Subtitles section Play video
-
[WatchMojo Intro Music]
-
J.K. Rowling's epic book series is so magical that it would be impossible to include it all on screen.
-
Welcome to WatchMojo.com,
-
and today we're counting down our picks for
-
the top 10 differences between the Harry Potter novels and movies.
-
Hmm...
-
Difficult, very difficult.
-
For this list we are looking at characters,
-
stories or pretty much anything that was left out when the Harry Potter books became movies.
-
Since we're talking about major plot points and characters,
-
you might want to put your extendable ears away.
-
And do some light reading and watching.
-
[Book opens]
-
This... is light?
-
Exspoilalarmus,
-
and by that we mean: Spoiler Alert.
-
Ron you've spoiled everything!
-
Number 10 - Book: There's a Sphinx in the maze. Movie: No Sphinx.
-
The Harry Potter novels offer some great riddle solving that unfortunately didn't make the final cut.
-
For example, in the Philosopher's stone,
-
Hermione has to solve a potions riddle to help Harry confront professor Quirrell.
-
Tell me...
-
What do you see?
-
J.K. Rowling once again threw a puzzle at her characters in the Goblet of Fire.
-
But here Harry has no help,
-
trapped alone in a hedge maze, during the Triwizard tournament.
-
While the movie version only has Harry escaping from some scary shrubbery,
-
the book's maze houses menacing creatures.
-
One such creature is a Sphinx that will only let Harry pass if he correctly answers a riddle.
-
This character inclusion reminded readers of Rowling's background in mythology,
-
while also suggesting that maybe Hermione rubbed off on Harry.
-
Me, books, and cleverness. There are more important things.
-
Friendship...
-
and bravery.
-
And Harry,
-
just be careful.
-
Number 9 - Book: Animagi are explained. Movie: Animagi are not really explained.
-
Please, sir...
-
An animagus is a wizard who elects to turn into an animal,
-
a werewolf has no choice.
-
Do you know the difference between a werewolf and an animagus?
-
If you've only seen the third Harry Potter movie,
-
Hermione's explanation is all you get.
-
However, the books go into greater detail about the process of turning into an animal
-
and the laws surrounding it.
-
We also learn that James Potter, Sirius Black, and Peter Pettigrew became unregistered animagi
-
to accompany Remus Lupin whenever he transformed into a werewolf.
-
And that they created the Marauder's map to help sneak out of Hogwarts.
-
Messrs Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot, and Prongs...
-
are proud to present...
-
the Marauder's map.
-
We owe them so much.
-
So, if you didn't read the books it might have been confusing when Pettigrew became a rat,
-
Sirius a dog,
-
and even McGonagall a cat.
-
Though you know she did it legally!
-
That was bloody brilliant!
-
Oh thank you for that assessment Mr. Weasley.
-
Understanding what an animagus is even gives significance to the Potter family's patronuses.
-
Since James became a stag.
-
No, my patronus is a stag.
-
Number 8 - Book: Peter Pettigrew is strangled to death by his silver hand. Movie: Peter Pettigrew does not die.
-
Thank you, master. Thank you!
-
Remember when Voldemort gives Peter Pettigrew a shiny new hand,
-
after he sacrifices his real one revive his master?
-
The books prove that this wasn't just a gift.
-
As Harry and company try to escape from Malfoy manor in the Deathly Hallows,
-
Pettigrew is all that stands in their way.
-
Let her go.
-
Shut up! Get back!
-
He briefly stops himself from killing son of his best friend.
-
But this proofs to be his downfall,
-
as he's then strangled to death by his own hand, since he defied his master Voldemort.
-
In the movie, Pettigrew was easily put out of commision by Dobby,
-
who only disarms him.
-
But does not kill him.
-
Guess some things are too dark for the silver screen, huh?
-
Who gets his wand?
-
Number 7 - Book: Harry replaces the elder wand in Dumbledore's tomb. Movie: Harry breaks the elder wand and throws it away.
-
He killed the wizard with whom he had once quarrelled.
-
Drunk, with the power that the Elder Wand had given him,
-
he bragged at his invincibility.
