Subtitles section Play video
-
Every day we engage in a behavior that is completely contrary
-
to how we would optimally function.
-
And I'm not talking about a modern technological practice
-
such as posting embarrassing snapshots of one's unsuspecting partner on Facebook.
-
I'm talking about an integral human behavior.
-
I'm talking about a deeply intimate behavior.
-
Every day we engage in a behavior that requires us
-
to distort our thoughts, numb our feelings
-
and act against our core values,
-
and which enables a global atrocity
-
that can make even the most stoic of us weep in sorrow.
-
And every day we could choose not to engage in this behavior,
-
except we don't realize that it's irrational.
-
We don't see that it's destructive and we don't even know we have a choice.
-
How can some of the most frequent and important choices we make,
-
appear not to be choices at all?
-
How can the irrationality and destruction of a widespread behavior
-
be virtually invisible?
-
These are the questions I asked when I began my nearly two decades of research
-
on the psychology of eating animals.
-
And what I discovered was not at all what I had expected.
-
As it turns out, there's a distinct underlying factor
-
that both drives our behavior and prevents us
-
from recognizing its irrationality and the destruction it causes.
-
I identified and codified this factor
-
and I'm here to share my findings with you.
-
And the good news is that simply becoming aware of this factor
-
enables us to reclaim our rationality and freedom of choice
-
and become more active participants in creating a humane and just world.
-
My journey of discovery began in 1968,
-
25 years before I set foot in my first Harvard lecture.
-
And nearly fifty years before
-
I received the Ahimsa Award at the British House of Commons
-
for my work on global non-violence.
-
I'm 48. Thank you.
-
(Laughter)
-
My family adopted a puppy we named Fritz.
-
Now, Fritz was my first dog and he was also my first friend.
-
We did everything together.
-
We played together. We napped together.
-
And we even vomited together once during a sickening road trip.
-
And Fritz was also my first heartbreak
-
when he died at the age of 13 of liver cancer.
-
What I didn't realize back then was that my connection with Fritz
-
would lead to a discovery that would transform my worldview.
-
So I cared about Fritz and I'm not unique.
-
Most of us care about animals.
-
We teach our children to be kind to animals.
-
Our hearts leap when we witness them at play.
-
We recognize the injustice and feel outraged when they are abused.
-
We empathize with animals.
-
We share their fear, their joy, their sorrow.
-
And how many of you have cared about a certain animal in your life?
-
Just raise your hand.
-
Now look around the room.
-
That's a whole lot of caring.
-
So to explain how my connection with my dog
-
led me to this stage, I'd like to do a thought experiment.
-
Imagine that you're a guest at a dinner party
-
and your host serves you a dish that looks like this.
-
Consider whether you find this delicious or disgusting.
-
For those who would find it delicious,
-
imagine you find it so delicious that you ask your host for the recipe.
-
And she replies the secret is in the meat.
-
You use three pounds of well-seasoned -
-
Golden Retriever.
-
Now take a moment to reflect on your thoughts and feelings.
-
Chances are, what you had just thought of as food,
-
you now think of as a dead animal.
-
What you just felt was delicious, you now feel is disgusting.
-
Chances are, your experience of the meat dramatically changed.
-
Even though nothing about the meat itself actually changed.
-
So what changed?
-
Well, what changed is your perception of the meat.
-
When it comes to eating animals our perception is shaped
-
largely, if not entirely, by our culture.
-
In meat-eating cultures around the world,
-
out of over seven million animal species,
-
people tend to classify only a handful as edible.
-
All the rest are inedible and disgusting.
-
So the question is, why are we not disgusted
-
by the select species we have learned to think of as edible?
-
And why don't we ever ask why?
-
Have you ever wondered why you might eat certain animals but not others?
-
Have you ever wondered why you haven't wondered?
-
For much of my life I never wondered about my choice to eat certain animals
-
because I never even knew I had a choice.
-
No one had ever asked me if I believed in eating animals.
-
Eating animals was just a given.
-
So, I never thought about how strange it was
-
that I could pet my dog with one hand, while I ate a pork chop with the other.
-
A pork chop that had once been an animal
-
who was at least as sentient and intelligent as my dog.
-
And frankly I didn't want to think about this contradiction;
-
it was just easier not to.
-
It wasn't until 1989 that I started asking why.
-
I had been hospitalized after eating what would be my very last hamburger.
-
A burger that was contaminated with the dangerous bacteria Campylobacter.
-
After being so sick I swore off meat.
-
And then something interesting happened.
-
When I stopped eating animals I had a paradigm shift.
-
In other words, I didn't see different things,
-
I saw the same things differently.
-
Beef stew seemed no different than golden retriever stew.
-
And everywhere I turned I saw people putting the bodies of dead animals
-
into their mouth as though nothing at all were wrong.
-
So I became very curious as to how rational caring people, like myself,
-
could just stop thinking and feeling.
-
Well, two advanced degrees later, I had my answer.
-
And this is what I discovered:
-
There is an invisible belief system or ideology
-
that conditions us to eat certain animals.
-
And I named the system: Carnism.
-
We tend to assume that only vegans and vegetarians follow a belief system.
-
But when eating animals is not a necessity
-
- which is the case in much of the world today -
-
then it is a choice.
-
And choices always stem from beliefs.
-
Now carnism is a dominant ideology.
-
Meaning that it's so widespread,
-
its doctrine is seen as a given rather than a choice.
-
Eating animals is just the way things are.
-
And it is a violent ideology.
