Subtitles section Play video
-
Welcome to another
-
I N T E R E S T I N G
-
episode of TwoSet Violin.
-
Today we will be reviewing...
-
That's very...
-
I N T E R E S T I N G ! ! !
-
A lot of people on the internet pointed out that certain
-
very famous and iconic soundtracks have been...
-
..."inspired"...
-
...almost copied,
-
so we thought we'd go through some of these claims.
-
Our ears should speak for itself.
-
But make sure to stick around to the end of this video,
-
because the whole reason we're doing this video
-
is our friend sent a clip that sounded
-
insanely like a very well-known classical piece
-
- that no one has talked about yet. - Oh...!
-
Make sure to stick around, and of course,
-
accent the like button,
-
legato the subscribe button.
-
Do it!
-
The first one is of course,
-
John Williams and Gustav Holst.
-
Holst composed The Planets,
-
and John Williams, Star Wars.
-
(both) Hmm...!
-
Star Wars and The Planets!
-
Isn't Star Wars about a lot of planets as well?
-
(both) Hmm!!!
-
Here's a part from the Star Wars soundtrack,
-
let's listen to it first.
-
I thought that was Holst.
-
Yeah!
-
- I can hear the similarity with Mars. - Similarity.
-
- The chords, right? - Yeah!
-
The chords and the uh...
-
...augmented fourth interval.
-
Dude, that's so obvious.
-
- I haven't heard this, I'm just shocked at how close it is. - Yeah...
-
Okay, sorry 'cause I..we...I...yeah.
-
- 'Cause we already know this piece, we played it. - Yeah.
-
Let us listen to the Mars,
-
- and then we can all collectively decide. - Okay, okay, my ears are here now.
-
I N T E R E S T I N G ! ! !
-
Alright, so,
-
- already, the fluttering string... - Strings...
-
- With the tense...build up. - It sounds the same.
-
Just changed a few notes.
-
It's like the exact same chords,
-
- it's even the same key! - Dude, it's exactly the same!
-
It's the exact same key.
-
- They didn't even bother to change... - D flat, G!
-
The only difference was...
-
Star Wars added like a random chord before...
-
In-between the semiquavers.
-
That one.
-
Yeah.
-
- It just added the... - Dude, was it like...
-
Was that to dodge copyright?
-
YouTube algorithm!
-
Don't see us!
-
By the way guys, on that note,
-
this video's gonna get copystriked, so...
-
Check out TwoSet Apparel!
-
Support us.
-
That's ironic.
-
We're gonna get copystriked by the copiers.
-
Oh, we are!
-
"We...we copy strike on behalf of Holst."
-
Send the money to Holst!
-
Next one, again!
-
John Williams.
-
What's up?
-
- Alright, so that's the famous...theme. - Yeah, we all know that.
-
No way!
-
No way!
-
Korngold did it already!
-
- I had no—I didn't know this one! - I'm actually...I don't know this one either!
-
Ohh!!!
-
It reminds me of the time my friend copied
-
my assignment in uni!
-
God, I had to redo it!
-
Wow, that was legit!
-
- Yeah! - You think the Star Wars theme would
-
- at least be original. - Guys, if you're watching this [and]
-
you're new to classical music, check out Korngold,
-
- 'cause he's also known for cinematic writing music. - Yeah.
-
His violin concerto is amazing.
-
It just blew my mind, I did not know.
-
Korngold, copystrike him!
-
Well that was SACRILEGIOUS!
-
I wanna listen to it again,
-
I just wanna appreciate how similar it was.
-
Ahh...!
-
- The first two chords are exactly the same! - It...it's not even...
-
It's the same chord, the first two chords.
-
And then the timbre and the instrumentation is exactly the same.
-
And then...
-
He changed to...
-
(both) Yeah.
-
It took up to the...
-
- ...that bit, before him to add one different note. - Yeah.
-
- Okay, the second half, he... - Okay.
-
But dude, man, that's...
-
Real sus.
-
Don't get us wrong, like I mean Star Wars,
-
- okay, it's cool, whatever, but... - Yeah.
-
Woooo!!!
-
...getting a bit close to home!
-
- You can take inspiration from different artists. - Yeah.
-
All artists are influenced by others.
-
Some people even say there's no such thing as
-
- "original thought", right? - Yeah.
-
- Taking someone's ideas and create it into your own. - Yeah.
-
And also, two people can come up
-
with the exact same ideas at the same time.
-
But where is that line?
-
'Cause this is getting a bit close!
-
This is like note by note!
-
- Yeah let's keep going, what else is there? - Let's keep going.
-
- Can I just say, I prefer Korngold's version. - Me too.
-
Korngold's got a bit more uh, sweeter...
-
I mean, to be fair,
-
- John Williams' suits the galaxy battle more, but, - He does,
-
- Korngold's so beautiful...! - but...personal taste, it's just...
-
Ahh.
-
Anyway.
-
Oh no, there's more?
-
- Okay, this one, I don't think so. - Yeah, I don't...yeah.
-
- It doesn't sound that similar to me. - It doesn't sound that similar.
