Subtitles section Play video
-
Ling Ling, be with me!
-
Mm, we're definitely gonna need Ling Ling's hearing skill
-
- for today's episode because we have... - Yes.
-
the ultimate challenge of a classical connoisseur.
-
We will be guessing...
-
the violinist just by the recording.
-
So this...
-
will be a test in how well we understand
-
the playing styles and interpretations of great violinists.
-
We have 20 audio files.
-
Over here, we have a list.
-
So we know what we're listening to,
-
otherwise it will be very very difficult.
-
Yeah, see which one we can guess, right?
-
And the consequences of losing this challenge...
-
is posting on TwoSet Violin Instagram, admitting...
-
you love the viola.
-
So "hey guys, I had a change of mind."
-
"I really love the viola. "
-
"I think I'll become a violist."
-
- Like betraying your own kind. - I know.
-
First one.
-
Oh, I know this.
-
Ah yeah, I know.
-
- Okay, answer reveal? - Yeah.
-
(both) 3, 2, 1!
-
(both) Gitlis. Yeah!
-
- Yeah! Ivry Gitlis, Bach Chaconne. - Yeah, woo!
-
He's very like, old school, and just very... kinda rough.
-
It's rough, the way he breaks the chord.
-
- Yeah. - Oh man, that's awesome.
-
-That's massive! - Ooh...
-
Whoa...
-
Who is this?
-
Dude, I don't know!
-
Dude, this is insane!
-
Okay, okay.
-
Oh, I don't know.
-
I'm doubting myself.
-
It's very aggressive style of playing for sure.
-
Oh... okay.
-
Oh, I don't know.
-
oOohH..
-
Yeah, okay.
-
3, 2, 1.
-
Really?!
-
What do you think?
-
I thought Midori,
-
- but then I changed my mind last second. - Ohh... Let's see, let's see.
-
The way he speeds the bow up at the end,
-
- Oh, that's a Vengerov thing! - that's something Vengerov does.
-
You can imagine...
-
Damn! Okay, that's wrong.
-
So I'll just put a cross next to it.
-
Number 3.
-
Oh!
-
Alright.
-
Okay.
-
- Yeah. - We got it.
-
3, 2, 1.
-
Podger, yeah.
-
Yeah, yeah, yeah, okay.
-
Who is Rachel Podger?
-
Alright, number 4.
-
It's so good.
-
Okay.
-
Is this the 4th, dude?
-
Yes.
-
Okay.
-
Okay, I think it's- I think I know.
-
I don't know. It's risky.
-
I feel like it's an old... violinist.
-
You know, I don't know.
-
But mine, I'm just gonna go with my gut feeling.
-
3, 2, 1.
-
Both are very good violinists though.
-
S**t! I thought Szryeng!
-
- Szeryng! So silky and- - I was like Szeryng or Oistrakh.
-
We-
-
We're not worthy of hardness.
-
This is so offensive.
-
Okay.
-
3, 2, 1.
-
(both) Kavakos.
-
Yeah...
-
- If we had heard that earlier... - Yeah, would've...
-
Yeah.
-
Oh.
-
Whoa, it sounds very old.
-
Yeah.
-
Are you looking at all the grey photos?
-
- Do you want to discuss? - I'm thinking Heifetz,
-
- Yeah, I was thinking- - but I don't wanna call it wrong
-
because that's a big bomber.
-
- Yeah, cos it's so insulting to guess Heifetz wrong. - Yeah.
-
My initial thought was Heifetz, then Menuhin, then Stern.
-
- Yes, exactly! - Yeah, yeah!
-
Stern is too...
-
Nah, okay, Heifetz.
-
Heifetz.
-
Mutual discussion about that one. 3, 2, 1!
-
IT WAS STERN!!
-
Stern!
-
Stern...
-
Part of me was just saying
-
"it just might be Stern."
-
It sounded sticky.
-
- Yeah, he never leaves the- - It means Stern sounds sticky.
-
No, the pieces are also...
-
they trick you.
-
- Cos you associate Wieniawski with Heifetz. - Exactly!
-
- You don't associate Wieniawski with Stern. - Oh, okay. Oh...
-
Alright, alright, I see what game we're playing now.
-
Let's do this. Next one.
-
You know, it's so bad that part of me thought
-
"it sounded just a little bit not good enough for Heifetz."
-
- I was thinking that as well. - You thought that as well?
-
That's why I considered.
-
- I thought Heifetz would've sounded a bit more clean. - Because it wasn't as clear.
-
- Yeah, clean, clean. - It sounded- yeah...
-
We should've trusted our instincts!
-
Whoa, this is hard. This is hard.
-
Very hard.
-
Alright, I think I know.
-
I mean I don't know, but I've just given up.
-
- Yeah, you've just given up! - Yeah. This is so hard to tell.
-
That was a very just kinda standard,
-
- tasteful interpretation. - But I'm trying to go by articulation,
-
the sound, the phrasing.
-
Would Ray play it like that?
