Subtitles section Play video
-
While politeness is, of course, always preferable to rudeness.
-
There are ways of being polite, that badly miss the mark
-
and can leave us feeling oddly detached and dissatisfied.
-
Picture the person who ends up, despite their best efforts,
-
seeming what we can call "coldly polite".
-
They may be extremely keen to please those they're seeing.
-
They obey all the rules of etiquette, they offer their guest drinks, ask them questions about their journey,
-
suggest they might want a little more gravy, remark on the interest of a recent prize winning novel.
-
And yet, they never manage to make their hospitality feel either engaging or memorable.
-
It may be a long time, before another meeting with them is suggested.
-
By contrast, there is the person we recognize as a warm, who follows the cold person in the basic principles of politeness,
-
but manages to add a critical, emotionally comforting ingredient to their manner.
-
They might, when we have an evening plan with them, suggest making toasted cheese sandwiches at their place
-
rather than going out to a restaurant.
-
They might chat to us through the bathroom door;
-
put on the songs they loved dancing to when they were fourteen;
-
plump up a cushion, and slot it behind our back;
-
confess to feeling intimidated by mutual acquaintance;
-
bring us a posy of daisies, or a card they made;
-
call us up when we're down with a flu and ask how our ears are feeling;
-
mention they like our haircut, and then when we spill something or fart by mistake exclaim
-
"I'm so glad you did that, it is usually me".
-
Beneath the difference between the warm and the cold person,
-
lies a contrasting vision of human nature.
-
Broadly, the cold person is operating with an implicit view that those they are attempting to please
-
are creatures endowed only with the highest needs.
-
As a result, all kinds of assumptions are made about them
-
That they are interested exclusively in so called "serious topics",
-
specially art and politics.
-
That they will appreciate a degree of formality in dining and sitting;
-
that they will be strong, self-contained and mature enough, never to have any hunger for reassurence or cosiness,
-
and that they will be without urgent physical vulnerabilities and drives.
-
which might prove deeply offensive if they were mentioned.
-
These higher beings would, the cold host believes, wins if someone suggested they curl up on the sofa with a blanket
-
or handed them a copy of magazine about filmstars when they headed for the bathroom.
-
Yet, the warmly polite person is always deeply aware that the stranger irrespective of their status or outward dignity
-
is a highly needy, fragile, confused, appetitive and susceptible creature.
-
And they know this about the stranger because they never forget this about themselves.
-
Warmly polite people have much in common with the character Kanga, the tenderly maternal kangaroo in A. A. Milne's "Winnie-the-pooh" books.
-
In one of the stories the little animals are deeply disconcerted by the arrival in the Hundred Acre Wood of Tigger,
-
who's very big, very loud and bouncy and assertive.
-
They treat him with caution and are, we might say, coldly polite.
-
But when Tigger finally meets Kanga, she is immediately warm with him.
-
She thinks of him in much the same terms as she does her own child Roo.
-
Just because an animal is large, it doesn't mean he doesn't want kindness.
-
"However big Tigger seems to be, remember that he wants as much kindness as Roo.", says Kanga.
-
In what might be a definition of the essence of the philosophy of warmth.
-
Sometimes it is deeply generous to think that another person may be more elevated than us.
-
Collectively, we've taken this thought very much to heart.
-
We've internalized distance and learned caution, moving on from the naivety of the small child
-
who wonders sweetly, when you're sad, if you might like to sniff their grimy blanket.
-
But the warm person knows that however solid and dignified someone appears on the outside,
-
behind the scenes there will inevitably be a struggling self.
-
Potentially awkward, easily bemused, beset by physical appetites, on the verge of loneliness and frequently in need of nothing more subtle or elevated
-
than a cheese sandwich, a glass of milk and a hug.