Subtitles section Play video
-
On this episode of China Uncensored,
-
just when you thought it couldn't get any more complicated
-
than a territorial dispute between China, Taiwan, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei,
-
and the Philippines, well...
-
Indonesia had to show up
-
like a...seventh wheel.
-
Hi, welcome to China Uncensored, I'm your maritime mariner, Chris Chappell.
-
The South China Sea is becoming a powder keg!
-
And who is to blame?!
-
"It is exactly one country and let me not avoid mentioning the name:
-
that is, the Philippines…"
-
Well, umm, I don't think that's really…
-
"We are on high alert for Japan's moves in the South China Sea."
-
Ok, no, it's not Japan this time either.
-
"I suggest to the media that in your reports you not selectively pump up or ignore things."
-
Okay, fine! Everyone's stirring up trouble in the South China Sea!
-
In fact, there is only one country not stirring up trouble:
-
Indonesia.
-
"And lastly I reiterate that Indonesia is not a claimant state in South China Sea issue."
-
Finally! A country actually not involved in the South China Sea dispute!
-
It's almost too good to be true!
-
"On March 19, the Chinese fishing boat was attacked by an Indonesian armed boat."
-
Oh. It was too good to be true.
-
You see, on Saturday, Indonesian authorities "attacked" a Chinese fishing vessel in "traditional
-
Chinese fishing grounds."
-
Of course, by "attack,"
-
the Chinese Foreign Ministry means Indonesia fired warning shots into the air
-
while approaching the Chinese vessel that was fishing there illegally.
-
And by "traditional Chinese fishing grounds,"
-
they mean Indonesia's Exclusive Economic Zone,
-
located within 200 miles around the Natuna Islands.
-
Don't worry, I didn't know what the Natuna Islands were either.
-
Apparently, they're here, outside the giant area of the South China Sea covered by China's
-
ridiculously large
-
I mean, historically accurate
-
Nine-dash line.
-
But a small part of the 200-mile Exclusive Economic Zone around the Natuna islands does
-
overlap with the Nine-dash line.
-
Fortunately, Saturday's incident is nothing like what happened back in 2013,
-
when Indonesian authorities caught other another Chinese fishing vessel.
-
That time, a Chinese patrol ship came,
-
armed with mounted machine guns and demanded they release the boat and crew.
-
This time the Chinese coast guard was much better behaved.
-
They merely followed Indonesian authorities through their Economic Zone,
-
into Indonesian territorial waters,
-
then began literally ramming the Chinese fishing boat until they released it.
-
The eight-person Chinese crew is still in Indonesian custody,
-
but China has called for their release.
-
Now Indonesia has typically stayed out of South China Sea territorial disputes
-
partly because Indonesia's waters are so far away from China, it's kind of ridiculous.
-
But now, that may have changed.
-
"With the events which unfolded yesterday we feel that we were interrupted and sabotaged
-
in our efforts and our years of works to promote peace in the South China Sea."
-
Wait a minute, Indonesia.
-
Your efforts to promote peace?
-
Didn't you know that China is the one doing all the peace promotion?
-
"And, we don't hope to see anymore close-up military reconnaissance or the dispatch of
-
missile destroyers or strategic bombers to the South China Sea.
-
This is something we have a responsibility for under our non-militarization commitment."
-
See? Non-militarization commitment.
-
Except last month, when this was reported.
-
"The Chinese military has deployed an advanced surface to air missile system on one of the disputed
-
islands in the south China Sea."
-
Or shortly after that.
-
"China deploys war planes to disputed South China Sea Islands."
-
But compared to previous times Indonesia has dealt with illegal Chinese fishing vessels,
-
their response this time has been much stronger.
-
"Indonesia will summon China's ambassador over an incident involving a Chinese fishing
-
vessel in the Natuna Sea."
-
Summoning the Ambassador?
-
That’s a pretty bold move for a country that relies on China as its largest trading partner.
-
But here's the thing:
-
China doesn't even dispute Indonesia's territorial claims.
-
"The sovereignty of the Natuna Islands belongs to Indonesia.
-
China has no objections to this."
-
Yet China insists that their fishermen were still in traditional Chinese fishing grounds?
-
I guess there is something to be said for tradition.
-
If everyone just respects each other's traditional fishing grounds, then we should be fine.
-
What's that, Shelley?
-
Ok, nevermind then.
-
But anyway, the biggest problem for China is that by alienating Indonesia,
-
they may have lost the closest thing to a neutral ally in the South China Sea disputes
-
disputes that have put China at odds with pretty much everyone else.
-
So how do you think this incident will affect Indonesia's involvement in South China Sea?
-
Leave your comments below.
-
And remember to subscribe for more episodes of China Uncensored.
-
Once again I'm Chris Chappell, see you next time.