Subtitles section Play video
-
Hello, everyone and welcome in this video
-
We're going to be discussing what happens when an engine has no oil as a demonstration will be viewing an engine with and without oil
-
running this is the exact same engine on the left and the right on the left with oil and on the right without
-
Both engines will start at the exact same time, but the video on the right was filmed 24 hours after the video on the left
-
Allowing for the engine to completely cool. This is a 212 CC. Air-cooled single-cylinder
-
Harbor freight engine I'll be keeping the oil equally classy using not just any oil but high performance
-
Premium motor oil from the grocery store my whole point for this is to [show] what even the cheapest engine oil can do
-
Versus nothing at all. It's api certified, but I wouldn't personally use this in my cars there are five points
-
We're monitoring on each engine point one is the crankcase
-
Below the level at which oil will rest
-
Point two is on top of the crankcase where they're obviously won't be any oil resting near point 3 is the air-cooled cylinder bore?
-
Point 4 is the exhaust pipe exiting the cylinder before entering the muffler and point five is the valve cover
-
This is a push Rod style valve train with overhead valves so at this point. You're wondering wait a minute
-
Why is the engine with oil so much hotter than the engine without?
-
Well, it's because I'm an idiot and left to choke clothes on the engine without oil for over two minutes even still after about seven
-
minutes the engine without oil
-
catch up
-
And exhaust temperature one thing I did want to make sure of is that there was no reason other than the oil that the engine
-
On the right would have higher temperatures than the engine on the left as a result its
-
Throttle is just slightly lower the choke was closed for far longer and it is in about one degree Cooler ambient air any temperature
-
That's higher on the right engine is purely a result of extra heat from not having lubrication
-
Now as you can see the surface of the engine is highly reflective of thermal imaging as a result
-
Calibrating for the material is challenging however if you see the frame freeze
-
This is the camera calibrating and immediately after a frozen image the temperature values will be the most accurate
-
ambient air temperature is about 15 to 16 degrees
-
Celsius though the engine was stored in my garage before filming which kept its temperature slightly cooler
-
Let's go ahead [and] fast-forward to [8] minutes where now the engines are operating at similar conditions to be honest. I was surprised
-
How trouble-free it seeing the engine was up until this point
-
it sounds fine and temperatures are no higher than the engine with oil as
-
Proof that the engine has no oil in it look at points 1 and 2 you can see a large temperature
-
Differential as the warm oil resting at the bottom is hotter than the crankcase on the right?
-
Points 1 and 2 are the same as there's only air on the other side of the crankcase for each point
-
I'll admit watching the temperatures Side-By-side
-
I was a bit disappointed how much cooler the engine without oil managed to be it goes against my intuition
-
but then again if I knew what would happen from the start there'd be no point in doing this so it's cool [to] see my
-
Best explanation is that the oil acts as a heat sink for the engine helping the engine with oil remain at higher temperatures than without
-
Without the oil the amount of energy stored internally is less than the amount of energy emitted through the air so it's cooler that said
-
Combustion temperatures are obviously a bit higher as the exhaust temperatures remains high on the right?
-
After 15 minutes the only temperature that's actually hotter for the no oil engine is the exhaust and just slightly
-
So what's my recommendation here if you want your engine to run cool?
-
You should remove all the oil no no absolutely not fun pleased with what I've seen so far
-
I decided to open up the crankcase and have a look inside
-
Here's where it became obvious permanent damage had occurred first of all look at the small amount of oil
-
But didn't [quite] make it out while draining
-
It's quite dark
-
and this is after a 15 minute run with oil and
-
15 minutes without in a brand New Engine I
-
Kept the oil which I drained out after the first test
-
And you can see it here on the left on the right the oil which remained in the drained engine
-
clearly quite dirty and actually it has quite a bit of metal content in it as you can see reflecting as I move around the
-
towel
-
Significant where of the engine occurred whereas the oil on the left is perfectly clean and clear examining further
-
I remove the connecting Rod caps from the crankshaft. This is the bearing the crank rotates on on the [left]
-
we can see a brand new cap and on the right after 30 or so minutes of running with half of that time in an
-
Engine without oil you can see the smooth shiny surface on the left
-
Versus the scored less reflective surface on the right indeed you can see the scratches on the crankshaft as well
-
I would also expect to see similar issues with the Camshaft in cylinder bore admittedly
-
this is a bit more of a scientific approach and didn't have the explosive ending many of us we're hoping for but don't fret as
-
The folks at car Throttle have driven a mercedes C180 without oil on a track until it's inevitable depth
-
I won't give it all away
-
But just know [that] the engine doesn't leave the track with all its original parts if you have any questions
-
Or comments feel free to leave them below. Thanks for watching