

  • Phone bill's about $280.

  • Internet's $60.

  • We both have vehicles.

  • Those are about $800.

  • Insurance on those vehicles is about $400.

  • On food, $400 to $500 a month, but that's increasing.

  • We budget down to the dollar.

  • And sometimes it's very disheartening to work all week and have people tell you like, Oh, you're so

  • lucky, you have a great job.

  • And you're like, Hmm, I don't know about that.

  • There are several reasons why the middle class is feeling squeezed.

  • The first reason is stagnated income.

  • Between 1970 and 2018, the middle class share of aggregate income fell by 19% in the

  • U.S. In comparison, the share of aggregate income for upper income households saw a rise of

  • 19%. Another study by the Brookings Institute found that income in the middle class has grown

  • half as fast compared to both the bottom 20% and the top 20% of income tiers once

  • taxes and transfers were taken into account.

  • If a stay at a company for a while, my income becomes stagnant.

  • You know, it increases by a couple thousand.

  • I generally have to job hop to have increases in my income, which in itself is not

  • security.

  • Middle class workers over the last 40 years have not been able to adequately benefit from the

  • productivity growth, the expansion of the pie, in the economy.

  • We've measured this and found that the typical worker has fallen 43 percentage points behind the

  • growth of productivity.

  • What that means is that the middle class worker could have earned one percentage point more per

  • year in compensation growth over the last 40 years, and they didn't get it because there was an

  • erosion of labor share of overall income and because of rising inequality such that the top

  • 10%, particularly the top 1%, and even more so the top 0.1%, took in much of the gains

  • from the growth of the economy.

  • While incomes stagnate, the cost of living has risen dramatically over the years.

  • To put it into perspective, the average household income in the U.S.

  • saw just a 16% increase over the last 50 years.

  • In comparison, housing costs increased by 190% and college tuition shot up by nearly

  • 264% in the same time period.

  • I first moved in over here in these apartments I live in five years ago.

  • My income, my rent was like $1100.

  • It's now $1700.

  • That's $600 increase happened.

  • I did not have a $600 increase, like my income did not increase at the same rate.

  • Rising expenditures, rising prices, in health, housing and education are very real and they've

  • put a tremendous amount of pressure on households in the middle whose income simply doesn't go as

  • far as it used to.

  • The situation is even worse in cities where the cost of living is already higher.

  • An analysis in 2018 found that raising a family and a middle class lifestyle in expensive coastal

  • cities like San Francisco or New York needs an income of at least $300,000 a year.

  • For reference, just 10% of all households made $200,000 or over in 2020.

  • I'd recently saw an apartment next to the building I work in in Plano, and I was like, It'd

  • be great to walk across the street to work.

  • And it was like $2,400 for an efficiency.

  • And I'm like, That's insane.

  • And then it's like for what I have, they call a townhome, three bed, two bath, $5,500.

  • I'm like, Well, absolutely not.

  • Like I'm going to pay $5,500 and I don't own it, it's not mine?

  • It's just getting worse. And everyone is like, I feel like native people are being pushed out into

  • the suburbs and then people from out of state can come in and enjoy the beautiful fruits of Dallas

  • and have fun and be close to the restaurants.

  • And, you know, I have to live out here and, you know, it's not bad, but it's not Dallas.

  • I'm from Dallas. I grew up there.

  • That's where I want to be. But how it is now, you know, it's just not affordable.

  • Policy making might be both the fault and the solution of the middle class squeeze.

  • There is no help whatsoever.

  • There is no policy in place to assist people, and I feel like as soon as you get a job or as soon as

  • you're working, they're just like, Oh, that's all you need is a job.

  • You got it. You know, go forth and have at it.

  • The stagnation of wages and paychecks for people started in the seventies when productivity started

  • growing more slowly, but really accelerated after 1979 and 80 when there was a huge growth of

  • inequality, when the top 1% took off, when the stock market grew, but people's paychecks didn't.

  • And that has to do with issues of deregulation, excessive unemployment, the weakening of unions,

  • the failure to raise the minimum wage, globalization with low wage countries that really

  • put the kibosh on blue collar job opportunities in many places.

  • The point is that it's not that the economy got worse.

  • It was that there were policy decisions made so that the economic growth did not filter down to

  • the vast majority.

  • The country wasn't built by Wall Street bankers, CEOs and hedge fund managers.

  • It was built by you.

  • It was built by the great American middle class.

  • In response, the Biden administration came into office in 2021 with a promise to revitalize the

  • middle class.

  • The $1 trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill from November 2021 and the upcoming Build Back

  • Better Act both include provisions aimed at financially supporting middle income families.

  • But as Congress continues to find itself in stalemate.

  • Only time will tell whether these bills would really have an impact on the survival of middle

  • income households.

  • I don't see any change effects.

  • My friends that were struggling are still struggling.

  • I'm still budgeting down to every dollar trying to get things done.

  • So I just feel like if the changes are happening, they're not trickling down fast enough for us to