Subtitles section Play video
-
When it was ratified in 1789,
-
the U.S. Constitution didn't just institute a government by the people.
-
It provided a way for the people to alter the constitution itself.
-
And yet, of the nearly 11,000 amendments proposed in the centuries since,
-
only 27 have succeeded as of 2016.
-
So what is it that makes the Constitution so hard to change?
-
In short, its creators.
-
The founders of the United States were trying to create a unified country
-
from thirteen different colonies,
-
which needed assurance that their agreements couldn't be easily undone.
-
So here's what they decided.
-
For an amendment to even be proposed,
-
it must receive a two-thirds vote of approval
-
in both houses of Congress,
-
or a request from two-thirds of state legislatures
-
to call a national convention,
-
and that's just the first step.
-
To actually change the Constitution,
-
the amendment must be ratified by three-quarters of all states.
-
To do this, each state can either have its legislature vote on the amendment,
-
or it can hold a separate ratification convention
-
with delegates elected by voters.
-
The result of such high thresholds
-
is that, today, the American Constitution is quite static.
-
Most other democracies pass amendments every couple of years.
-
The U.S., on the other hand, hasn't passed one since 1992.
-
At this point, you may wonder how any amendments managed to pass at all.
-
The first ten, known as the Bill of Rights,
-
includes some of America's most well-known freedoms,
-
such as the freedom of speech,
-
and the right to a fair trial.
-
These were passed all at once
-
to resolve some conflicts from the original Constitutional Convention.
-
Years later, the Thirteenth Amendment, which abolished slavery,
-
as well as the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments,
-
only passed after a bloody civil war.
-
Ratifying amendments has also become harder
-
as the country has grown larger and more diverse.
-
The first ever proposed amendment,
-
a formula to assign congressional representatives,
-
was on the verge of ratification in the 1790s.
-
However, as more and more states joined the union,
-
the number needed to reach the three-quarter mark increased as well,
-
leaving it unratified to this day.
-
Today, there are many suggested amendments,
-
including outlawing the burning of the flag,
-
limiting congressional terms,
-
or even repealing the Second Amendment.
-
While many enjoy strong support, their likelihood of passing is slim.
-
Americans today are the most politically polarized since the Civil War,
-
making it nearly impossible to reach a broad consensus.
-
In fact, the late Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia
-
once calculated that due to America's representative system of government,
-
it could take as little as 2% of the total population to block an amendment.
-
Of course, the simplest solution would be to make the Constitution easier to amend
-
by lowering the thresholds required for proposal and ratification.
-
That, however, would require its own amendment.
-
Instead, historical progress has mainly come from the U.S. Supreme Court,
-
which has expanded its interpretation of existing constitutional laws
-
to keep up with the times.
-
Considering that Supreme Court justices are unelected
-
and serve for life once appointed,
-
this is far from the most democratic option.
-
Interestingly, the founders themselves may have foreseen this problem early on.
-
In a letter to James Madison,
-
Thomas Jefferson wrote that laws should expire every 19 years
-
rather than having to be changed or repealed
-
since every political process is full of obstacles
-
that distort the will of the people.
-
Although he believed
-
that the basic principles of the Constitution would endure,
-
he stressed that the Earth belongs to the living,
-
and not to the dead.