-
Here's a moment that made all Potter fans gasp,
-
in both the book and the film.
-
Harry is revealed as the Elder Wand's true master
-
after he disarms its previous master Draco Malfoy.
-
It's what he does with it in the movie that irks Potterheads to this day.
-
After the battle of Hogwarts in the final film,
-
Harry does what probably no one with an all-powerful wand would do:
-
He snaps it in two and throws it off a bridge.
-
In the book however,
-
Harry uses it to fix his own wand, which he always preferred,
-
then returns it to Dumbledore's grave, so that when Harry finally dies,
-
the wand will have no allegiance to anyone else.
-
Well, that makes more sense.
-
She thinks you're the chosen one.
-
But I am the chosen one.
-
Okay, sorry. Um.
-
Kidding.
-
Number 6 - Book: House-elves are mistreated, but play vital roles. Movie: House-elves are mostly unimportant, unseen.
-
Why do you wear that thing Dobby?
-
This uh...
-
it is a mark of the house-elf's enslavement.
-
Harry Potter deals with many issues.
-
But one that's glossed over in the movies is the mistreatment of house-elves.
-
We do see Dobby as a slave to the Malfoys...
-
I will deal with you later.
-
...but he has much more purpose than the movies led on.
-
For example, he is the one who gives Harry the gillyweed in the Goblet of Fire,
-
not Neville.
-
You sure about this Neville?
-
Absolutely.
-
For an hour?
-
Most likely.
-
Something else the movies don't show is that Dobby and other house-elves
-
are given proper employment in the Hogwarts kitchens.
-
Plus, the films don't include the female house-elf Winky,
-
who cares for Barty Crouch Jr.,
-
gets fired and is then employed at Hogwarts.
-
Man, house-elves deserve more credit.
-
Just ask the creator of SPEW,
-
the Society for the Promotion of Elfish Welfare:
-
Hermione Granger.
-
That is the general idea.
-
It's brilliant.
-
Number 5 - Book: Harry & Hermione miss Ron. Movie: Harry & Hermione slow dance to cheer up.
-
[Music plays]
-
When Harry, Ron, and Hermione search for the deathly hallows,
-
their relationships slowly become strained.
-
Ron in particular is affected, as he has to wear the horcrux locket,
-
which forces his most negative feelings to surface.
-
You think I don't know how this feels.
-
No you don't know how it feels.
-
Your parents are dead. You have no family.
-
Ron soon can't deal with it and leaves his two friends alone.
-
In the Deathly Hallows part 1, Harry and Hermione are wallowing in despair while listening to the radio.
-
When a soothing song pops on, the two then begin to dance with each other,
-
sharing a brief moment of cheerfullnes they hadn't felt for quite some time.
-
[Music plays]
-
But, as the song finishes, it's back to reality.
-
This scene doesn't appear at all in the books but is a nice moment between friends.
-
Number 4 - Book: Voldemort dies like a human. Movie: Voldemort dies like a supernatural creature.
-
In both the books and the movies, Harry and Voldemort are having their final duel,
-
and their wands connect as they done in the Goblet of Fire.
-
Voldemort uses the Elder Wand, even though it doesn't have allegiance to him,
-
but doesn't realize that he's actually fighting its real master.
-
The Elder Wand refuses to harm Harry,
-
and rebounds Voldemort's killing curse back towards him.
-
The book does not afford Voldemort the grandiose death he wanted,
-
instead he dies like a human, in a purposefully anti-climactic way.
-
In the movie however, Voldemort just sort of breaks apart and fades away,
-
which is visually stunning, but doesn't have that same finality,
-
and affords him more power than he deserves.
-
[Music plays]
-
Number 3 - Book: Peeves, Ludo Bagman, Charlie Weasley & Teddy Lupin all exist. Movie: Peeves, Ludo Bagman, Charlie Weasley & Teddy Lupin don't appear.
-
Why, it's Potty Wee Potter!
-
I'm Peeves, Potter, and you better watch out for me!
-
When any book series is given the film treatment, some characters don't make the cut,
-
because they interfere with the pace, but we missed a few.
