Subtitles section Play video
-
I'm going to take you back in time, 1400 years,
-
to the city of Medina, Saudi Arabia.
-
To a time when Prophet Mouhammed was given the task
-
of finding a solution to women in the city being attacked and molested.
-
The situation was this:
-
It was around the year 680,
-
long before the modern convenience,
-
of plumbing.
-
When a woman awoke in the middle of the night
-
with the urge to relieve herself,
-
she would have to walk out,
-
past the outskirts of the city, and into the wild by herself,
-
for privacy.
-
Believe it or not,
-
a group of men actually began to see an opportunity
-
in women's nightly tracks,
-
and started to linger at the outskirts of the city -
-
their identities hidden in the dark, watching.
-
If a woman walked by,
-
and she happened to be wearing a jilbab,
-
which was a garment like a coat,
-
the men knew to leave her alone.
-
A jilbab of centuries ago was a status symbol,
-
like a Burberry trench or a Chanel jacket.
-
It announced that the woman was free,
-
and a free woman was protected by her clan.
-
She would have no problems speaking out against the attacker
-
and identifying him.
-
But if the woman walking out at night wasn't wearing a jilbab,
-
if she happened to be dressed a bit more freely,
-
then the men knew she was a slave,
-
and they attacked her.
-
Concerned members of the community brought the situation to the Prophet,
-
and like so many other social, political, and familial issues
-
that Muhammed faced during his Prophethood,
-
he turned this particular matter over to God,
-
and a verse was revealed for the Quran,
-
the Muslim holy book.
-
"O Prophet," it reads,
-
"tell your wives, your daughters, and the women of the believers
-
to draw upon themselves their garments.
-
This is better, so that they not be known and molested."
-
Basically, the verse advises that all women dress similarly,
-
so that they can't be picked out from one another,
-
zeroed in on, and attacked.
-
Now, on the surface,
-
this may seem like a relatively easy solution to the problem,
-
but turns out it wasn't.
-
The early Muslim community was tribal, and so deeply entrenched in social status,
-
and the idea that a slave would look like a free woman,
-
that was almost insulting.
-
And then there was the matter of practicality.
-
How would a slave do her work?
-
How would she function, if her body was constricted by a coat?
-
How would she cook, clean, fetch water?
-
In the end, the early Muslim scholars ruled
-
that a woman's way of dress should be based on two considerations:
-
a woman's function in society -
-
her role, what we might consider her job -
-
and the society's specific customs.
-
Or, in another way: when in Rome.
-
Muslims like to take historical rulings and apply them to the modern era.
-
So, let's do that.
-
A woman's way of dress should be based on custom and function.
-
So, what does that mean for a Muslim woman living in America today,
-
for someone like me?
-
First, it means that I have a function, a role in society, a contribution
-
that I can make.
-
Second, it means
-
that while I'm making that contribution,
-
and living in a society where veiling is not the custom,
-
and where, in fact, if I veil it might actually lead to harassment,
-
then wearing what is the custom,
-
such as a dress, a pair of jeans or even yoga pants,
-
is not only acceptable,
-
it's recommended.
-
But wait, could that be right?
-
After all, haven't we all come to assume
-
that a Muslim woman must veil,
-
that veiling is a requirement of her faith?
-
There is even a term
-
that we've all come to associate with the Muslim woman's veil,
-
an Arabic term that we've all heard use,
-
whether or not we've been aware of it:
-
"Hijab."
-
So, maybe I missed it.
-
Maybe the requirement that a woman veil is in a different part of the Quran.
-
For those of you who don't know, the Quran consists of 114 chapters,
-
each chapter is written out in verses, like poetry.
-
There are more than 6,000 verses in the Quran.
-
Out of the 6,000 plus verses,
-
three refer to how a woman should dress.
-
The first is the verse I've already told you about.
-
The second is a verse that directly speaks to the Prophet's wives,
-
asking that they begin to dress a bit more modestly
-
because of their role, their function in society as his wives.
-
And the third verse is similar to the first,
-
in that it was revealed in direct response to a historical situation.
-
Early records show that the custom,
-
the fashion during the pre-Islamic era,
-
was for women to wear a scarf on the head, called a khimar,
-
which would be tucked behind the ears and allowed to flow behind the back.
-
In the front, a woman wore a tight vest or a bodice,
-
which she left open exposing her breasts -
-
sort of like the images you've seen in Game of Thrones.
-
(Laughter)
-
When Islam spread through the Arabian Peninsula,
-
a verse was sent down asking that women use this scarf,
-
or any other garment,
-
to cover the breasts.
-
And that's it.
-
That's basically all there is in the Quran concerning how a woman should dress.
-
Turns out, God doesn't give a bullet point of all the parts on a woman's body
-
that he wants hidden from view.
-
And in fact, it might be argued, and it is argued,
-
I cannot stress enough that it is argued by many Muslim scholars
-
that the reason these verses were left intentionally vague
-
is so that a woman could choose for herself how to dress
-
according to her specific culture
-
and the progression of time.
-
And that the term "hijab,"
-
guess what?
