Subtitles section Play video
-
- You may not know this,
-
but there are actually only two ways
-
that us English-speaking humans perceive time.
-
So I'm gonna ask you a question right now
-
so you can find out which one you are.
-
If I tell you that Wednesday's noon meeting
-
has been moved forward by two hours,
-
do you now think that it's at 2:00 p.m. or at 10:00 a.m.?
-
If you think the meeting is now at 2:00 p.m.,
-
this means you have the ego-moving perception of time.
-
You see yourself as moving forward through time.
-
If you think that the meeting's now at 10:00 a.m.,
-
this means you have the time-moving perception of time.
-
You think that you are stagnant
-
or static and time is flowing through you
-
as if you are standing in a stream
-
and time is the water.
-
Here's a visual representation of what I mean.
-
Ego-moving perspective, those who chose 2:00 p.m.,
-
they see themselves as moving forward through time.
-
Time-moving perspective, those who chose 10:00 a.m.,
-
see themselves as static,
-
with time moving forward through them.
-
You may think that your answer is the obvious one.
-
I obviously think the meeting is at 2:00 p.m.,
-
and I can't think of how anyone could see it any other way,
-
but when I talked to Mitch about this,
-
he thought it was 10:00 a.m., and then we realized,
-
that we see the world completely differently.
-
- So I'm here to represent all of the 10:00 a.m. people
-
who have the correct answer.
-
- And I'm here for 2:00 p.m.
-
I don't really think there's a correct,
-
right or wrong answer.
-
I'm here to just defend them.
-
I think we can be fluid with our perception of time.
-
- In English, we call these perceptions fictive motion.
-
The metaphorical movement of an object through space.
-
There technically is another way that English speakers
-
can reference time that has nothing to do with our egos,
-
and that's called the time reference point.
-
So if you think about seasons,
-
you would say winter comes before spring.
-
In that sense, time isn't perceived in reference to us.
-
Greg posted this question on TikTok,
-
and it was wild to see how split it was.
-
People unable to comprehend
-
how other people can see it the other way
-
and really seeing like 10,000 votes on 2:00 p.m.,
-
and 10,000 votes on 10:00 a.m.
-
- People were reacting
-
and even just immediately,
-
when I first saw someone say, "Oh, it's 10:00 a.m."
-
I was like, "Duh what?"
-
And I think that is fascinating,
-
it's an English language issue in many ways.
-
I don't think we're ever gonna be able to explain or agree.
-
- Metaphors are important
-
because they bridge people's language and thoughts.
-
But this all has to do with the English language.
-
The indigenous people of Aymara have a language
-
where they construe the past as in front of them
-
and the future behind them.
-
Speakers gesture to the front
-
when they're talkin' about the past
-
and to the back when they're talkin' about the future.
-
But to be honest, lots of different languages
-
perceive times in different ways
-
and maybe don't even have this issue
-
because their language is much more direct.
-
It honestly reminds me of Yanny and Laurel.
-
- [Man] Laurel.
-
- In the fact that it must be just ambiguous enough
-
and falling just in the space between it could be either/or,
-
with enough context, with maybe one more word,
-
everyone could be on the same page.
-
But because of the way it's positioned,
-
like the Yanny, Laurel, or the dress,
-
it's because of the lighting,
-
it's because of subtle differences that leave it
-
just in this weird zone,
-
that your brain has to sort of make a decision.
-
- But that's an illusion, I don't-
-
- I think this is sort of an illusion.
-
- Time is an illusion.
-
- Time is an illusion.
-
- Oh my God.
-
This research is fascinating because it makes you realize
-
that although time is objectively measured,
-
it's subjectively understood.
-
Studies have also found
-
that we actually switch our perspectives
-
depending on which event we're talking about.
-
For example, a wedding, something you're looking forward to,
-
people are more likely
-
to switch to the ego-moving perspective.
-
Whereas, if something's coming up that they dread,
-
like a job interview that they're nervous about,
-
they start to then become time-moving perspective
-
as they fear and almost wanna keep that thing
-
that keeps getting closer and closer, away from them.
-
But we still also have to grapple with the fact
-
that I might think, you might think the holidays are coming,
-
whereas I'm excited to get to the holidays.
-
Like fundamentally, I think of myself
-
as moving through time, whereas okay,
-
do you think the holidays are coming to you,
-
or do you think that you are excited to get to them?
-
- A bit of both, but I guess in general,
-
I feel that they are coming, yes.
-
- And I think that we're gonna get to them.
-
- You're trying to say that this isn't illusion
-
because there's some fundamental, underlying principle
-
that separates people- - of language.
-
- That separates people into two groups.
-
- And linguistics, yeah.
-
- But what I'm saying is that many illusions,
-
the reason, like a Yanny, Laurel or the dress,
-
where people split into two categories,
-
there probably is some underlying,
-
fundamental perception of life, or visual perception,
-
or auditory perception that puts people into two groups.
-
- Okay so you think the dissimilarity
-
is like the language version.
-
Oh my God. - I think so.
-
- When you start to ask people about which one they are,
-
you might even learn a bit about their personality
-
because they did personality tests on people
-
with different time perceptions.
-
And they found, that people who felt like
-
they had personal agency,
-
who actually felt like their life mattered,
-
were more likely to have the ego-moving perspective,
-
to see themselves again, moving forward through time.
-
Whereas other people, who through a personality test
-
were seen to be more fatalistic,
-
which means that they thought events were inevitable,
-
or pre-determined, were more likely to have
-
the time-moving perspective of time.
-
- And it feels like you're lying to me.
-
- Yeah, and it is interesting,
-
because they have done studies where people
-
have just gotten off airplanes
-
and they're more likely to have the ego-moving perspective.
-
So they've just moved viscerally through space
-
and therefore they're more likely to now say,
-
that they are moving through time.
-
It's like you can actually
-
change people's perception,
-
which does make me think of more of an illusion.
-
- So a plane is like building context around something.
-
I've just moved, so now my brain is actually thinking of it
-
in a way that context around like what time is,
-
is maybe kinda broken down.
-
- Yeah, they did the same study
-
where people were moving on a train,
-
and they were more likely to do an ego-moving perspective.
-
Wow, okay, (sighs) well I'm right.
-
(Mitch laughs)
-
Show this to your family and friends
-
and find out where they're at.
-
Find out if you perceive time
-
differently than your loved ones.
-
- Please let us know.
-
I wanna see if it actually is split evenly, 50/50.
-
- No. - Or if way more people
-
see one than the other, because to me you're lying.
-
It's a true lie.
-
Everyone must see 10:00 a.m.
-
- And I'm so curious about other people's languages.
-
I wanna know if people think
-
this is just a ridiculous concept, I don't know.
-
- Thank you all for watching
-
and allowing us to destroy your friendships
-
and your relationships
-
because you're gonna be arguing with everyone
-
for a long time.
-
- And not that it's anything that important,
-
it's just time.
-
Yeah, we'll see you soon for a new science video.
-
- Bye.