-
Meat cannot be procured without violence.
-
And egg and dairy production cause extensive harm to animals.
-
Ideologies such as carnism run counter to core human values.
-
Values such as compassion, justice and authenticity.
-
And so they need to use defense mechanisms
-
that distort our thoughts and numb our feelings
-
so that we act against our values without fully realizing what we are doing.
-
Now, the main defense of carnism is denial,
-
which is expressed largely through invisibility.
-
The ideology itself is invisible
-
and so are its victims.
-
For instance, 1.2 billion farmed animals are slaughtered globally every week.
-
So in one week more farmed animals are killed
-
than the total number of people killed in all wars throughout history.
-
But how many of these animals have you seen?
-
Where are they?
-
Approximately 98 percent of the meat, eggs and dairy we eat
-
comes from animals who were raised in factory farms.
-
Windowless sheds in remote locations
-
that are virtually impossible to obtain access to.
-
Yet, although these animals are treated as commodities,
-
they are in fact sentient, intelligent individuals
-
with lives that matter to them.
-
In a moment I'm going to show a two-minute video
-
of animal factories which can be difficult to watch.
-
So I want to remind you that my intention is simply to raise awareness.
-
So I have to make the invisible visible.
-
I've selected material that I think is sufficient to inform you,
-
without traumatizing you.
-
But if it's too difficult to watch, just close your eyes and plug your ears.
-
(Video)
-
Piglets are castrated by workers who cut into their skin
-
and rip out their testicles.
-
(Piglet squeal)
-
Next the workers chop off their tail.
-
Once pigs have reached market weight, they are sent to slaughter.
-
At the slaughterhouse pigs are knocked in the head with a steal rod,
-
hung upside down and have their throats slit.
-
(Pig squeal)
-
Improper stunning condemns many pigs
-
to having their throats slit while they are fully conscious and suffering.
-
Because male chicks don't lay eggs,
-
and do not grow quickly enough to be raised profitably for meat,
-
they are killed within hours after hatching.
-
The females have it even worse.
-
Workers use a hot blade or laser to remove part of the chicks' beaks.
-
At the slaughter plant, the birds are dumped from their crates,
-
then roughly snapped upside down
-
into moving shackles by their fragile legs.
-
They are then pulled across a blade which slices their throats
-
causing blood to pour from their necks.
-
Calves on dairy farms are dragged away from their mothers and violently killed.
-
The majority of today's dairy cows are confined on factory farms.
-
Workers subject young cows to painful mutilations and amputations.
-
Unreliable stunning practices at the slaughterhouse
-
condemn many cattle to having their throats cut,
-
their limps hacked off while still alive and conscious.
-
Massive trawling nets indiscriminately drag hundreds of tons
-
of fish and other animals along the ocean floor.
-
They are then tossed on board,
-
where the surviving fish either suffocate or are crushed to death.
-
Melanie Joy: Thank you.
-
I know it can be painful to see that.
-
Fortunately for us the hard part is over.
-
But before we move on I want to just point out
-
that this footage focuses on standard industry practices
-
including in so-called humane or bio facilities.
-
And I also want to point out that there is a gift in our pain.
-
Our pain is the mirror in which we can see the reflection of our humanity.
-
So, clearly the animals pay for our carnism.
-
But we are also victims of the system.
-
We pay for our carnism with our health,
-
as eating an animal-based diet can lead to serious disease,
-
while eating a plant-based or vegan diet can optimize health.
-
And we pay for our carnism with our hearts and with our minds,
-
with our dampened empathy and diminished objectivity.
-
But, of course, invisibility alone cannot maintain the system.
-
Hints of the truth surround us.
-
So another defense is necessary:
-
Justification.
-
And the way that we learn to justify eating animals is by learning to believe
-
that the myths of meat, eggs and dairy are the facts of meat, eggs and dairy.
-
These myths are expressed largely through what I refer to as:
-
The 3 N's of Justification.
-
Eating animals is - What do you think?
-
You're good. That. Great. Okay.
-
Normal,
-
Natural - and -
-
Necessary.
-
And haven't we heard this somewhere before?
-
Slavery is normal, natural and necessary.
-
Male dominance is normal, natural and necessary.
-
Heterosexual supremacy is normal, natural and necessary.
-
And as with other dominant violent ideologies,
-
the myths of carnism are institutionalized.
-
So carnistic bias is embedded within the very foundations of the system.
-
And when we are born into an institutionalized system, such as carnism,
-
we inevitably internalize it;
-
we learn to look at the world through the lens of carnism.
-
And carnism uses a set of defenses
-
that distort our perceptions of farmed animals.
-
For instance, carnism teaches us to see farmed animals as abstractions,
-
as lacking any individuality or personality of their own.
-
A pig is a pig and all pigs are the same.
-
And carnism blinds us to the absurdities of the system.
-
Voltaire was right.
-
If we believe absurdities, we shall commit atrocities.
-
And carnism is but one of the many atrocities,
-
one of the many violent ideologies,
-
that are an unfortunate part of the human legacy.
-
And although the experience of each set of victims
-
will always be somewhat unique, the ideologies themselves are similar,
-
the mentality that enables such violence is the same.
-
It's the mentality of domination and subjugation.
-
Of privilege and oppression.
-
It's the mentality that causes us to turn someone into something,
-
to reduce a life to a unit of production.
-
It is the might-makes-right mentality
-
that makes us feel entitled to wield complete control over the lives and deaths
-
of those with less power - just because we can.
-
And to feel justified in our actions