Subtitles section Play video
-
I'm a grandmother.
-
And as a grandmother,
-
I want to share with mothers and fathers
-
how important it is that we never hit our children,
-
including spanking.
-
My granddaughter just started kindergarten,
-
and she loves school--I mean, she loves everything about school,
-
except for this one thing: reminder sticks.
-
She tells me that if you don't do what the teacher tells you to do,
-
you have to give her a reminder stick.
-
But the trouble is you only have three, and if you give up
-
all three reminder sticks, you have to sit out recess,
-
and watch the other children play.
-
She's really worried that one day she's going to lose all three sticks.
-
She says, "Jack--he loses all three sticks every day, grandma."
-
I'm aware of how stressful this is, because she begins to play this game
-
with me, where she's the teacher taking away reminder sticks,
-
and I'm basically Jack.
-
I believe that children do well when they can,
-
and the trouble is, with some kids like Jack,
-
it's much harder to do well.
-
So you know, she takes me to school,
-
and points out all of her friends, she points to the boy over there
-
and she says, "That's Jack. He's annoying."
-
I'm like, "Is he now?"
-
I work with kids with behavior problems,
-
so I'm interested in Jack, and I watch as the teacher says,
-
"Now, boys and girls, get out your crayons,
-
we're going to make a portrait of your neighbor."
-
And all the children are coloring, and what's Jack doing?
-
Oh, he's humming and he's picking the paper off the crayons,
-
and breaking the crayons into pieces.
-
He takes this little nub of a black crayon and starts making this big fat scribble.
-
Now, the rule is you don't have to keep the portrait if you don't like it--
-
if it doesn't--if you don't like it.
-
And so, of course,
-
Jack's scribble portrait goes right into the trash can.
-
Then it's activity time, and you have to get an activity out of the cabinet.
-
So Jack's rifling through the cabinet but can't find
-
anything of interest, so he snatches the pieces
-
from the boy next to him, and sits on them.
-
And this goes on all day long.
-
I mean, you've got to love Jack.
-
I had a mother once tell me:
-
"You only love these kids because you know what to do with them,"
-
Isn't that the truth, but I didn't always know what to do with them.
-
My son was one of those wiggle worms/squeaky noise-makers,
-
that always had to sit right next to the teacher.
-
Those of us that work with young children who struggle know that often
-
they're from homes where the relationship to their parents is stressed.
-
And I wonder: what stresses Jack?
-
I read a study that asked little children what worries them most.
-
Do you know what the most common response was?
-
Being spanked.
-
Little children are worried about being hit by their parents.
-
And I'm worried, too, because spanking is a huge neurobiological stressor
-
that can have long-term negative consequences.
-
I learned about this
-
when I was studying the effects of trauma on brain development.
-
Now, there's this monumental study that studies early stress, called
-
the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study,
-
and what they're looking at, is that there's a dose-rate relationship
-
where the more early stress you have in childhood, family dysfunction,
-
the greater your risk for all sorts of health problems.
-
So you can have a score of 0 to 10,
-
and let's just say that your dad could be kind of mean
-
and sometimes physical when he was drinking,
-
and that your mother divorced him because of it.
-
So your ACE score would be probably a four or more.
-
If you have an ACE score of four or more,
-
you're two and a half times more likely to have cardiac disease,
-
you're four and a half times more likely to be chronically depressed,
-
you are five times more likely to struggle with alcoholism,
-
twelve times more likely to attempt suicide when you're a teenager,
-
and thirteen times more likely to be an IV drug user.
-
One in six middle-class Americans have an ACE score of four or more.
-
And if your ACE score is 6 or more, your life expectancy is 20 years less.
-
My ACE score is an 8.
-
The findings of this study are that adverse childhood experiences
-
are the leading cause of illness, death, and poor quality of life
-
in the United States.
-
So, what is at the root of this family dysfunction?
-
Well, it's family violence.
-
I worry: "Is Jack worried about being hit?"
-
After all, statistically speaking, either you or the person sitting next to you
-
on either side, has been physically abused by their parents as children.
-
And I don't mean spanking.
-
Domestic violence against children is over twice the rate of spousal abuse.
-
And in this country several children will die today
-
from physical abuse at the hands of their own parents.
-
And we know that physical child abuse, usually begins with physical punishment.
-
Now you might be wondering, "How does early violence lead
-
to all these long-term health problems?"
-
Well, it's because the impact of early adversity,
-
especially in the first five years of life,
-
is more like a brain injury, than a psychological one.
-
So Jack, he's not just making poor choices,
-
his brain can't regulate.
-
Self-regulation is a neurobiological capability
-
to manage arousal, both physical and emotional.
-
And children learn to self-regulate
-
by co-regulating with a calm and regulated parent.
-
So of course the most serious problem is when the parents themselves
-
are the source of the stress.
-
Now for Jack, he needs the close interaction of his teacher,
-
which, you know, kindergarten is like crowd control--twenty-five kids.
