Subtitles section Play video
-
The Concorde could rip across the Atlantic in just over three hours, twice
-
as fast as any modern-day airliner. And you'd do it in style while sipping
-
champagne. Wait a minute... This isn't Concorde!
-
This is the only other supersonic jet to ever carry commercial passengers.
-
No, this isn't Concorde. This is the Soviet Union's Tupolev 144.
-
And yes, it looks like the Concorde but flying on this thing was nothing
-
like the Concorde. The Tu-144 was kind of like the Concord's crazy older sister.
-
She was loud, uncomfortable and a little dangerous. But the 144 story is
-
definitely worth telling. It clearly knocked off a lot of the
-
Concord's design - just look at - it but it actually did some things better, like
-
carry more passengers, it even flew faster. But ultimately the 144's story is
-
about faking it. About deceiving the world. In the 1960's the race to build a
-
supersonic passenger jet, well it was more than about just flying fast, it was
-
about asserting superiority for both the Soviets and the West. And the race to be
-
the first actually started as a three-way between the Americans with
-
their half-baked Boeing 2707, the joint British-French Concorde, and the Soviets
-
with their Tu-144. The Americans ruined their shot by tying themselves up in
-
bureaucracy and cost overruns, this put the Concorde project firmly in the lead.
-
The Soviets who had more primitive technology had a lot of catching up to
-
do, so they relied on good old Soviet ingenuity.. oh and they stole a whole
-
bunch from the Concorde program. Early on Soviet spies made out with over 90,000
-
technical documents on the Concorde and other aircraft so they caught up to the
-
Concorde program and the 144 took flight two months before Concorde
-
It's obvious the Concorde was designed around passenger experience. Journalists
-
marveled at how quiet and smooth supersonic flight was and how flight
-
attendants had no trouble chatting up passengers while they served martinis. In
-
the 144? Well caviar and champagne were also brought out, but Western journalists
-
fixated on the cramped seats, window shades that would suddenly drop without
-
being pulled, and that some of the bathrooms weren't even working. The 144's
-
more primitive engines and cooling system worked together to produce a
-
sound so loud that passengers couldn't talk to one another. Instead they had to
-
pass around handwritten notes and playing pass the note with other
-
passengers must have killed some of the opulence. Not that flying on the 144
-
was ever going to be a normal experience. The plane only ever saw passenger
-
service on a single lonely route between Moscow and Almaty, Kazakhstan. The thing
-
is the 144's engines burned so much fuel, it couldn't actually fly much
-
further, it couldn't even cross the Soviet Union. Compare that to the
-
Concorde, its route spanned continents and oceans and the Tu-144 flew only once
-
a week, even though there were seven more certified and ready for service. This
-
shows how confident Soviet leaders were in the 144. Out of 102
-
scheduled flights there were 226 mechanical failures, 80 of which were
-
serious enough to delay or canceled the flight altogether. The possibility of 144
-
crashing with passengers on board was a huge political risk. From
-
the very beginning the one full force air worthiness was in serious question.
-
It crashed in front of thousands of spectators during the 1973 Paris Air
-
Show. Then again in 1978 when a cargo version
-
went down after a fuel line rupture. And yet again in 1981 one suffered an engine
-
explosion, forcing an emergency landing. The problem was the Tu-144 had clearly
-
been rushed in its development. Getting this thing built before the Concorde was
-
more important for the Soviets than actually building it well, and the 144's
-
engineers had fewer resources and inferior technologies. But still, you
-
gotta hand it to them for actually getting it done. The Concorde's design
-
team had state-of-the-art rolls-royce olympus engines with computer-controlled
-
engine inlets that allowed for something called super
-
cruise. So once Concorde reached supersonic
-
her fuel thirsty after burners could be switched off while still maintaining
-
supersonic. Tu-144 engineers had to make do with engines that needed continuous
-
afterburners to maintain supersonic. The Concorde had a sophisticated wing
-
optimized for both supersonic and low-speed flying, the Tu-144's wing was
-
really only good for supersonic, so pilots had to land the 144
-
at higher speeds, making for brutally hard landings that even required a
-
parachute. The Soviets worked around their wing limitations by designing
-
canards, little deploy-able wings at the front of the aircraft which would
-
improve low-speed stability. But all the innovation on both sides of the Iron
-
Curtain couldn't overcome the reality that supersonic travel was just too
-
expensive. In the capitalist West you could price Concorde tickets at 5 or 6
-
times what a regular flight would cost, so the Concorde became about glitz and
-
glamour, but on the other side of the Iron Curtain things were a little bit
-
more awkward. Who exactly in the Communist Soviet Union was supposed to
-
fly aboard the Tu-144? The price of a ticket was set at just 37 rubles, not
-
much more than you'd expect to pay on a regular flight and not nearly enough to
-
cover operational costs. The 14 Concordes that entered service found a small niche
-
serving celebrities and the rich, but even with that Concorde itself was still
-
a commercial failure. The French and the British had poured billions into
-
developing it even as they knew very early on that they'd never be able to
-
sell hundreds of Concordes needed to recoup development costs. But the 144
-
without the same premium niche to fill on the other side of the Iron Curtain,
-
could only ever be used as a propaganda tool and a prestige project. The Concorde
-
would ferry passengers for 27 years up until it was retired in 2003. The Tu-144? Well it
-
was retired from regular passenger service not even a full year after it
-
started.