Subtitles section Play video
-
We all know medical school is enormously expensive, with the average medical student graduating
-
with $200,000 in student debt.
-
But did you know that over a quarter of medical school graduates have no loans at all?
-
This is the real cost of medical school.
-
Dr. Jubbal, MedSchoolInsiders.com.
-
Data from this video comes from the official 2020 AAMC Medical School Graduation Questionnaire
-
and the AAMC's reports on Economic Diversity.
-
Links in the description.
-
Here's a trend that will surprise you — the percentage of newly minted doctors graduating
-
with medical school student debt is dropping.
-
In 2014, 82.6% of students had medical school loans, trending down to 70.8% of students
-
in 2020.
-
In terms of the debt distribution, approximately 50% of students graduate with debt between
-
$100,000 and $300,000.
-
Approximately 12% graduate with $300,000 or more, 12% with less than $100,000, and 25%
-
with no debt at all.
-
The median debt for those who need to take out loans is going up, meaning the average
-
medical student taking out loans is in more debt than the average from just a few years
-
ago.
-
But the fraction of students graduating with any debt at all is decreasing.
-
In the 1980's, rates hovered around 90%, in 2014 it was 82.6%, and in 2020 we're at 72.3%.
-
So what does this mean?
-
There doesn't seem to be a simple and clear cut explanation.
-
This decreasing trend cannot simply be explained by a few medical schools offering free tuition,
-
namely NYU, Columbia, and Kaiser.
-
Nor is it likely that this can be accounted for by masses of medical students going to
-
service contracts, such as the military, to cover their medical tuition.
-
One possibility is that scholarships are increasing in number and in value, which is part of the
-
equation, but I don't think this accounts for the whole story.
-
The number of medical students receiving free money in the form of scholarships, stipends,
-
or grants has slightly increased from 61% to 63% from 2014 to 2020.
-
But the median scholarship amount has remained around $20,000 to $25,000.
-
Or perhaps it's because more students from affluent families have parents who are footing
-
the bill.
-
For some time now, more than half of matriculating medical students have parents who are in the
-
top quintile of income.
-
Explaining that finding could be a separate video in and of itself, but what's important
-
to focus on here is the trend, which seems pretty stable.
-
In the last decade, there doesn't seem to be a shift to explain the larger number of
-
students graduating without debt.
-
I'm not quite sure what to make of the data.
-
What do you think?
-
Let us know with a comment below.
-
Another interesting finding is that 2/3 of matriculating medical students have no loans
-
from their college premed years, which is surprising to say the least.
-
On a national level, 70% of college graduates take on student loans with a median of $29,000,
-
yet only 33% of first year medical students have any student debt, similarly with a median
-
of $28,000.
-
This is likely due to two main factors.
-
First, the socioeconomic status of entering medical students is skewed towards more privileged
-
backgrounds, therefore more medical students have parents who footed their college bills.
-
And second, those who were successful in getting into medical school were very strong students,
-
and were therefore more likely to secure merit based grants and scholarships, thus reducing
-
their loan burden.
-
So what does this all mean?
-
The number of graduating medical students without any student debt is increasing.
-
Maybe you're rejoicing and giving your friends high fives right about now.
-
Not so fast.
-
It's important for premeds and medical students alike to keep this data in perspective and
-
understand the nuances of what it tells us.
-
First, yes, it's great that close to 30% of freshly minted doctors have no med school
-
debt.
-
That's a substantial improvement from just a few years ago, and that's something to celebrate.
-
But understand that the median medical school debt has been increasing, meaning if you're
-
not one of the lucky 30% to graduate without any debt, your total loan burden is likely
-
going up — more specifically, up from $180,000 in 2017 to $200,000 in 2020.
-
Considering median debt amounts have been steadily rising for the last several years,
-
it's not unreasonable to expect that trend to continue, meaning if you're graduating
-
medical school in 2022 or 2025, the median student debt will likely be higher than $200,000.
-
Second, understand that when we talk about the median, that doesn't mean you'll necessarily
-
graduate with that amount.
-
You could be in substantially more or substantially less debt.
-
In 2020, 11% of graduating medical students had between $300,000 and $400,000 in medical
-
school debt, nearly 3% had between $400,000 and $500,000, and about 1% had more than half
-
a million dollars in debt.
-
Third, understand the math that goes behind student loans and paying them off.
