Subtitles section Play video
-
Since around 1750
-
we've been living in a highly distinctive era in the history of love
-
that we can call "romanticism".
-
Romanticism emerged as an ideology in Europe in the mid 18th century
-
in the minds of poets, artists and philosophers.
-
And it's now conquered the world.
-
No single relationship ever follows the romantic template exactly.
-
But it's broad outlines are frequently present, nevertheless.
-
And can be summed up as follows:
-
Romanticism is deeply hopeful about marriage.
-
Romanticism took marriage,
-
hitherto seen as practical and emotionally temperate union,
-
and fused it together with a passionate love story
-
to create a unique proposition of a life-long, passionate love marriage.
-
Along the way romanticism united love and sex.
-
Previously people had imagined that they could have sex with characters they didn't love,
-
and that they could love someone without having extraordinary sex with them.
-
Romanticism elevated sex to the supreme expression of love.
-
Frequent, mutually satisfying sex became the bellwether of the health of any relationship.
-
Without necessarily meaning to, romanticism made infrequent sex and adultery into catastrophes.
-
Romanticism proposed that true love must mean an end to all loneliness.
-
The right partner must, it promised, understand us entirely
-
possibly without needing even to speak to us.
-
They would intuit our souls.
-
Romantics put a special premium on the idea that our partner might understand us without needing to say anything.
-
Romanticism believed that choosing a partner should be about letting oneself be guided by feelings,
-
rather than practical considerations.
-
You know you're in love because you have a special feeling.
-
Romanticism has manifested a powerful disdain for practicalities and money.
-
It feels cold or, as we say, unromantic
-
to say you know you're with the right person because the two of you make an excellent financial fit
-
or because you cherish the things like bathroom etiquette and attitudes to punctuality.
-
Romanticism believes that true love is synonymous with accepting everything about someone.
-
The idea that one's partner or oneself may need to change
-
is taken to be a sign that the relationship is on the rocks.
-
"You're going to have to change" is a last ditch threat.
-
This template of love is a historical creation.
-
It's a hugely beautiful and often enjoyable one.
-
But we can state boldly: romanticism has been a disaster for relationships.
-
It's an intellectual and spiritual movement
-
which has had a devastating impact on the ability of ordinary people
-
to lead succesful emotional lives.
-
The salvation of love lies in overcoming a succession of errors within romanticism.
-
These are some of the myths of romanticism.
-
That we should meet a person of extraordinary inner and outer beauty
-
and immediately feel a special attraction to them and they to us.
-
We should have highly satisfying sex, not only at the start, but forever.
-
We should never be attracted to anyone else
-
We should understand one another intuitively.
-
We don't need an education in love.
-
We may need to train to become a pilot or brain surgeon, but not a lover.
-
We'll pick that up along the way by following our feelings.
-
We should have no secrets and spend constant time together.
-
Work won't get in the way.
-
We should raise a family without any loss of sexual or emotional intensity.
-
Our lover must be our soulmate, best friend, co-parent, co-chauffeur, accountant, household manager and spiritual guide.
-
If we question the assumptions of the romantic view of love
-
it's not in order to destroy love, but to save it.
-
We need to piece together a post-romantic theory of couples
-
because in order to make a relationship last
-
we have to be disloyal to the romantic emotions that get us into it in the first place.
-
We need to replace the romantic template with a psychologically mature vision of love we might call "classical",
-
and which encourages in us a range of unfamiliar, but hopefully effective, attitudes.
-
For example:
-
That it's normal that love and sex may not always belong together.
-
That discussing money, early on, up front, in a serious way, is not a betrayal of love.
-
That realizing that we're rather flawed, and our partner is too, is a huge benefit to a couple
-
because it increases the amount of tolerance and generosity in circulation.
-
That we will never find everything in one person, nor they in us,
-
not because of some unique flaw, but because that's just the way human nature is.
-
That we need to make amends and often rather artificial sounding efforts to understand one another.
-
That intuition can't get us where we need to go.
-
And that spending two hours discussing whether bathroom towels should be hung up or can be left on the floor
-
is neither trivial nor unserious.
-
There is a special dignity around issues of laundry and time keeping.
-
All these attitudes and more belong to a new, more hopeful, post-romantic future for love.