Subtitles section Play video
-
After a long summer of protests in Hong Kong, credit rating agency Moody's changed its outlook for the city to negative.
-
Banks, hedge funds, and other financial specialists may now consider life outside Hong Kong, a place known for its liberal economy and direct access to China.
-
So where could they go?
-
Singapore, Tokyo, and Shanghai are possible options.
-
In March, the three financial hubs were just behind Hong Kong in a ranking of the competitiveness of more than 100 financial centers.
-
So could these cities get more of Hong Kong's business?
-
Singapore has a lot of the same qualities that make Hong Kong attractive.
-
The city state has rule of law and an attractive tax system, and just like Hong Kong, it has the ubiquitous use of English.
-
It's also a major center for wealth management.
-
But Hong Kong has one really big advantage.
-
It's a gateway to China.
-
Hong Kong is part of China, but it has its own special legal and regulatory system.
-
Singapore of course, has got a lot of cultural affinities with China, and there's a big Chinese diaspora there, but of course it's a separate country...
-
And I don't think for Chinese companies or for Chinese officials, it's quite the same thing to list a business in Singapore as it is to list it right next door in Hong Kong.
-
As a result, Singapore's stock market has always been smaller than Hong Kong's.
-
Very roughly, the Singapore market is about a quarter the size of the Hong Kong market in terms of the capitalization.
-
In September, when the Hong Kong Exchange made a surprise takeover proposal to the London Stock Exchange, the LSE's board rejected the order and said it actually preferred Shanghai as a direct channel to access China.
-
Shanghai already serves as mainland China's most advanced financial hub, including bond and stock markets capitalized at trillions of dollars.
-
Its exchange is already larger than Hong Kong's, and it is forecast to grow much further in the coming decades, but being in China can also be seen as a disadvantage.
-
China still operates capital control so you can't take money in and out of the country very easily, given that there's quite a complicated and opaque legal system, and so often companies feel they're operating in an unfair system.
-
For years, the government has been liberalizing the financial sector to attract foreign institutions and their money.
-
We will encourage and support bold and creative steps by Shanghai to advance investment and trade liberalization and facilitation.
-
But the bureaucracy so far has hindered Shanghai's ambition as a truly global financial center.
-
Tokyo is the capital of the world's third largest economy.
-
It is a place where companies enjoy the rule of law and which boasts deep markets.
-
The city has more Fortune 500 companies than anywhere else.
-
- And in late August... -Aramco might list in Tokyo.
-
The city made big news with a Saudi Arabian oil giant.
-
The Japanese authorities might be comfortable with a slightly lower level of disclosure about things like reserves for example, which might make it easier for Aramco, which is a very politically sensitive company to list in Tokyo.
-
If Tokyo won a listing of Aramco, that would be a really big feather in the cap of that stock market.
-
But there are factors holding Tokyo back.
-
Taxes are higher than in Hong Kong or Singapore.
-
Tokyo also has stricter VISA requirements.
-
It's also a less cosmopolitan place.
-
Language is a big barrier.
-
It can be difficult for companies to find employees who have a good command of English.
-
The country was rated 32nd in latest HSBC list of top expat destinations, way behind even mainland China.
-
Many financiers say that Hong Kong is still the only city in Asia to offer the combination of the rule of law, an open capital account, and a convenient base for jumping into the Chinese market.
-
Yet the long months of protests are already taking a toll.
-
Chinese E-commerce giant Alibaba recently put a blockbuster listing there on hold for instance.
-
Hong Kong is scheduled to keep its special status as a semi-autonomous region until 2047.
-
But as Beijing's grip on the territory increases, so does uncertainty about what might happen in the near future.