Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Right, this is going to be a slightly more improvised video than normal, for two reasons.

  • Er, one, it is really cold here and I want to move on,

  • but also because I didn't know I was going to be passing through Schengen,

  • a little town in Luxembourg on the borders with France and Germany, until today.

  • But here I am, next to the international border, the Moselle River,

  • and that border is a little bit weird.

  • And I wasn't going to do another video about a weird border. Because I've done that.

  • Years ago I went to the towns of Baarle-Nassau and Baarle-Hertog

  • in Belgium and the Netherlands,

  • where the borders are incredibly complicated and twisted thanks to history.

  • But that's an old video that I'm not really proud of,

  • and frankly it's not that interesting:

  • I only managed about a minute of script

  • before I had to go into a diversion on sovereignty

  • and why we even have borders in the first place.

  • Strange borders often make for great video titles,

  • but there's not much to talk about other thanhuh, that's weird”.

  • Which is also why I've never been to the island that changes country every six months

  • between France and Spain.

  • Because once you're there, what is there to say but, “huh, that's weird”.

  • But it turns out this border raises a different question.

  • If you look on the map, there is a tripoint just of there, to the west of an island:

  • that's where France, Germany and Luxembourg all meet.

  • It was hereactually, on a boat out at that tripoint,

  • where the Schengen agreement was signed,

  • where most of the countries of the EU, all the ones that have their flags here,

  • decided to open their internal borders.

  • But that the tripoint there is not strictly true.

  • The border between Germany and Luxembourg doesn't follow the Moselle river:

  • the border is the Moselle river.

  • And that's an important distinction.

  • In most cases, international borders that follow rivers

  • are defined as following the centre line,

  • which raises questions in itself,

  • because rivers can erode the banks and change paths sometimes,

  • but borders are, at least, usually defined as a line of theoretically zero width.

  • Which is how mapmakers mark it.

  • But here, Germany and Luxembourg share the river north of France. It is a "condominium".

  • Under the treaties they signed, they both have full control over it.

  • Which means that if you're standing on the north tip of that island,

  • or on that bridge up there,

  • you are in both countries at the same time.

  • Not just in terms of having a foot on each side,

  • although that may well be how the locals treat it,

  • and that's certainly how the signs mark it.

  • But no: standing on that bridge above the water,

  • all of you is in both countries simultaneously.

  • This international border is a shape, not a line. It's two-dimensional.

  • Although, actually, I guess it's three-dimensional if you count depth.

  • Half an hour of research, and I can't tell you why they made that decision,

  • or what the legal result would be if you tried to commit a crime

  • on that bridge or on a boat on the river.

  • I even asked the folks at the little European museum just over there,

  • and they didn't know the answer.

  • Although they do have a lovely little display of all the border guard hats

  • that the Schengen agreement made obsolete.

  • I suspect that the answer would betreat it as if it's a line, it's easier”.

  • And that's what I mean when I say that there's not much to talk about here.

  • Because that's one of the wonderful things about borders like this:

  • when you can walk between three countries

  • as easily as you can walk between counties or towns or neighbourhoods:

  • it's a lot easier to sayhuh, that's weird

  • and just get on with your life.

Right, this is going to be a slightly more improvised video than normal, for two reasons.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it