-
Too often I hear students saying $300k in loans is no big deal, I'll pay that off in
-
one year as an orthopedic surgeon!
-
Not quite.
-
That $300,000 is going to be compounding around 6-7% per year during your residency training.
-
So while you'll be making minimum payments, the principal will actually be increasing
-
during that time.
-
Even as an orthopedic surgeon pulling in $500,000, you have to pay taxes, meaning you'll take
-
home between $289,000 and $335,000, depending on your state income tax situation.
-
And out of that amount, you'll need to pay your mortgage, utilities, health insurance,
-
your kid's daycare, car payments, car insurance, food, travel, Netflix, that new iPhone you
-
gotta have, a new sim racing rig with VR headset, and of course save for retirement.
-
And that's before making a dent in your loans.
-
Suddenly that $300k doesn't seem like such an insignificant amount, particularly when
-
you add the reality of the compounding effect working against you with your student loan
-
interest rates.
-
And while there are many aspiring orthopedic surgeons, many are unable to match because
-
it's one of the top 5 most competitive specialties.
-
If you end up going into sports medicine, internal medicine, emergency medicine, anesthesiology,
-
or something else, you'll likely be making substantially less than the average orthopod,
-
meaning it'll take much longer to pay off your loans.
-
While the default path in the United States is to attend an allopathic medical school,
-
we cannot exclude the alternate paths from the financial analysis, namely osteopathic
-
and Caribbean medical schools.
-
The American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine publishes similar data in their annual
-
survey, showing similar trends.
-
In recent years, the median osteopathic medical school debt has been increasing, from $256,000
-
to $265,000.
-
But similar to allopathic medical schools, the percentage that are in debt has been decreasing,
-
from 85% in 2017 to 83% most recently.
-
Caribbean medical schools don't have a central organization publishing this data, so it's
-
more difficult to pin down an exact number.
-
It's widely accepted, however, that students graduating from Caribbean medical schools
-
have a greater student loan burden than those from US allopathic or osteopathic medical
-
schools.
-
This isn't a surprise, considering these schools generally have substantially more costly tuition
-
and fees.
-
Depending on the article and school you're looking at, a 40-50% increase in the median
-
student loan burden for Caribbean grads, compared to US allopathic graduates, is not out of
-
the ordinary.
-
That means close to $300,000.
-
In terms of stratifying the financial cost of allopathic medical schools, osteopathic
-
medical schools, and Caribbean medical schools, US MD schools generally have the best financial
-
outlook, followed by DO schools, with Caribbean medical schools trailing.
-
We've already discussed on this channel why the finances even for US MD graduates is not
-
a clear cut win.
-
But what's concerning here isn't just that DO and Caribbean grads have more debt, but
-
also the fact that greater proportions of these graduates end up in primary care and
-
other specialties with lower average compensation.
-
And while DO graduates have a similar residency match rate to their US MD counterparts, understand
-
that a significant proportion of Caribbean medical school graduates fail to secure a
-
residency seat.
-
And without residency, they cannot practice as a board certified physician, meaning they
-
won't necessarily be making six figures per year.
-
And unfortunately, those student loans don't disappear, even if you file bankruptcy.
-
Imagine being in $300,000 in debt with no residency position, and no easy way to pay
-
off your loans.
-
I don't say this to scare you or discourage you, but to be realistic with you.
-
That's what we're about at Med School Insiders.
-
I care more about your success than your feelings, and if the numbers are making you uncomfortable,
-
I prefer you getting comfortable with reality now rather than when you're in six figures
-
of debt and unable to do anything about it.
-
While your personal situation is going to vary and I cannot speak for every student
-
watching this video, I'll provide you with some general guidelines.
-
First, make sure you truly want to go into medicine, and you understand that it's not
-
nearly as financially lucrative as pop culture has led you to believe.
-
Second, try to attend a US MD school with favorable financial aid and scholarship packages
-
over DO or Caribbean options.
-
And third, be as competitive of a student as you can be, not only because US MD schools
-
are more competitive than DO and Caribbean schools, but because if you're in a position
-
where multiple medical schools want you, you're in a position of power to leverage more favorable
-
financial aid packages.
-
If you want to know more, check out my video about how I got my medical school tuition
-
paid for through merit based scholarship, or my video about medical school prestige.
-
Much love, and I'll see you guys there.