-
- It has a similar contour, and a similar vibe, - Yeah.
-
- but the chords were different, - Notes, yeah.
-
- and the texture was different. - Yeah, yeah.
-
I think the biggest difference is...
-
- And... - Yeah.
-
- I think it's...yeah. - It feels very different.
-
I think that's different.
-
Also, I want to say the last...
-
That.
-
- That kind of suspension, that's not in the Tchaikovsky. - Yeah, it's not.
-
Look, I mean, Mr. Williams knew not to go there.
-
You don't mess with Tchaikovsky.
-
Tchaikovsky will come after you.
-
Bro when I saw Tchaikovsky Violin I was like,
-
(both) No way!
-
That is SACRILEGIOUS!
-
Dune Sea...
-
- This sounds very familiar. - Yeah.
-
(both) Stravinsky...!
-
It is!
-
It is Stravinsky!
-
Of course!
-
Rite of Spring!
-
Yeah, that's why I was like,
-
- "It sounds almost like Stravinsky!" - It is, it does sound familiar, I'm like "This is..."
-
Yeah, and I was like, "Stravinsky!"
-
- For me, this one was less obnoxious than the first two. - Yeah.
-
But it's getting there, like...
-
- To me, this is like a 75% similarity, - Yeah.
-
- where the others were like 95. - Dude, look at Stravinsky's face,
-
he's like, "You copy me?"
-
- Right on that one. - I wanna listen to it again.
-
The...that kind of weird...
-
...dissonant chord,
-
- is exactly the same as the Stravin... - The same.
-
Dude, that's exactly the same.
-
If he didn't copy,
-
I do think he probably was inspired from this.
-
- Oh, 100% inspired, like... - Yeah.
-
- Okay, okay, 99.9%. Like just in case. - 99.9. We don't know.
-
Maybe he just thought of...
-
Maybe he goes....
-
He's like, "Damn, that was so good.
-
No one could ever do that."
-
Think classical musicians are not there?
-
We are here!
-
Did they like, have to pay royalty fees?
-
Because Stravinsky and Korngold
-
- aren't in public domain yet. - It's not! They're not,
-
so it hasn't [been] hundred years yet.
-
Well, I'm not a lawyer.
-
- Yeah...yeah. - I'm just a musician sharing my thoughts.
-
The pieces you heard are almost the exact same,
-
listen again, they're both being played...
-
- Hang on, did they just...did he just layer it? - They just let us put them...
-
- Together. - Yeah.
-
You know, if you played that to me,
-
I would think it's Stravinsky, straight up.
-
As a classical musician,
-
it's...hands-down Stravinsky.
-
- That's crazy. - Dude, I'm conflicted right now.
-
Like I'm really confused.
-
Okay, another one.
-
Of course, the Jaws theme.
-
- Yeah. I feel like this one is... - I mean, yeah.
-
- You just feel like, "Ehh..." - ...passable.
-
- You're just taking a motif, and an idea. - Yeah, mm-hmm.
-
But you're not copying.
-
This is fine.
-
- Alright, so that's Mars, by Holst. - Yeah.
-
Yeah...
-
Okay, yeah, I mean...
-
This is similar, but...
-
- It's so short it's passable. - Yeah.
-
But that is a very recognisable motif though.
-
I know it was meant to be
-
film music versus classical music,
-
but it somehow ended up being primarily Star Wars...
-
- Yeah...! Whoopsies! - ...versus classical music.
-
But, on that note,
-
time for our bonus video.
-
Just happens to be from...
-
...Star Wars.
-
But the animated series, the Clone Wars.
-
Are you ready for some
-
I N T E R E S T I N G ?
-
Are you alright?
-
Without Ahsoka's foresight,
-
I fear things would have gone quite differently.
-
Served you well, your visions have, young Padawan.
-
Thank you, Master Yoda.
-
But,
-
we still don't know who's really behind this.
-
Hmm.
-
Concentrate.
-
Remember.
-
What do you see?
-
I see...
-
...shapes.
-
Large...
-
...devouring.
-
The strings part.
-
I hear...
-
...laughter.
-
Did you guys hear that?
-
- Yeah...yeah. - Conveniently the voiceover came on top.
-
But that music...
-
...sounds like something we've played at the
-
Conservatory Orchestra together.
-
If you're a classical musician,
-
[you] probably would notice.
-
Epic symphony.
-
Yeah.
-
The thing that confused us so much was
-
the second half of that clip sounded so exactly similar,
-
that I thought,
-
"Maybe they just used the actual Rachmaninoff
-
in the soundtrack."
-
But nowhere on the internet do they say
-
they used Rachmaninoff 2 in the soundtrack.
-
And more suspicious, is before that...
-
The previous bit shares similar harmonies
-
- and textures, but it's clearly a different melody. - Yeah.
-
So it's almost as if
-
they were trying to compose something
-
that sounded like Rachmaninoff,
-
but they kind of just gave up
-
- and just copy and pasted. - It's like they kept the chords
-
and just inverted like the melody.
-
- Yeah. - Flipped it around a bit.
-
It's so small that no one really picked this up,