-
Peeves, the poltergeist, a pesky ghoul who pulls pranks on staff and students at Hogwarts
-
is a fan favourite.
-
The ministry of magic's head of the division for magical games, Ludo Bagman,
-
appears in the Goblet of Fire book,
-
but not the film.
-
On screen, the Weasley family second-eldest Charlie is only mentioned and shown in pictures.
-
My parents decided to go to Romania, to visit my brother Charlie.
-
He's studying dragons there!
-
But, an especially upsetting omission is Teddy Lupin,
-
son of Remus Lupin and Nymphadora Tonks.
-
By the way, wait till you hear the news... Remus and I...
-
It can wait we have time for a cozy catch up later.
-
This book character represents the tragic cyclical nature of the series,
-
as he's orphaned in the battle of Hogwarts,
-
and essentially becomes his generation's Harry.
-
And Remus, your son.
-
Others will tell him what his mother and father died for.
-
One day, he'll understand.
-
They even cast the character.
-
You have this new life you know
-
doing your own thing and you're suddenly independent.
-
Number 2 - Book: Various characters visit St. Mungo's hospital for magical maladies. Movie: St. Mungo's never appears.
-
Yup, even a wizarding world needs a hospital.
-
In the books, several wizards are injured enough to be sent to St. Mungo's,
-
including Arthur Weasley after he is attacked by Nagini.
-
Some patients are there permanently, like Gilderoy Lockhart,
-
who suffers from a backfired memory charm.
-
Bet you forgot about him.
-
Who are you?
-
Ummh...
-
Ron Weasley.
-
Really?
-
And uhh..
-
Who, who am I?
-
Other long-term residents are Neville's parents,
-
who were tortured into insanity with the cruciatus curse by Voldemort's minions.
-
Neville's parents.
-
They suffered a fate worse than death if you ask me.
-
This scene not only shows the terrible effects of the first wizarding war.
-
It also fleshes out Neville's tragic backstory.
-
Highlighting the fact that the Longbottoms' history of defying the dark lord
-
may have made Neville the chosen one instead of Harry.
-
But it may have just been too hard to watch when the Longbottoms' don't recognize their own son.
-
I'm quite proud to be their son.
-
Before we unveil our number one pick, here are some honorable mentions.
-
Ah, there you are, Harry! Hermione and Ron are already at my Deathday party.
-
It's a Firebolt. It's the fastest broom in the world!
-
For me.. But who sent it?
-
No one knows.
-
This came with it.
-
[A Letter with Molly Weasley's voice] How dare you steal that car!
-
Number 1 - Book: Half-blood Tom Riddle was conceived thanks to a love potion. Movie: Voldemort's parentage is largely glossed over.
-
Bone of the father, unwillingly given.
-
When Dumbledore takes Harry through Voldemort's past in the movies,
-
we learn a little about how he went from orphan boy to the dark lord.
-
I can make things move without touching them.
-
I can make animals do what I want without training them.
-
I can make bad things happen to people who are mean to me.
-
The books, however, tell the full story.
-
Voldemort is the son of the witch Merope Gaunt and the muggle Tom Riddle.
-
Merope fell in love with Tom Riddle and with the help of a love potion, she married him.
-
And became pregnant.
-
Rowling has said it's important that Voldemort was conceived as a result of force rather than real love.
-
As it explains why he cannot feel love.
-
Merope eventually stopped using the potion,
-
hoping Riddle actually loved her.
-
Unfortunately, he abandoned both Merope and their unborn son.
-
This explains Voldemort's hatred of muggles, as well as half-bloods,
-
as he himself is one.
-
You're Voldemort.
-
Surely, you didn't think I was going to keep my filthy muggle father's name?
-
Do you agree with our list?
-
Were we put under a confundus charm when we made this?
-
Harry.
-
I protest!
-
Harry, did you put your name in the Goblet of Fire?
-
No sir!
-
You asked one of the older students to do it for you?
-
No sir.
-
You're absolutely sure?
-
Yes sir.
-
For more magical top tens published every day, be sure to subscribe to WatchMojo.com!
-
I think it is clear. That we can expect great things from you.