-
Hahahahahaha!!
-
There's Gidon Kremer as well.
-
Ooh...
-
He's a Bach guy...
-
Oh, look at the way Perlman's looking at you.
-
Ahahaha, yeah!
-
It could be him as well, he's like
-
"Hehe!"
-
"It's me all along."
-
Alright, what does the playing style remind you?
-
Ooh...
-
- Yeah, I thought Hilary. I think Hilary. - I think Hilary Hahn.
-
- I think Hilary. - Yeah, okay.
-
(both) YEAH!!
-
I got Hilary, yes!
-
Oh, we didn't insult Hilary.
-
Thank you.
-
Sounds like a girl to me.
-
Yeah, I think so! I'm thinking the same thing!
-
I thought Anne-Sophie Mutter first. I was like m...
-
Dude...
-
- Should be practicing, not doing this game. - I know.
-
It does sound feminine though.
-
It sounds feminine.
-
- So Midori, Janine, or Anne-Sophie. - Yeah.
-
It's very, just "bam!" Going through, right?
-
It's got a bit of Janine Jansen.
-
- Fi- like the... sizzle. - The fire, right?
-
That's what I thought.
-
- The last note reminds me of Anne-Sophie Mutter. - Yes!
-
- Alright, Anne-Sophie Mutter. Stop changing. - Anne-Sophie... Anne-Sophie!
-
YES!!
-
YES! YES!
-
- The last note. Woo!! - Only-
-
- Only Anne-Sophie would go... - Yeah... would do that.
-
- "BAM" on such a high note. - She's like...
-
- I don't really listen to Vivaldi, so I would- - No, me neither.
-
But look at Itzhak Perlman's face.
-
Looking at you.
-
I think I know who it is.
-
Alright.
-
3, 2, 1.
-
I say Gidon Kremer.
-
I thought Gidon Kremer or Joshua Bell, those two.
-
YES!! WOOHOOoOooOh!
-
I thought Kremer, but then the light bow strokes
-
- reminded me of Joshua Bell. - Woohoo!
-
Oh yeah- I mean, Joshua Bell was close.
-
No!
-
I lost my lead!
-
Yeah! We're even now.
-
Yeah, yeah, yeah...
-
I think I know.
-
Yeah, I know.
-
I got it.
-
Dude, it's so fast.
-
Heifetz.
-
Yeah, Heifetz.
-
- Only Heifetz plays it that fast... - Yeah.
-
with every note in tune, and freaking perfect.
-
He's the original 15-notes-a-second, but musical, and-
-
- And every accuracy. - accurate.
-
Yeah, the OG!
-
There's two in my mind.
-
Oh... this is hard.
-
I've got...
-
- two on my mind. - Yep.
-
Lock yours in first?
-
Yeah, I've got it, yeah.
-
Okay, what were the two on your mind?
-
Ray chen,
-
Or?
-
and Joshua Bell.
-
I thought Ray or Janine. I chose Ray.
-
I chose Ray as well.
-
Oh...
-
I thought Ray or Janine!
-
Sorry, Janine- just kidding!
-
We suck!
-
- At least we're on the same mark. - Yeah, okay.
-
It's very...
-
gentle approach there.
-
Feels like they're playing in the upper half of the bow a lot.
-
Mm!
-
I've made my bet.
-
I've placed my bet.
-
Give me a second.
-
But I'm completely guessing.
-
It's just- It was like intuition.
-
Really?
-
I'm probably completely wrong.
-
Alright, me too.
-
Oh, it's gonna be so wrong.
-
No, dude, so off, nah.
-
This is the biggest guess of my life.
-
Alright.
-
Oowhoa!
-
Ah, I forgot about him!
-
I wrote James Ehnes.
-
Yup.
-
Yeah, okay.
-
- I thought him. I thought him. - I thought him, but you said gentle,
-
- so I was like "Nah... Zukerman's not gentle." - Yeah. Yeah.
-
Ahh! I thought him!
-
I thought him as well. I thought him-
-
I thought- I-
-
Yeah.
-
Zukerman, I thought you like to catch the string!
-
And who would do that?
-
Alright, done.
-
- Done? - Yeah.
-
What the hell?
-
- Who do you think? - Perlman.
-
Oh...
-
I thought Ray.
-
I thought Ray as well, but-
-
I thought Joshua Bell as well!
-
I thought Joshua Bell or Ray.
-
I swear I thought Joshua Bell or Ray.
-
Dude, we suck!
-
What?
-
This doesn't sound like a very professional recording though.
-
I might- I think I know.
-
Yeah, okay.
-
Alright, I'm gonna take a guess.
-
- I said Menuhin. - Same.
-
Imagine it's Oistrakh.
-
I thought so. I thought so.
-
- Me too. The D string, the D... - I thought so.
-
That D sounds Oistrakh, right?
-
Wow, okay, we're both sucking.
-
Let's keep going.
-
Okay, okay.
-
I don't know! That was so quick!