-
It's not in any of these three verses.
-
In fact, it's nowhere in the Quran, directly meaning a woman's veil.
-
That's not to say that the word doesn't appear in the Quran
-
because it does appear.
-
But when it appears, it's actually used correctly,
-
to mean a barrier or a divide.
-
Such as the barrier or divide that exists between us humans and the divine,
-
or between believers and non-believers.
-
Or it means a barrier, like a physical screen,
-
that men during Muhammad's time were asked to stand behind
-
when speaking to his wives.
-
Or it means the seclusion, the separation that Mary sought
-
when she was giving birth to Jesus.
-
That separation and seclusion,
-
that means hijab;
-
that physical screen,
-
that means hijab;
-
that barrier, that divide,
-
that means hijab.
-
Hijab doesn't mean a woman's veil.
-
And yet, isn't it strange that what the term actually means,
-
being screened off, divided away, barred, separated out,
-
these are the very terms that come to our minds
-
when we think of a Muslim woman?
-
Why shouldn't they?
-
We have all seen the way some Muslim women are treated around the world:
-
if she attempts to go to school,
-
she's shot in the head;
-
if she attempts to drive a car,
-
she's jailed;
-
if she attempts to take part
-
in the political uprisings happening in her own country,
-
to be heard, to be counted,
-
she is publicly assaulted.
-
Forget about hiding out in the dark at the outskirts of the city,
-
some men now feel comfortable enough to assault a woman on the sidewalk,
-
for the world to see.
-
And they don't care to hide their identities,
-
they're more interested in making international headlines.
-
They're too busy making videos and uploading them onto YouTube,
-
bragging about what they've done.
-
Why don't they care to hide their crimes?
-
They don't feel like they've committed any crimes.
-
It's the women who've committed the crimes.
-
It's the women who got these funny ideas in their heads,
-
ideas that actually led them out of the house,
-
led them into society,
-
believing that they can make a contribution,
-
and we all know,
-
honorable women, they stay at home;
-
honorable women stay invisible.
-
Just as it was the custom for honorable women to do
-
during the Prophet's time.
-
Is that true?
-
1400 years ago is long before feminism.
-
Were women locked away behind doors, screened off by veils?
-
Well, it turns out that the Prophet's first wife
-
was what we would define today
-
as a CEO.
-
She was a successful merchant
-
whose caravan equaled the caravans of all the other traders put together.
-
She essentially headed up a successful import-export company.
-
When she hired Muhammed to work for her,
-
she was so taken with his honesty
-
that eventually she proposed.
-
(Laughter)
-
I'm not sure how many women feel comfortable
-
proposing marriage to a man today.
-
And Muhammad's second wife?
-
She was no slacker either.
-
She rode into battle on the back of a camel,
-
which is equivalent to a woman riding into battle today
-
inside of a Humvee or a tank.
-
And what of the other women?
-
Early records show that women demanded to be included
-
in the Islamic revolution taking place around the Prophet.
-
One woman became famous as a general
-
when she led her army of men into battle and crushed a rebellion.
-
Men and women freely associated with one another, exchanged gifts.
-
It was custom for a woman to select her own husband and propose.
-
And when things didn't work out,
-
to initiate divorce.
-
Women even loudly debated with the Prophet himself.
-
Seems to me that if fundamentalists
-
want to return current Muslim society to 680 AD,
-
it might be a huge step forward.
-
(Laughter)
-
Progress.
-
(Applause)
-
But we still have to answer an important question.
-
If not from Islamic history, and if not from the Quran,
-
how is it that we, in the modern era,
-
have come to associate Muslim women with hijab?
-
With being separated out from society,
-
secluded and isolated,
-
barred from the most basic human rights?
-
I hope it's not any surprise to you that this isn't by accident.
-
For the past few decades, the very people who have been given the important task
-
of reading and interpreting the Quran
-
in a variety of different Muslim communities,
-
certain clerics have been inserting a certain meaning
-
into those three verses concerning women.
-
For instance that verse I told you about earlier:
-
"O Prophet, tell your wives, your daughters,
-
and the women of the believers to draw upon themselves their garments,
-
this is better, so that they not be known and molested."
-
Some clerics, not all, some clerics
-
have added a few words to that,
-
so that in certain translations of the Quran,
-
that verse reads like this:
-
"O Prophet, tell your wives, your daughters,
-
and the women of the believers, to draw upon themselves their garments,
-
parentheses, a garment is a veil
-
that covers the entire head and the face,
-
the neck and the breast all the way down to the ankles
-
and all the way to the wrists.
-
Everything on a woman's body is covered except for one eye
-
because she must see where she is headed,
-
and the hands must be covered in gloves.
-
Because, of course,
-
there was certainly a lot of gloves back in the desert of Saudi Arabia.
-
(Laughter)
-
Etc., etc., etc., etc., on, and on, and on,
-
end of parentheses,
-
so that she not be known and molested."
-
And what these so-called clerics
-
have concluded based on these types of insertions
-
is that a woman only has one function.
-
To understand what that function is,