-
So instead, what he does to self-regulate
-
is he chews on erasers, he wiggles, he makes noises,
-
and he walks around the room.
-
These aren't bad behaviors. These behaviors regulate his brain.
-
If you have self-regulation problems, it's like having a dimmer switch
-
that's turned way up high. And it gets stuck,
-
and it's really hard to turn it back down.
-
So how do we help Jack?
-
The hardest thing to do is to stay calm and regulated ourselves.
-
To breathe, to remember to exhale,
-
and when Jack is too difficult, to walk away.
-
But if you can hang in there, then you mirror him,
-
like, "How awful that your artwork is in the trash can," and enjoy him,
-
because mutual enjoyment is regulating to the brain,
-
and is very nourishing to brain development.
-
So self-regulation is the foundation to further development.
-
If you have problems early on, like if Jack has trouble early on,
-
it can affect the ongoing development of his brain, so the impact
-
of early stress--sometimes you can't see it until Jack is a teenager.
-
In neuroscience, they call it the time-bomb effect.
-
An example of this is a study of over 8,000 adolescents, and they found
-
that the number of the times they're hit as children correlates directly
-
to the frequency that they will binge drink in adolescence.
-
It just goes up and up and up. It's like, Whoa!
-
You know, Jack--he went from being annoying, to reaching adolescence
-
and becoming a bully.
-
He starts binge drinking because he can't feel good.
-
He beats up his girlfriend because he can't handle being angry.
-
He attempts suicide because he can't find enough comfort in relationships.
-
It's like, what happened?
-
Well, whatever it was, it probably started before kindergarten.
-
So what's one thing we can do to help Jack?
-
We can reject all forms of domestic violence,
-
including spanking.
-
I mean, what is at the root of physical violence against children?
-
Spanking is at the root.
-
It is the belief that we think it's OK to hit them.
-
Spanking is physical violence against children.
-
Now, many of you --most of you--I maybe would say,
-
have been spanked as children, and you turned out pretty well,
-
or reasonably well, like myself.
-
And yet there's this avalanche of research, with over 93% agreement
-
that says that spanking cranks up the dial; it's related
-
to aggression, emotional problems, and physical problems.
-
So why is this?
-
Well, it's because spanking can dysregulate
-
the regulatory equipment. It can damage it.
-
So you might be thinking,
-
"Well, I spanked my child. Does that mean I damaged him?"
-
Well, I've had to ask myself that very question.
-
When my stepson was small, he was jumping off the walls,
-
mostly because he was really distressed about his parents' divorce.
-
I was 18 years old, I didn't have a clue what to do with him
-
and so, like many parents, I spanked him.
-
It didn't work, you know, thankfully I found this counselor who helped me
-
get into my son's world and feel what it was like to be him.
-
And once I was inside of his world, I never hit him again.
-
Did spanking damage him? You know, my son is a very accomplished person.
-
He's an incredible physical athlete.
-
He's one of our nation's heroes: he's served several tours in Afghanistan.
-
He's a professional firefighter. He's a loving husband and a loving father.
-
He's one of my favorite people.
-
And he has trouble with self-regulation.
-
He can get scattered, he can over-respond to threat.
-
Like, what about the time his high school teacher got in his face
-
and he was poking him in the chest, and he nearly broke his hand?
-
Even now my son has to physically exercise regularly.
-
Kind of like the adult equivalent of being a wiggle worm,
-
and needing to move.
-
And if he doesn't he gets scattered.
-
I just wish he didn't have to work so hard.
-
But the problem is: spanking is a family tradition.
-
My grandmother's mom would say: "I'm going to give you some peach tea."
-
And that meant my grandmother had to go out to a peach tree and cut off a stick
-
and take it to her mom to beat her with it.
-
You know, my father's generation, they don't believe in
-
hitting kids with sticks-- they spank them with a belt or a spoon.
-
And my generation? We're still holding on to this idea
-
that you can just smack them on the bottom with an open hand.
-
It's just watered down peach tea.
-
You know, it causes me a sickening sadness when I think about
-
that I spanked my son when he was small.
-
And I understand mothers will feel defensive,
-
because after all, "Society says it's OK." and, "I'm doing the best I can."
-
I know, I know.
-
But I think we owe it to our children to reject spanking.
-
We must stop giving stressed out parents permission to strike their children.
-
You know 50% of toddlers are hit more than three times a week.
-
Can you just imagine how you'd feel
-
if your spouse were smacking you a couple times a week?
-
Spanking is sanctioned violence against children.
-
If we were to end spanking we would change the brains of an entire generation.
-
How do we help Jack?
-
Oh, we've got to slow down.
-
We've got to get down on the floor with Jack, and touch him
-
and be present, and let go of what we need Jack to do
-
and engage in what he's actually doing.
-
Treasure his scribble portraits and mirror his frustration
-
and pick the paper off the crayons with him.
-
And let him feel just how much we really love being with him.
-
And if you see another child being hit,
-
Stand up and say, "Stop!"
-
Thank you.
-
(Applause)