Subtitles section Play video
-
- [Jaden] This parking lot in California
-
is piling up with empty Boeing and Airbus aircraft,
-
planes that, until recently,
-
were busy flying people to places,
-
and then suddenly people stopped flying.
-
Daily traffic is down some 80% from its peak in 2019.
-
Airlines are fighting for survival
-
as airport activity has fallen to near zero.
-
Meanwhile, industry giants, Boeing and Airbus,
-
have seen order cancellations
-
and furloughed or laid off staff.
-
- I don't believe the industry
-
has ever seen anything like this,
-
and because of that, there's no one you can turn to.
-
We're literally all learning as we go.
-
- [Jaden] Boeing, already weakened by the 737 MAX crisis,
-
saw its stock drop more than 70% in February and March
-
while Airbus' fell about 65% in the same period.
-
The plane makers employ hundreds of thousands of people
-
in several countries,
-
and they're major economic players,
-
often at the center of global politics.
-
- Both those companies are in many ways too big to fail.
-
- [David] Nobody has an interest in retaining
-
government equity in their company.
-
- We can recover from this crisis.
-
- So as the coronavirus pandemic shakes up the industry,
-
we wanted to know,
-
what will it take for Boeing and Airbus
-
to survive this unprecedented crisis,
-
and what does it mean for the future of aviation?
-
- Before coronavirus,
-
Boeing was already struggling to get regulator approval
-
to return its 737 Max to the skies,
-
as the jet was grounded after two deadly accidents
-
linked to a faulty flight control system.
-
In another blow, Boeing recently dropped
-
its 4.2 billion dollar bid to team up
-
with Brazilian jet maker, Embraer,
-
which was supposed to transform the aviation industry,
-
and Airbus had already overtaken Boeing
-
as the world's top plane maker in terms of deliveries.
-
- We think our capacity to compete
-
and be strong on the long term is intact, if not improved.
-
- [Jaden] I wanted to get a better idea
-
of how well-positioned the plane makers are
-
to withstand this crisis
-
so I called Addison Schonland, a partner at AirInsight.
-
- It appears as we sit here right now,
-
there's an advantage to Airbus
-
given its particular tools available to airlines.
-
Boeing is at a disadvantage now
-
because of the MAX grounding
-
and the incompletion of the Boeing/Brazil project.
-
- [Jaden] Now, the coronavirus pandemic
-
has forced the companies to draft survival plans.
-
- We will be suspending all travel
-
from Europe to the United States for the next 30 days.
-
- [Jaden] Air passenger volumes fell more than 90%
-
sending airlines into crisis.
-
In February, major airlines like Delta and United
-
started to cut their losses by canceling some flights.
-
Only weeks later, the collapse in air travel
-
had already trickled down to Boeing and Airbus,
-
with many orders being postponed or canceled.
-
In the first three months of 2020,
-
Boeing saw customers cancel 196 of its aircraft orders.
-
Airbus had 66 cancellations
-
and said almost all of its customers have approached it
-
to discuss deferring or canceling orders.
-
- We're accustomed to bad years like 9/11
-
or the SARS year, Gulf War One,
-
but at the end of the day this is just an unprecedented
-
freezing up of the end user market.
-
- Even in this crisis, both Boeing and Airbus
-
have a key customer they can count on, governments.
-
They're some of the world's biggest defense contractors,
-
with the U.S. Navy even ordering new planes
-
from Boeing amid the pandemic.
-
- The ultimate safe haven right now is defense,
-
particularly U.S. defense programs.
-
- [Jaden] Through their history,
-
Boeing and Airbus have become ingrained
-
in defense, industrial development, and geopolitics.
-
Boeing has worked with the U.S. government
-
to build military planes since World War I,
-
and Airbus' very inception
-
is deeply rooted in European politics,
-
as it was formed as an example of how European countries
-
and companies are stronger when they come together.
-
- Airbus doesn't have a hundred years of history,
-
but if you look at what Airbus consists of,
-
all those European aerospace companies
-
that came together that were also very old,
-
brought with them amazing amount of knowledge.
-
- Boeing and Airbus both spend millions of dollars
-
on lobbying every year.
-
They've criticized each other
-
for getting unfair government subsidies,
-
and they're both massive employers
-
with roughly 161,000 and 134,000 employees respectively,
-
so a major hit to one of their bottom lines
-
means a potential hit to a lot
-
of American and European jobs.
-
When the U.S. government was crafting
-
its two trillion dollar coronavirus stimulus package,
-
a big part of the bailout was focused
-
on the aviation industry.
-
The bill included 17 billion dollars
-
for companies deemed essential to national security,
-
which could potentially include Boeing.
-
Here's the thing, as of early May,
-
some airlines had applied for government aid,
-
but Boeing hadn't,
-
and the idea of Boeing getting bailed out
-
by taxpayer money is sensitive.
-
- You can imagine that those companies,
-
the management is going to fight tooth and nail
-
to prevent the government saying,
-
"Here's 60 billion dollars.
-
"By the way, here's the warrants
-
"and here's the stuff that we're taking.
-
"We own you."
-
- [Jaden] Any loans offered by the government
-
would likely come with strings attached,
-
like limiting stock buybacks, layoffs,
-
and giving the U.S. government a stake in the company,
-
something Boeing CEO suggested he wouldn't be open to.
-
- [David] I don't have a need for an equity stake.
-
If they force it, we just looked at all the other options,
-
and we've got plenty of them.
-
- So what are the options for Boeing and Airbus
-
to keep the cash flowing?
-
In May, Boeing raised 25 billion dollars
-
from private investors and said it didn't expect
-
to need anymore funds, including government aid.
-
But Boeing has already suffered a number of new setbacks.
-
It's now facing civil and criminal scrutiny
-
over the 737 MAX crisis.
-
It suspended its dividend,
-
is offering staff buyout packages,
-
and plans to cut its workforce by 10% this year.
-
- Airbus and the border (mumbles) sector,
-
we emerge from this difficult period eventually.
-
- [Jaden] Airbus also needs to cut spending,
-
but after the pandemic, analysts expect the market
-
for smaller planes to grow
-
because domestic travel is expected to bounce back first,
-
and Airbus can offer its direct competitor to the 737 MAX,
-
its best-selling A320 family.
-
That includes the A321LR, a single-aisle plane
-
that's capable of transatlantic routes.
-
- Boeing really doesn't have a competitor to that jet.
-
- [Jaden] And both companies will likely face
-
a big supply chain issue.
-
Boeing and Airbus rely on a massive network
-
of smaller companies that are struggling to survive.
-
- The million parts that you see flying in close formation
-
that is actually an airplane,
-
all those parts come from all kinds of places
-
around the globe.
-
Some of these places,
-
the companies that make these small parts,
-
are literally family-owned, they're tiny.
-
They don't have the resources
-
if the system is shaken up like this.
-
How do you protect them?
-
- [Jaden] Analysts say it could potentially
-
take several years before the aviation industry recovers,
-
but whenever people will need new planes,
-
they'll likely come from Boeing or Airbus.
-
Not that there are many alternatives.
-
The duopoly makes up about 99%
-
of all large commercial plane orders,
-
with China's state-run plane maker
-
believed to be 10 to 20 years out
-
from becoming a real competitor.
-
- Will the companies be different
-
at the end of this pandemic?
-
Probably, the longer it goes,
-
the more that there will be some kind of structural change,
-
but neither of those companies,
-
based where they are, are dispensable,
-
so I think that whatever happens, we come through this,
-
and they may be different,
-
but they will remain the two top dogs in that industry.
-
(light music)