Subtitles section Play video
-
“Michael, welcome to the White House.”
-
This is the 40th president of the United States, Ronald Wilson Reagan, and Michael Joseph Jackson.
-
1984 Michael Jackson.
-
“For Michael Jackson brings a thrill a minute to his millions of fan.”
-
“We have quite a few young folks in the White House who all wanted me to give you
-
the same message - they said to tell Michael, please give some TLC to the PYTs.”
-
So this is not just a footnote in history.
-
It actually connects, in a weird way, to the reason that you have to be 21 in every state
-
in the United States to buy alcohol.
-
I'll show you.
-
States determine their own minimum legal drinking ages, and in 1975, they looked like this.
-
All these blue states are at 18.
-
All these green ones are 19.
-
Delaware's yellow, alone at 20.
-
These orange ones are 21, but with allowances for lower alcohol levels in stuff like beer
-
and wine.
-
And these red ones are the 21 and older states.
-
It's a complicated map.
-
Now look at the map today.
-
It's all 21 How did that change happen?
-
This story takes you to a political crossroads, and the Supreme Court, and, in a weird way,
-
to Michael Jackson shaking hands next to the president, while dressed like this.
-
But the drinking age change is ultimately a story...about roads.
-
Prohibition, the 18th amendment to the US Constitution, banned alcohol in 1920.
-
It was repealed by the 21st amendment — and after that, a lot of states settled on a drinking
-
age of 21 and older.
-
See the red here, in the late 60s?
-
Those are all 21 and older states.
-
In the 70s, the 26th amendment changed the dynamic again.
-
“That amendment, as you know, provides for the right to vote of all of our young people
-
between 18 and 21, 11 million new voters as a result of this amendment.”
-
18 year olds could be drafted to Vietnam and vote, so a lot of states decided they could
-
drink.
-
That map was short lived for one reason.
-
“And here comes the President.”
-
“Nearly 50,000 people were killed on our highways last year.
-
Now out of that statistic comes an even more chilling one.
-
Drunk drivers were involved in 25,000 of those fatalities, in addition to 750,000 injuries
-
a year.”
-
Drinking age reform advocates quickly attributed drunk driving fatalities in the blue states,
-
or 18 and older states, to earlier drinking ages.
-
People argued that teens driving across state lines to drink or purchase alcohol increased
-
drunk driving.
-
This 1983 map was still a hodgepodge, but see how more states turned green — for 19
-
— and yellow — for 20 years old?
-
That was driven partly by an awareness campaign.
-
“Thank you very much, Mr. President.”
-
Michael Jackson?
-
He was being honored for letting his music be used in anti-drunk driving PSAs.
-
“You're as good as dead.”
-
But tactics weren't limited to PR.
-
President Reagan is famous for saying: “The nine most terrifying words in the English
-
language are 'I'm from the government and I'm here to help.'”
-
That made his strategy kind of surprising.
-
“For even though drunk driving is a problem nation-wide, it can only be solved at the
-
state and local level.
-
Yet the Federal Government also has a role to play.”
-
His thinking was influenced by two main groups.
-
“Much of the credit for focusing public attention goes to the grassroots campaign
-
of organizations like MADD, Mothers Against Drunk Drivers, and RID, Remove Intoxicated
-
Drivers.”
-
Candace “Candy” Lightner founded MADD in 1980 after her daughter Cari was killed
-
by a drunk driver.
-
MADD's goals at the time included making it easier to obtain DUI convictions... and
-
raising the drinking age.
-
This direction was clear at River Dell High School in Oradell, New Jersey, where President
-
Reagan explained his unpredictable political evolution.
-
The problem: “I appointed a Presidential Commission on
-
Drunk Driving.
-
They told us that alcohol related automobile accidents are the leading cause of teenage
-
deaths in this country.”
-
The theory: “In states in which the drinking age has
-
been raised, teenage drinking fatalities have gone down significantly.
-
Here in New Jersey, you raised the drinking age to 21 in 1983, and you know what happened:
-
you had a 26% reduction in nighttime single vehicle fatalities among 19 and 20 year olds
-
in the first year alone.”
-
The dilemma: “I was delighted again because I hoped that
-
the states would, as they should, take this action themselves without federal orders or
-
interference.”
-
“It's led to a kind of crazy quilt of different state drinking laws, and that's
-
led to what's been called blood borders, with teenagers leaving their home to go the
-
nearest state with a lower drinking age.”
-
And here?
-
This is where the roads come in.
-
The Interstate Highway Act of 1956 created a network of roads largely funded by Federal
-
dollars.
-
Those roads quickly became crucial to state economies.
-
That money also became a way to bend the states to Federal priorities, even if it meant Reagan
-
had to change his typical political positions.
-
“I've decided to support legislation to withhold 5% of a state's highway funds if
-
it does not enact the 21-year-old drinking age.
-
Some may feel that my decision is at odds with my philosophical viewpoint that state
-
problems should involve state solutions, and it isn't up to a big and overwhelming government
-
in Washington to tell the states what to do.
-
And you're partly right.
-
Beyond that, there are some special cases in which overwhelming need can be dealt with
-
by prudent and limited federal action.”
-
The law passed.
-
That's Candy Lightner, celebrating.
-
“I'd like to make you an honorary mother against drunk drivers.”
-
It wasn't technically a nationwide drinking age law, but in effect — it was.
-
“We have no misgiving about this judicious use of Federal power.”
-
States quickly adopted the 21-year-old drinking age.
-
Most couldn't afford to lose federal funding for their highways.
-
Louisiana was the only state that held out at age 18 (due to a loophole, which it closed
-
in the mid 90s).
-
South Dakota challenged the law to preserve sale of low alcohol beer for 19 year olds
-
and up, and it reached the Supreme Court.
-
“You may proceed whenever you're ready.”
-
“Mr. Chief Justice and may it please the court, the issue in this case is whether or
-
not Congress may condition the receipt of highway funds upon a state having in effect
-
21-year-old drinking age.”
-
The court ruled 7-2, stating it was within Congress's powers to control spending that
-
promoted “general welfare,” argued as the reduction of youth drinking and driving
-
via the 21-year-old drinking age.
-
Did it work?
-
Most studies of studies declare “case closed” — that the higher drinking age saves lives,
-
and “reduces alcohol consumption.”
-
Skeptics, like people from the libertarian Cato Institute, claim a broader cultural change,
-
not a law, should be credited with saving lives.
-
Reagan himself kind of argued both sides, saying that, “the new minimum drinking age
-
is working,” but that “my friends, there's so much more to do, and it's not government
-
that can do it.”
-
Politically, Ronald Reagan using Federal purse strings to strong arm states is…a strange
-
pairing.
-
But beyond the politics, there's a bigger message.
-
The Federal government has used other levers to push states, but to change the drinking
-
age there was one big tool.
-
The thing that changed the country wasn't just the lines on states' edges.
-
It was the ones that run through them.
-
Alright, that's it for this road trip edition of Almanac.
-
I'm about to reveal what the theme for the next edition is gonna be, but first I want
-
to read some comments from the last video all about Route 66.
-
“People born in the 20th century: the reasons in this video.
-
2000s kids: Ka-Chow!”
-
“Kachow!”
-
So many Cars comments.
-
“That warning at 1:00 is basically TLDR; hey tourists, wild donkeys kick.”
-
Alright, that's it for this edition of Almanac.
-
In the next one, I'm gonna be looking at the big ideas that completely changed movies
-
— and had nothing to do with Hollywood.