Subtitles section Play video
-
So it was the fall of 1902,
-
and President Theodore Roosevelt
-
needed a little break from the White House,
-
so he took a train to Mississippi
-
to do a little black bear hunting outside of a town
-
called Smedes.
-
The first day of the hunt, they didn't see a single bear,
-
so it was a big bummer for everyone,
-
but the second day, the dogs cornered one
-
after a really long chase, but by that point,
-
the president had given up
-
and gone back to camp for lunch,
-
so his hunting guide cracked the animal
-
on the top of the head with the butt of his rifle,
-
and then tied it up to a tree
-
and started tooting away on his bugle
-
to call Roosevelt back so he could have the honor
-
of shooting it.
-
The bear was a female.
-
It was dazed, injured,
-
severely underweight, a little mangy-looking,
-
and when Roosevelt saw this animal
-
tied up to the tree,
-
he just couldn't bring himself to fire at it.
-
He felt like that would go against his code
-
as a sportsman.
-
A few days later, the scene was memorialized
-
in a political cartoon back in Washington.
-
It was called "Drawing a Line in Mississippi,"
-
and it showed Roosevelt with his gun down and his arm out,
-
sparing the bear's life,
-
and the bear was sitting on its hind legs
-
with these two big, frightened, wide eyes
-
and little ears pricked up at the top of its head.
-
It looked really helpless, like you just wanted to
-
sweep it up into your arms
-
and reassure it.
-
It wouldn't have looked familiar at the time,
-
but if you go looking for the cartoon now,
-
you recognize the animal right away:
-
It's a teddy bear.
-
And this is how the teddy bear was born.
-
Essentially, toymakers took the bear from the cartoon,
-
turned it into a plush toy, and then named it
-
after President Roosevelt -- Teddy's bear.
-
And I do feel a little ridiculous
-
that I'm up here on this stage
-
and I'm choosing to use my time
-
to tell you about a 100-year-old story
-
about the invention of a squishy kid's toy,
-
but I'd argue that the invention of the teddy bear,
-
inside that story is a more important story,
-
a story about how dramatically our ideas
-
about nature can change,
-
and also about how, on the planet right now,
-
the stories that we tell
-
are dramatically changing nature.
-
Because think about the teddy bear.
-
For us, in retrospect, it feels like an obvious fit,
-
because bears are so cute and cuddly,
-
and who wouldn't want to give one to their kids to play with,
-
but the truth is that in 1902,
-
bears weren't cute and cuddly.
-
I mean, they looked the same,
-
but no one thought of them that way.
-
In 1902, bears were monsters.
-
Bears were something that frickin' terrified kids.
-
For generations at that point,
-
the bear had been a shorthand for all the danger
-
that people were encountering on the frontier,
-
and the federal government was actually
-
systematically exterminating bears
-
and lots of other predators too,
-
like coyotes and wolves.
-
These animals, they were being demonized.
-
They were called murderers
-
because they killed people's livestock.
-
One government biologist, he explained this
-
war on animals like the bear by saying
-
that they no longer had a place
-
in our advancing civilization,
-
and so we were just clearing them out of the way.
-
In one 10-year period, close to half a million wolves
-
had been slaughtered.
-
The grizzly would soon be wiped out
-
from 95 percent of its original territory,
-
and whereas once there had been 30 million bison
-
moving across the plains, and you would have
-
these stories of trains having to stop
-
for four or five hours so that these thick,
-
living rivers of the animals could pour over the tracks,
-
now, by 1902, there were maybe less than 100 left in the wild.
-
And so what I'm saying is, the teddy bear was born
-
into the middle of this great spasm of extermination,
-
and you can see it as a sign that
-
maybe some people deep down
-
were starting to feel conflicted about all that killing.
-
America still hated the bear and feared it,
-
but all of a sudden, America also wanted
-
to give the bear a great big hug.
-
So this is something that I've been really curious about in the last few years.
-
How do we imagine animals,
-
how do we think and feel about them,
-
and how do their reputations get written
-
and then rewritten in our minds?
-
We're here living in the eye of a great storm
-
of extinction where half the species on the planet
-
could be gone by the end of the century,
-
and so why is it that we come to care about
-
some of those species and not others?
-
Well, there's a new field, a relatively new field
-
of social science that started looking at
-
these questions and trying to unpack the powerful
-
and sometimes pretty schizophrenic relationships
-
that we have to animals,
-
and I spent a lot of time looking through
-
their academic journals,
-
and all I can really say is that their findings
-
are astonishingly wide-ranging.
-
So some of my favorites include that
-
the more television a person watches in Upstate New York,
-
the more he or she is afraid
-
of being attacked by a black bear.
-
If you show a tiger to an American,
-
they're much more likely to assume that it's female
-
and not male.
-
In a study where a fake snake
-
and a fake turtle were put on the side of the road,
-
drivers hit the snake much more often than the turtle,
-
and about three percent of drivers who hit the fake animals
-
seemed to do it on purpose.
-
Women are more likely than men to get a
-
"magical feeling" when they see dolphins in the surf.
-
Sixty-eight percent of mothers with
-
"high feelings of entitlement and self-esteem"
-
identified with the dancing cats
-
in a commercial for Purina. (Laughter)
-
Americans consider lobsters
-
more important than pigeons
-
but also much, much stupider.
-
Wild turkeys are seen as only slightly more dangerous than sea otters,
-
and pandas are twice as lovable as ladybugs.
-
So some of this is physical, right?
-
We tend to sympathize more with animals that look like us,
-
and especially that resemble human babies,
-
so with big, forward-facing eyes
-
and circular faces,
-
kind of a roly-poly posture.
-
This is why, if you get a Christmas card from, like,
-
your great aunt in Minnesota,
-
there's usually a fuzzy penguin chick on it,
-
and not something like a Glacier Bay wolf spider.
-
But it's not all physical, right?
-
There's a cultural dimension to how we think about animals,
-
and we're telling stories about these animals,
-
and like all stories,
-
they are shaped by the times and the places
-
in which we're telling them.
-
So think about that moment
-
back in 1902 again where a ferocious bear
-
became a teddy bear.
-
What was the context? Well, America was urbanizing.
-
For the first time, nearly a majority of people lived in cities,
-
so there was a growing distance between us and nature.
-
There was a safe space where we could
-
reconsider the bear and romanticize it.
-
Nature could only start to seem this pure and adorable
-
because we didn't have to be afraid of it anymore.
-
And you can see that cycle playing out
-
again and again with all kinds of animals.
-
It seems like we're always stuck between
-
demonizing a species and wanting to wipe it out,
-
and then when we get very close to doing that,
-
empathizing with it as an underdog
-
and wanting to show it compassion.
-
So we exert our power,
-
but then we're unsettled
-
by how powerful we are.
-
So for example, this is one of
-
probably thousands of letters and drawings
-
that kids sent to the Bush administration,
-
begging it to protect the polar bear
-
under the Endangered Species Act,
-
and these were sent back in the mid-2000s,
-
when awareness of climate change was suddenly surging.
-
We kept seeing that image of a polar bear
-
stranded on a little ice floe
-
looking really morose.
-
I spent days looking through these files.
-
I really love them. This one's my favorite.
-
If you can see, it's a polar bear that's drowning
-
and then it's also being eaten simultaneously
-
by a lobster and a shark.
-
This one came from a kid named Fritz,
-
and he's actually got a solution to climate change.
-
He's got it all worked out to an ethanol-based solution.
-
He says, "I feel bad about the polar bears.
-
I like polar bears.
-
Everyone can use corn juice for cars. From Fritz."
-
So 200 years ago, you would have Arctic explorers
-
writing about polar bears leaping into their boats
-
and trying to devour them,
-
even if they lit the bear on fire,
-
but these kids don't see the polar bear that way,
-
and actually they don't even see the polar bear
-
the way that I did back in the '80s.
-
I mean, we thought of these animals
-
as mysterious and terrifying lords of the Arctic.
-
But look now how quickly that climate change
-
has flipped the image of the animal in our minds.
-
It's gone from that bloodthirsty man-killer
-
to this delicate, drowning victim,
-
and when you think about it, that's kind of
-
the conclusion to the story
-
that the teddy bear started telling back in 1902,
-
because back then, America had more or less
-
conquered its share of the continent.
-
We were just getting around to
-
polishing off these last wild predators.
-
Now, society's reach has expanded
-
all the way to the top of the world,
-
and it's made even these, the most remote,
-
the most powerful bears on the planet,
-
seem like adorable and blameless victims.
-
But you know, there's also a postscript to the teddy bear story
-
that not a lot of people talk about.
-
We're going to talk about it,
-
because even though it didn't really take long
-
after Roosevelt's hunt in 1902
-
for the toy to become a full-blown craze,
-
most people figured it was a fad,
-
it was a sort of silly political novelty item
-
and it would go away once the president left office,
-
and so by 1909, when Roosevelt's successor,
-
William Howard Taft,
-
was getting ready to be inaugurated,
-
the toy industry was on the hunt
-
for the next big thing.
-
They didn't do too well.
-
That January, Taft was the guest of honor
-
at a banquet in Atlanta,
-
and for days in advance,
-
the big news was the menu.
-
They were going to be serving him
-
a Southern specialty, a delicacy, really,
-
called possum and taters.
-
So you would have a whole opossum
-
roasted on a bed of sweet potatoes,
-
and then sometimes they'd leave
-
the big tail on it like a big, meaty noodle.
-
The one brought to Taft's table
-
weighed 18 pounds.
-